To wish a happy holiday to a person you know does not celebrate that holiday is just stupid. But to be told to keep your mouth shut just in case you unknowingly bump into a non-Christian celebrant - is offensive.
I disagree. Up until a few weeks ago I would have agreed with you.
My day job as a mailman puts me in contact with many people each day. In December I always wish the customers "Happy Holidays" when I leave thier house. I don't know what they celebrate so I try to play it safe.
Last year I even did a holiday party for a local hospital. There were MANY people who, for lack of a better word, were Indian. I'm not exactly what country they were from. The head person from the department of the hospital made a speech about how a great year it was, etc... He ended the speech with something like "I'm sick and tired of all this PC stuff. This is NOT a holiday party, it's a CHRISTMAS party! and many people clapped.
This started the ball rolling for me. I couldn't believe he was saying this in front of many people who I ASSUME were not Christian, simply judging by their culture. This has stayed with me and a few weeks ago reared it's head again at school.
I am currently taking teaching classes at college and a few weeks ago my professor spoke about this very matter. He pretty much said that we are not allowed to celebrate ANY holiday in school. Sure, Christmas dominates but there are many people who don't celebrate Christmas. Jews don't celebrate, yet they get bombarded with Christmas. Radio plays Christmas songs 24/7 starting Turkey Day. Stores have Christmas decorations. TV has Christmas shows. Jewish children must get an inferiority complex with all this.
It doesn't stop there. What about St. Patrick's Day? Think back to when you were in kindergarten. The teacher would show flash cards with a bunch of symbols. Every picture on each card was the same with the exception of one. There was ALWAYS a 4 leaf clover associated with this game. Even a desk of cards has a clover. What's the symbol of St. Patrick's Day? A CLOVER! Any kid who is NOT Irish must get an inferiority complex. They see that Irish kids have not only St. Patirick's Day but that clovers are all over their world and they see them on a dailiy basis. The same goes for Christmas trees. Just like a clover is on these cards, there's always a Christmas tree too reminding non Christians about just how "uncool" their religion really is.
I use Indian below to classify Native Americans.
What about Colombus Day? Teachers have students create Indian head dresses with feathers and have the "pilgrims" and "indians" sit down and eat together. OK, but what you're NOT teaching these kids is that just a few short years later the children of the pilgrims desimated the indians. The pilgrims and indians didn't get along well because the white people were KILLING the indians for their land. So, go back to today and you're a little boy who is half or a quarter indian. How are YOU supposed to feel about Colombus Day?
So what are you gonna say? Are you gonna say "To Hell with that one little indian boy? 99.9 of us are not Indian so let's celebrate Colombus Day anyway!" How does this make the little boy feel?
What about birthdays? Jehovah's Witnesses do NOT celebrate ANYTHING. No birthdays, no holidays, nothing. How are you supposed to celebrate a birthday in class with a Jehevoah's witness child? The child CAN NOT partake in the celebration. Is it fair to have his motehr pick him up right before the celebration? How is the kid supposed to feel knowing that his friends are having a party that he can't attend. Doesn't that make him feel inadequate?
Even if you don't want to celebrate holidays at school, you can't even TEACh the holdays. You can't just teach the students about Christmas. You would have to teach the students about EVERY holiday in EVERY culture. Who has time for that? If you DON'T teach about EVERY holiday in EVERY culture then the students will see THEIR holidays as SUPERIOR to other holidays in other cultures. Is this right?
I feel that many people who say "to hell with them, I'm gonna wish everyone a Merry Christmas.......etc...." have never been on the other end.
I wonder how these same people feel about spanish immigrants. Do you get offended if a spanish person tries to talk to you. Do you get offended by seeing spanish words on the products you buy? I find that many people who dislike the immigrants are anti PC. Don't the immigrants have the same rights as you? Do you attempt to learn spanish? There's no national language in the US so the immigrants have every right to speak spanish. They don't HAVE to learn English. It's beneficial to them to learn but they don't HAVE to learn. Do you bother with them or do you brush them aside?