If it's any help I've tried the lower cost for more work scenario. Seemed that other DJ companies were undercutting me so I figured two can play that game...
This was one of those times when I should have considered the consequences of my actions.
To be certain, I got more shows, many of which were ball-busting loads that most DJs wouldn't have touched. Out in the hot sun, up on somebody's deck or patio. Up stairs in cheap, ratty, rented venues that I never knew existed. Got rained on, struggled with icy sidewalks etc.
Was doing two, three or more shows per weekend. Some Saturdays I left one show to drive to another.
Come the end of the month I was no further ahead as far as the bank balance went. I was beating myself to death, putting more miles on the truck and cleaning mud and dirt off the speaker cabs... but I had no more gross income to show for it. My overhead had increased due to the additional work.
That had to come to a stop. The phone was still ringing but I couldn't keep saying "Yes" every time a prospect called. I went back to stating my regular rate and the backbreaking shows receded to a trickle.
On the other hand, the upscale shows stayed steady. At the end of the month the bank balance hadn't suffered, even though net income had dropped slightly.
I feel very fortunate in that I "DJ" for the mere enjoyment of it.......My hats off to those who are doing this for a living.....it's tough.
One thing I have done when pricing a job is to respect my competitors in my area, and I maintain rates commensurate with the rates in my area.

