Review: The Best Wedding Reception ... Ever!

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
G

Guest

Guest
Review of – The Best Wedding reception … Ever! By Peter Merry
Reviewer – Tom Ohlendorf, President, Good Knight Entertainment

Honestly, I planned to can this book and pick all kinds of fault with it. While a majority of it would put it on my list to recommend to every bride and groom I speak to, his treatment of part-time DJs puts a completely negative spin on the book for me. Take out that section, and yes, I’d buy a whole case and give them to every bride.

On the positive side, Peter used his experiences over the years he has been performing at weddings to illustrate many points in this book and I can empathize with many of them from my own personal experience.

As I was going through the book, I highlighted some sections and made many notes in the margins. In the introduction, one point I noted as important was the following statement by Peter, “Some of these ideas may seem inappropriate for your plans, while others may leap off the page and connect with your innermost feelings about how you have envisioned your reception. Keep this in mind as you read on, because we all have different personalities, styles, and tastes. What works for you may not be right for somebody else. But when it comes to creating your wedding reception, there are no more rules. Follow your heart and choose the ideas that inspire you.” I marked this as very important because it should set the tone for the entire book; that is, this is a set of examples and suggestions. It is not the be all and end all for developing your reception and if you have heard that it is through the rumor mills, put that idea aside.

Peter makes the analogy that developing a wedding is like developing a movie; it is a production event. He follows from post production, through execution, to the final cut; giving tips and examples throughout. He also makes use of sidebars that convey a brief overview of the information on the page so that the reader can come back to use it as a quick reference. And finally, the pictures included are well chosen to also convey the message of the page or section.

Part one is all about the post production; that is, choosing the time, place and cast.

Chapter one is all about the timing; day of the week and time of day. Other impacts on the timing, such as holidays and sporting events are brought up in addition duration and how you may want your reception to end. I am confident that there are many brides out there that do not consider the impact of a sporting event on their reception or even how they want it to end.

Chapter two is all about the money. One of the sidebar statements here is “Investing more in the quality of entertainment that you desire fir your reception is not a risk, but rather an investment in the overall success of your reception”. As a DJ that primarily entertains at wedding, I couldn’t agree more. Peter also says, “Quality entertainment requires professionalism, artistry, unique talent and skill, so don’t be fooled into thinking that someone who will ‘just push play’ on a CD player can make your reception fun and entertaining”; another point I wholeheartedly agree with. And, Peter describes all of the functions the “entertainment’ is supposed to provide at the wedding reception.

Peter backs all of this up with results from surveys, quotes from seminars and articles by Mark Ferrell, and a real life example of a unique idea.

Peter’s main point in this chapter is that the three main elements of a winning strategy are location, photographer, and entertainment; put the majority of your funds with these, survey what you have left, and work a strict budget for the rest from there.

In chapter three Peter links picking a coordinator to finding a movie producer. Here he is talking about the role a coordinator would play and kind of missed the mark on the analogy. The movie producer is more on the financial end and, while they play a key role in the film, what should have really been used in the analogy is the director. Come on Peter, you’re in movie land, you should know this stuff. The producer is the bride or the parents; whoever is funding the wedding.

Regardless, the chapter is all about determining how the wedding should be coordinated; by the bride, by a family friend, or by a professional coordinator. He goes into the pros and cons of each.

I particularly like the points he made about using a family member or a friend. I had a bad experience with a family member that had never done this before and would caution most brides that want to use a friend or family member with no experience.

Another valid point Peter makes is about the coordinator allowing your entertainment to give input regarding the agenda. This is a very valid point. In another situation I had the coordinator did not want me to attend the meeting to set the agenda. When the bride asked why, the coordinator said, “He’s just the DJ. He’s only there to play music. Nothing more.” The bride fired the coordinator on the spot.

Chapter four is location, location, location. Peter first talks about the ceremony location and then the reception location. I can’t argue with any of the points Peter makes here. I hear about some these things from every bride I work with.

Chapter five is all about the setting; how the environment is set, how much room there is, ambiance, centerpieces, and such. In discussing centerpieces,

Peter states the obvious that may not be too obvious when planning is first initiated; that is, if you can’t see the other guests around the table, the centerpiece is too big and that limits the guest’s interaction with each other and may block their view of the rest of the reception. Honestly, when my wife and I planned our wedding back in 1994, we didn’t think of this important fact.

Peter goes into practical suggestions here, not details. The details are left for the other books that are specific to decorating your wedding. It is these types of practicalities that have caused me to consider recommending this book to my brides.

You also have to check out the picture of Peter and the Bride and Groom on page 39. Just look at that smile and wonder where his eyes were before and after that shot.

Chapter six is about the photographer and videographer. Again, Peter shows his experience with his practical suggestions. As a DJ I’ve lived this before and know exactly where he is coming from.

Chapter seven is all about the talent; the officiant, the ceremony singers and instrumentation, the band, the DJ, and, yes, the IPOD.

When talking about the officiant, practical advice is given. I really wish I had something like this when my wife and I tied the knot.

Again, good and practical tips are given on the “minstrels” for the ceremony.

Bravo and props to Peter on this statement; “The title of this chapter is ‘Auditioning For Talent’ and talent is the one component Apple will never be able to program into their IPods.” The talent and skill to play the right music at time is a human factor that the IPod just does not have. The ability to guide and direct the celebration while keeping the guests informed and involved is something an IPod will never be able to do. Additionally, the story of a failed IPod wedding highlights why this media just does not work.

Peter next talks about bands. There are many good points any bride should consider in this section if they are considering a band. Even though most of Peter’s experience is on the DJ side, he does not bash bands; he only gives logical pointers on what to look for.

This next section on the DJ/MC was the one I was most interested in reading. It took much to keep me from looking ahead to this section. This is where Peter bashes part-timers. I really don’t care how he cares to couch it, he is still bashing part-timers. He is correct in his statistics about the majority of DJs being in the part-time category; however, he is way off base in his assessment of the time most part-timers put in, skill levels, or performance incentives. I feel very insulted by this section and am considering trashing this book because of it. Basically, his description of “average pricing” and his lumping of part-timers and hobbyists all into one group essentially calls all of us that prefer to deliver our services on the weekends only BOTTOM FEEDERS! There it is folks, if you are a part-time DJ, Peter Merry has labeled you as a bottom feeder.

What he doesn’t consider is that there truly are people out there that cannot afford $1,200, $1,000, or event $700 to spend on a DJ/MC for their wedding. What are these people supposed to do; Boom Box, IPod, the sound of silence? Many part-timers fill that niche and can deliver a great service for the price they charge.

Peter needs to get himself out into the real world. He wouldn’t survive six months in some of the markets in this country.

My review of this book is over. The value I did find in it to this point is now gone. I don’t consider that I’ve wasted $24.95, I consider that I’ve saved other DJs the time and expense of picking up this garbage.
 
Matt:

That wasn't the last chapter. It was less than halfway through. That's the point where I got too pissed off to continue.
 
I am definitely planning on reading this someday and I'm sure it will be helpful.

I am aware of Peter's point of view on part timers and I understand why he feels that way.

You've got to stand for what you believe in, but there is always something to be said for being gracious as you do it.

Good example: "I believe a full-time DJ is liable to be better prepared to provide you with the immaculate service that you deserve. Because of this, I encourage brides to hire full-time DJ's and I encourage serious DJ's to commit full-time."

Bad examples: "Don't hire a part-time DJ." "Part time DJ's are NOT professional." "Being a true professional DJ means committing to the business FULL TIME, and if you aren't able to or don't you are NOT professional."

I've not read Peter's book yet, but I hope he was able to say this without being a jerk about it.

Has anyone ever seen a debate between an atheist and a Christian?

"This guy is a douche, and GOD DOESN'T EXIST!"

"THIS guy is a douche, and GOD DOES EXIST!"

Yeah, you're both intolerant jerks and I'm not listening to anything either of you says.
 
I would attempt to explain what PM said reguarding the pt/ft debate on another chat board.

But the last time I mentioned PM the thread was closed, I was told I had an agenda, and was being a tattle tale reporting the ongoings of this board to other people.

Oh, well.

If one chooses to do searching, some clairification and answers can be had.

Then again, a phone call or email to "anyone" that one has issues with, usually ends up in a better understanding on each persons perspective.

sigh.
 
I would attempt to explain what PM said reguarding the pt/ft debate on another chat board.

Kinda late considering the book's already in print. :sqfrown:
 
Then everybody who is a PT DJ is a 800px-Channelcat.jpg
and James Brown is still dead :D .
 
Goodnight, you spend about two dozen paragraphs giving neutral to very positive reviews on the book and about four giving it a negative review. And looks like on the one chapter in question...and that equals to the book being "garbage?"

:sqconfused: :sqconfused: :sqconfused: :sqconfused:
 
Goodnight, you spend about two dozen paragraphs giving neutral to very positive reviews on the book and about four giving it a negative review. And looks like on the one chapter in question...and that equals to the book being "garbage?"

:sqconfused: :sqconfused: :sqconfused: :sqconfused:

If I can't hand it to a bride for her use, it is garbage. That section puts this book in that category.
 
Ah, but you ARE admitting this book has value......LOL

I'm going to hold on to it. I plan to put everything he has in my own words, delete the stuff about f/t vs. p/t and pricing, and come up with something useful I can hand to brides.
 
If I can't hand it to a bride for her use, it is garbage. That section puts this book in that category.

If you are a PT DJ, giving this to a prospective bride could actually cost you the job. If the brides question your ability to provide excellent entertainment just on the basis of your status it's a loosing situation for any part timer no matter how good you are.

That's what I think tarnishes the book. There is a ton of information for the bride and also for DJ's to improve what they offer which will result in polishing rough areas in your presentation at the wedding.

I don't think bad mouthing part timers is going to accomplish anything except building up more hate in peoples minds. In my field of work a large percentage of people have "elitist" attitudes thinking they are better than everybody. Just sad IMHO.