PCness

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

Mr. K

New DJ
Aug 7, 2006
4,215
0
I would never say this to anybody in the DJ industry, especially to my clients or to my guests.

However, to anybody else, if I ever say, "Merry Christmas," and that person makes a stink about how I should not say that because it is offensive, "Because I don't believe in Christianity," then I would reply, "So, since you don't believe in it, you won't be offended when I say, 'Go to Hell.'"

Thanks for reading my story.

I don't like what Christmas has become anyway, but that's not the point.

:)
 
LOL,, I liked that and yes it would be cool to say that...

At the end of my "Holiday" parties I say " Mahalo for coming and no matter what Holiday you celebrate, I hope that you have a good one, Aloha!"
 
Vinyl,

You've probably never been a minority. Sometimes an innocent greeting such as "Merry Christmas" is an instant reminder that the other person is is different. It may set off parasitic memories of times when their religious difference resulted in undo persecution. They may even be reading all sorts of negative things into your greeting such as; does the greeter think everyone living here should be Christian. Whatever the case, there are probably some very upsetting feelings going through their head. That's why they try to correct people. Unfortunately, they are probably thinking about all those unpleasant thoughts when they're doing this so it comes out pretty snotty.

I'm not condoning the attitude they send, I just understand it. Telling them to go to hell is just reinforcing their stereotypes of your stereotypes. (Did that make any sense?)

Personally, I am more offended by store people that say "Have a nice day" without making eye contact or smiling. They are like robots with a limited vocabulary. They are ingenuine in their greeting. People saying Merry Christmas are generally in good spirit. Their intention is generally just to share the good spirit.

I might suggest an alternate response that will make them feel like total heels. I don't have such a response in mind at this time, but I'm working on it.
 
I've had people tell me that my saying "Merry Christmas" to them offended them. I had one guy tell me in Atlantic City that I offended him when I said Grace.

To those people I say, "Will you get offended if I say I don't give a F***?"

The guy in Atlantic City got real upset about it. I said, "The United States is still a free country. If my freedom of speach and religion offend you, you are free to leave."
 
While I hate being all PC....... ( like you didn't know that already ).... I'm blowing it off if it is a client unless they are over the top about it. Maybe then I would respond.
 
My tagline over at DJChat says the "The essence of communication is intention". I wish more people understood this. I didn't until about 10 years ago.

Rarely does someone say Merry Christmas with ill intent. If you're Jewish or Muslim you don't have to make someone feel bad for trying to be nice. You can say, "Thanks. I'm (other religion), but I'll accept your greeting as an expression of good wishes for the new year. Merry Christmas to you."

Of course, I'll be speechless if I ever heard someone say that. I don't see a problem with a Jew, Muslim or Bhuddist wishing a Christian a Merry Christmas. I can't see how such a wish compromises one's own belief. It is just showing respect for someone else to practice their belief. But that's just me.
 
If I wish you a Merry Christmas it's because I believe and I am invoking my faith in order to bestow well wishes upon you. Whether or not you practice christianity is not important. The value of such a greeting is in the faith of the person who bestows it.

You don't have to believe in someone else's god, but you should believe in the sincerety of anyone who would invoke their god to address you. When a person of faith invokes their religion to wish you well - simply be grateful that anyone would care so much.

When a non-Christian wishes me Merry Christmas I understand that to be an acknowledgement of my faith, and that they trust me to do well with it. Likewise, I sacrifice nothing when I recognize and acknowledge the value of religious faith in others; even where that faith differs.

My tagline over at DJChat says the "The essence of communication is intention". I wish more people understood this. I didn't until about 10 years ago.

Rarely does someone say Merry Christmas with ill intent. If you're Jewish or Muslim you don't have to make someone feel bad for trying to be nice. You can say, "Thanks. I'm (other religion), but I'll accept your greeting as an expression of good wishes for the new year. Merry Christmas to you."

The idea of "intention" is a curious one. Specifically, the "intention" of those who would be politically correct.

Freedom of religion does not grant you freedom from religion. For the latter, you'll have to go to a planet where you can avoid contact with other people.

The essence of political correctness is not sensitivity. It is not about respect for minority ideas. Political correctness is an offensive form of incrementalism used to dismantle that which does not serve specific special interests.

Consider this:

Does the canning of Christmas encourage individual free expression or does it simply stifle the religious practice of Christians? Is this consistemt with freedom of religion?

If you look at the motivation behind many PC issues the "intent" is often quite malicious.
 
I wish it was possible to give multiple thanks!!!
 
This has become a perennial issue. It arises every year. I still get a kick out of all the ink and newsprint that's expended by printing opinion after opinion on this topic. And it really isn't news... it's been going on for thousands of years.

Jon make a good point. Some practices have the ability to create fear in others. This serves to illustrate why there have been countless wars over the centuries.

I don't think it's PC to wish others a safe and enjoyable holiday season (my personal choice). If I know the person celebrates Christmas I'll wish him or her a Merry Christmas.

I don't celebrate Kwanzaa... but I have no issues with folks who do. My intent is to wish the best of the season, no matter what you may call it. :)

To respect the wishes of those who say grace before a meal is simply good manners. When we were pups growing up, we said grace before every meal. My father hated it but Mom insisted upon it. Later in years I came to understand her reasoning.

Good manners never go out of style. Respect for the practices and cultures of others is just one more way of raising one's personal bar. Besides, who are we to buck traditions that are thousands of years old?

The traditions and practices have stuck around for a reason. :)

But that's just one old dog's opinion, nothing more.
 
Vinyl,

You've probably never been a minority.

I am, but I am not a VISIBLE MINORITY.

Any further discussion would send my "Political INcorrectness" ratings through the roof.

I hear what you're saying, though.
 
Fred,

While we are in agreement over the greetings stuff, I see it a bit differently when it comes to saying grace. Perhaps it is a semantics issue though. The intent behind saying grace is a good one. We are just sanctifying an everyday task. Doing this separates us from our animal instincts. Every religion from Wiccan to Buddhism does this in some manner. However, the difference in manners creates the problem.

Most people saying grace begin it by asking people to pray in unison (bow your heads, join hands, etc). The prayer may then be said in such a way to single out (or perhaps, rule out) particular belief systems. This could be by refering to Jesus directly or just in how the higher power is referenced. Basically, people have been asked to pray in someone else's belief system. That is very awkward and it may fly directly in the face of one's own belief system (i.e. praying to a different god, prophet, etc.). IMHO, that is very different than simply extending a greeting.
 
In defense of PC (in moderation)

In support of PC

Johnny, you evil beast. You started this thread and see where it has gone?.

If anyone took offense to my wishing them a Merry Christmas, I would inquire which part of wishing them merry offended them? I would assure them if it had been flag, arbor or groundhog day I would wish them merry on those occasions too.

The yuletide season is upon us and so are the annual rantings of O’Reilly and his ilk. The godless humanists are coming to take the Christ out of Christmas once again. Horror of horrors! Where? At that bastion of Christianity, Target, the heart and soul of Christmas spirit. A sub minority has their knickers in a knot and want to replace the Happy Christmas sign with a Happy Holidays one. A show of hands, how many of us has been admonished for wishing someone a Merry Christmas? Not only have I not ever been admonished, no one within my earshot has been admonished. Further, no one has ever conveyed to me, they experienced such an admonishment. This is a big country and a few instances where a few misguided bureaucrats go overboard does not constitute a cabal.

Since no one wishes to own up to it, I will. I attempt to be PC. To wit: I make a good faith effort to be cognizant of other’s sensibilities. Years ago this might have been simply regarded as tact and good manners. Today it carries sinister overtones of the Trojan Horse of Political Correctness. Warning, ulterior motives reside within that PC horse. No, the basic idea is be aware of other’s sensitivities. If the guy is wearing a yarmulke, and you can see a lit menorah would it kill anyone to wish the dude a Happy Hanukkah rather than Merry Christmas? That to me is being PC. To use offensive racial-ethnic-sexual slurs is to be non-PC. Can PC be carried to extremes? Yes, like O’Reilly can on his rants. Recently, Christian activists have had the temerity to claim they are politically oppressed, yet every American President has been Christian, all but one Protestant (JFK was Irish-Catholic). Yeah some anti-PC Protestants floated the possibility of the Papist (Kennedy) being controlled by the Pope in the Vatican. Around 1900, Catholics were depicted in political cartoons as alligators swimming onto these shores. The alligator’s jaws were drawn as the Pope’s miter. That might be seen as non-PC today. Not such a bad thing don’t ya think?

If I were being PC, I’d not point out that before Christmas was a Christian or more accurately a Catholic feast day, it was a pagan one. The winter solstice was celebrated many years before the birth of Christ. The holiday, Saturnalia, honored the god of agriculture. Since this holiday offered the riff-raff (people like you and I) much merriment, gluttony and general bacchanal, the people of the time were not too keen on replacing a fun holiday with one that didn’t have as much appeal. Despite the fact, that Biblical scholars have determined Christ’s birth was closer to six months after Passover (September), in AD 350 Pope Julius I declared December 25th to be Christ’s birthday. Doesn’t that line up better with the winter solstice? Let’s note that the Catholic Pope is calling the shots for all Christianity as it will be another 1200 years before the Great Schism and Martin Luther nails his thesis to the church door (another good story that didn’t happen). To say the least, Pope Julius I was mindful that Christians were in the minority. Romans loved their holidays. Not taking away some of their favorite ones made conversion much more palatable. We won’t go into the stuff about circumcision. Easter too was pagan in origin.

The yule log, pine boughs, gift giving, Christmas trees were all pagan in origin. The yule, literally “wheel” was lit in honor of the sun, the wheel being symbolic of the sun. It was intended to encourage the sun’s return. Oh, you say Protestants don’t believe it was pagan in origin? Nope, Protestant sects (Puritans) banned christmas due to the links with the pagan past. Just like some Protestant sects ban dancing today. Just like some Muslim sects ban dancing and music and fun in general.

I can understand the fundamentalist Christian aversion to things PC as in my personal experience, they have precious little regard for the sensitivities of persons of science, other faiths or atheists. As evidence of this may I briefly explain? The complete denial of the cosmic, geologic and biologic record regarding the age of the cosmos, the earth and human origins. I have experienced being told that I’m not a Christian as I was raised a Catholic. Yes, I responded, and Christ wasn’t a Jew. They looked confused. Fundamentalists reserve the highest disdain for atheists. The argument is made (heard with my own ears and heard again in print and broadcast media) that since you (the recipient of the argument) did not believe in a god there was nothing to keep you from murder and pillage. They had to be less moral than their god-fearing counterpart. For the record, persons with advanced degrees are more likely to be atheist by a wide margin over their less educated brothers. Contrary to popular belief, atheists commit less crime, take up less prison space and commit murder less often.

If I were being PC, I’d not mention that the overwhelming numbers of souls (I use the term loosely) are of the same religion as their parents. These thinkers, these persons of great faith, simply accept the faith of their parents. On the whole there is no quest for the answer to the great question. We accept the answer our parents accepted almost universally. There is always the rare exception but for more than 98 percent of us this is true.

I believe there is something commendable in an effort to be moderately PC. What do you think? For myself I’ll continue to wish persons, Merry Christmas, godspeed, Happy May Day or whatever other salutation might best fit the recipient. Life is too short to worry about such things. Merry Christmas! No. Not yet, it is too early. As I explained to a bank teller (Christmas decorations were up Nov. 1), Christmas for one-twelfth the year is sufficient. Christmas for one-sixth of the year is ridiculous.

Have a nice day!
 
Thanks, guys.

This is a cool thread.

:thumbsup:

I have never personally experienced this, but I am prepared, for people in my life have experienced this.

The best story (told in FIRST person):

I went to pay for my Christmas gifts and, after I paid, I said, "Merry Christmas."

She said nothing.

I asked, "Don't you like being told to have a MERRY CHRISTMAS?"

"We're not allowed to say that," replied the teller.

So I asked for my money back and went to shop somewhere else.


I dug that. But my point was not so much to say GO TO HELL. My point was that people wish to be PC (which is bad enough), but only when it suits them.

Double standards are everywhere, but this note was to bring us all into the Christmas spirit.

:thumbsup:
 
Balanced,

Great post!

You've also added a whole new dimension to the PC debate; early holiday celebration. Just like you aren't supposed to wear white after Labor Day, I don't think you should be able to hang Christmas decorations until after Thanksgiving. It ought to be a law. My neighbor put his lights up last week when the temps were near 90. Of course, we'll let Gretchen Wilson keep her Christmas lights on the front porch all year long because she's an avowed redneck woman. ;)
 
I'ts not so much that it is offensive to wish a Jewish person, or someone who celebrates any other Hoilday, but it just goes on to remind them that their Holiday doesn't grow longer every year.

So they are mad. :)
 
Yes Chuck, the humor you find in most everything

Chuck, you are a marvel for finding the humor in almost any topic.

Since I've donned my PC hat, may I point out that you most likely meant to say they [Jews] are angry not mad?

Even Lewis Black, a Jew as well as a very funny guy pointed out their holiday sucked in comparison as they didn't get nearly as much really neat stuff. A dreidel? That sux in comparison to the Christmas tree and the other neat stuff.

To the more serious folks, may I say that none of this is meant to demean the true intent of the holiday whether practiced in a secular or religious manner.
 
If the guy is wearing a yarmulke, and you can see a lit menorah would it kill anyone to wish the dude a Happy Hanukkah rather than Merry Christmas?

You seem to be confused on the difference between Political correctness and common sense.

When a Christian store owner is publicly criticized for a banner that includes the word "Christmas" that is political correctness.

The difference between your personal approach and that of a beaurocrat is that the beaurocrat's opinion has the potential to become law, or carry some other civil or economic penalty.

To wish a happy holiday to a person you know does not celebrate that holiday is just stupid. But to be told to keep your mouth shut just in case you unknowingly bump into a non-Christian celebrant - is offensive.
 
To wish a happy holiday to a person you know does not celebrate that holiday is just stupid. But to be told to keep your mouth shut just in case you unknowingly bump into a non-Christian celebrant - is offensive.


I disagree. Up until a few weeks ago I would have agreed with you.

My day job as a mailman puts me in contact with many people each day. In December I always wish the customers "Happy Holidays" when I leave thier house. I don't know what they celebrate so I try to play it safe.

Last year I even did a holiday party for a local hospital. There were MANY people who, for lack of a better word, were Indian. I'm not exactly what country they were from. The head person from the department of the hospital made a speech about how a great year it was, etc... He ended the speech with something like "I'm sick and tired of all this PC stuff. This is NOT a holiday party, it's a CHRISTMAS party! and many people clapped.

This started the ball rolling for me. I couldn't believe he was saying this in front of many people who I ASSUME were not Christian, simply judging by their culture. This has stayed with me and a few weeks ago reared it's head again at school.

I am currently taking teaching classes at college and a few weeks ago my professor spoke about this very matter. He pretty much said that we are not allowed to celebrate ANY holiday in school. Sure, Christmas dominates but there are many people who don't celebrate Christmas. Jews don't celebrate, yet they get bombarded with Christmas. Radio plays Christmas songs 24/7 starting Turkey Day. Stores have Christmas decorations. TV has Christmas shows. Jewish children must get an inferiority complex with all this.

It doesn't stop there. What about St. Patrick's Day? Think back to when you were in kindergarten. The teacher would show flash cards with a bunch of symbols. Every picture on each card was the same with the exception of one. There was ALWAYS a 4 leaf clover associated with this game. Even a desk of cards has a clover. What's the symbol of St. Patrick's Day? A CLOVER! Any kid who is NOT Irish must get an inferiority complex. They see that Irish kids have not only St. Patirick's Day but that clovers are all over their world and they see them on a dailiy basis. The same goes for Christmas trees. Just like a clover is on these cards, there's always a Christmas tree too reminding non Christians about just how "uncool" their religion really is.

I use Indian below to classify Native Americans.

What about Colombus Day? Teachers have students create Indian head dresses with feathers and have the "pilgrims" and "indians" sit down and eat together. OK, but what you're NOT teaching these kids is that just a few short years later the children of the pilgrims desimated the indians. The pilgrims and indians didn't get along well because the white people were KILLING the indians for their land. So, go back to today and you're a little boy who is half or a quarter indian. How are YOU supposed to feel about Colombus Day?

So what are you gonna say? Are you gonna say "To Hell with that one little indian boy? 99.9 of us are not Indian so let's celebrate Colombus Day anyway!" How does this make the little boy feel?

What about birthdays? Jehovah's Witnesses do NOT celebrate ANYTHING. No birthdays, no holidays, nothing. How are you supposed to celebrate a birthday in class with a Jehevoah's witness child? The child CAN NOT partake in the celebration. Is it fair to have his motehr pick him up right before the celebration? How is the kid supposed to feel knowing that his friends are having a party that he can't attend. Doesn't that make him feel inadequate?

Even if you don't want to celebrate holidays at school, you can't even TEACh the holdays. You can't just teach the students about Christmas. You would have to teach the students about EVERY holiday in EVERY culture. Who has time for that? If you DON'T teach about EVERY holiday in EVERY culture then the students will see THEIR holidays as SUPERIOR to other holidays in other cultures. Is this right?

I feel that many people who say "to hell with them, I'm gonna wish everyone a Merry Christmas.......etc...." have never been on the other end.

I wonder how these same people feel about spanish immigrants. Do you get offended if a spanish person tries to talk to you. Do you get offended by seeing spanish words on the products you buy? I find that many people who dislike the immigrants are anti PC. Don't the immigrants have the same rights as you? Do you attempt to learn spanish? There's no national language in the US so the immigrants have every right to speak spanish. They don't HAVE to learn English. It's beneficial to them to learn but they don't HAVE to learn. Do you bother with them or do you brush them aside?