Correct regarding all of the above. It's certainly technically as easy to pirate a disc as an MP3. However, to pirate a disc, you must first have it in your possession. To pirate an MP3 one just need to find it on line and hack in. I believe that digital music has, and will continue to cause an INCREASE in piracy.
As for the KJ making money: If you mean charging for downloading a requested song, it might. However, some PC KJs are already doing this from pirate sites- ALL profit. Illegal, immoral, and still being done.
From a business standpoint, it's something else. If you charge for a download, you really don't have much of a product to sell. It depends how many are willing to PAY YOU for a song that they can ONLY SING AT YOUR SHOW. You are asking them to pay for something that ultimately benefits YOU.
Of course, if you make them a copy, you become a pirate yourself. One other thing. If it's available to you, it's available to all, or at least on the web where it can be found.
BTW- Many singers come to a disc based show and wish to use their own discs, with THEIR favorite versions of a song. What happens when they start bringing memory sticks? Do you want to take a chance on infecting your computer?
And on a side note: Why the hell do most of the PC hosts I've run into insist on deleting mfrs. disc numbers in their books? Except for the most inexperienced singers, this makes the books almost useless. I mean,don't get me wrong. If the books are like this, with no version indicators, AND the PC host can't play personal discs, the host is just PUSHING their singers at me! I love it, but so you know, that is the number 1 most heard complaint. #2 is that many KJs just lie when asked what version a song is ( "oh, all my stuff is Sound Choice", or "trust me, it's the version everyone knows"). The singer gets up, it's not the version specified, they don't do as well as they think they should- and they come to me.
HELPFUL HINT: If nothing else, include the mfr. in the book, or be capable of playing customer discs.
Actually a PURELY digital source would be harder to pirate. How many people do you know that can hack a 128 bit encrypted server? Not impossible by any stretch of the imagination, but it isn't exactly a common skill either.
Most of the pirated sources for karaoke start with a disc. And yes, it is possible for someone to get something they want and charge for it, but it isn't as easy.
Let's take the most common sources for karaoke. Usenet, KAZZA and Limewire.
With USENET the only thing you can do to get a specific disc you want is hope that someone has already uploaded it AND it hasn't been deleted from your ISP server. 9 times out of ten, i have tried to download something from there only to have one part of the download missing or corrupted, making everything totally useless. Or you can post a request and wait. No instant gratification there.
Kazza and limewire you can search for exactly what you are looking for, but they may or may not have it. Hit and miss at best and you have to contend with crappy copies and possible viruses.
With the place I went to, yes you could get virtually everything, but it was a private, invite only network so not available to the general public. Plus the newest releases were usually only available from one or two people, so it could take as much as three weeks until you found them online to get a download. Still a bit hit and miss.
Or i can go to a place like tricerasoft, get EXACTLY what i want, when i want it, and I know its 100% legal and virus free. Option A may be free but I choose option B because its a hell of a lot easier and hassle free.
As for people with their own discs, that's very simple. I can get a $5 video switcher, hook up my computer and a karaoke player and switch back and forth. No big deal there.
In fact, it looks like in order to satisfy Canadian law, I will have to keep an mp3 file for every karaoke track, make up a cdg that says something to the effect of "Due to liscensing restrictions, this track is not availble on computer. Please wait while the KJ loads your disc" and pair those up for every track that I did not buy the download for *or have permission to copy, like I got from Zoom* and play the discs exclusively.
That way I can still use my computer for rotation and queing songs, but I'll have to use my player with the disc to actually play the song..
All I need is a digital music liscense which are relatively inexpensive. The hassle will be converting all the karaoke tracks i have..
As to manufacturer codes. I switched to my own numbering system because listing by manufacturer seemed to confuse the heck out of the kj who rented my music. She could never find the right disc.
Personally it was never an issue for me, i've never had anyone request a specific disc, altho i have suggested one when they ask.
For the software i have, its easy to include a manufacturer code along with the numbering system i use. Most of them are standard *ie sc = soundchoice cb= chartbusters etc*