Chartbuster Collection

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
.

and a Simon and Garfunkle. Both so-so IMO, not that great and no comparison to companies like Soundchoice and Chartbusters.

I've sang a couple of Monster hits tracks and I thought they were very good. I sing the MH "Kiss and Say Goodbye" by the Manhattans frequently and it's a very good version, in fact better than any other version I've heard so far.

IMHO, the definitive Simon and Garfunkle disc is Doctor Music DM101. Beats all the better known brands...


You know what? I REALLY like Monster Hits. Surprisingly good for a decent price....
 
After writing and harasing virtually every karaoke company I could think of to try and get someone to listen to the concept of why digital karaoke is a good idea for the companies to combat piracy and make money,

You are about half right. Digital karaoke makes it EASIER to pirate, and always will. The accessibility makes this inherent. NOTHING is hack proof..

On the other hand: Of COURSE the company will make more money. No production costs, no true & secure way of keeping track of downloads, so they can continue to rip off the artists, and best of all, you can pay money for something, they still have the product, and can re-sell it over and over and over! Terrific for the economy!

.... um, sorry for that...:sqembarrassed:
 
Actually its not that hard to pirate disks either. It used to be that you needed a special CD or DVD drive with the proper software encoded but now most drives will at least rip a cdg properly with the right software.

I used to frequent a site that got virutally every new realease from all the major brands. i used them to evaluate discs so i wouldn't have to buy it first *still doesn't make it right tho, which is why i stopped*

If someone REALLY wants to steal, they will do it, regardless of how well you try to protect something, or what the potential consequences may be. Digital karaoke isn't going to change that. Nothing will. What will change is the oportunity for the KJ to make income that you can't easily make with pirated material.

I also happen to believe that the MAJORITY of people who host for a living are basically honest, hard working people who if they were presented with a better, easier and faster way of doing things, would hop on the bandwagon willingly.

As for keeping track of the music. I think if they can invent a microchip that will track a human being's every single movement, anywhere on the planet, then they can come up with a scheme to keep track of purchases of digital music.. :sqeek:
 
Actually its not that hard to pirate disks either. It used to be that you needed a special CD or DVD drive with the proper software encoded but now most drives will at least rip a cdg properly with the right software.

IIf someone REALLY wants to steal, they will do it, regardless of how well you try to protect something, or what the potential consequences may be. Digital karaoke isn't going to change that.
As for keeping track of the music. I think if they can invent a microchip that will track a human being's every single movement, anywhere on the planet, then they can come up with a scheme to keep track of purchases of digital music.. :sqeek:


Correct regarding all of the above. It's certainly technically as easy to pirate a disc as an MP3. However, to pirate a disc, you must first have it in your possession. To pirate an MP3 one just need to find it on line and hack in. I believe that digital music has, and will continue to cause an INCREASE in piracy.

As for the KJ making money: If you mean charging for downloading a requested song, it might. However, some PC KJs are already doing this from pirate sites- ALL profit. Illegal, immoral, and still being done.

From a business standpoint, it's something else. If you charge for a download, you really don't have much of a product to sell. It depends how many are willing to PAY YOU for a song that they can ONLY SING AT YOUR SHOW. You are asking them to pay for something that ultimately benefits YOU.

Of course, if you make them a copy, you become a pirate yourself. One other thing. If it's available to you, it's available to all, or at least on the web where it can be found.

BTW- Many singers come to a disc based show and wish to use their own discs, with THEIR favorite versions of a song. What happens when they start bringing memory sticks? Do you want to take a chance on infecting your computer?


And on a side note: Why the hell do most of the PC hosts I've run into insist on deleting mfrs. disc numbers in their books? Except for the most inexperienced singers, this makes the books almost useless. I mean,don't get me wrong. If the books are like this, with no version indicators, AND the PC host can't play personal discs, the host is just PUSHING their singers at me! I love it, but so you know, that is the number 1 most heard complaint. #2 is that many KJs just lie when asked what version a song is ( "oh, all my stuff is Sound Choice", or "trust me, it's the version everyone knows"). The singer gets up, it's not the version specified, they don't do as well as they think they should- and they come to me.

HELPFUL HINT: If nothing else, include the mfr. in the book, or be capable of playing customer discs.
 
Correct regarding all of the above. It's certainly technically as easy to pirate a disc as an MP3. However, to pirate a disc, you must first have it in your possession. To pirate an MP3 one just need to find it on line and hack in. I believe that digital music has, and will continue to cause an INCREASE in piracy.

Ummmmmm, no. Digital music is in no way resposible for piracy. The people that are making the digital music available via a P2P site such as Limewire are the ones contributing to piracy. Also one doesn't have to have the disc to pirate the music all you have to do is log into a p2p site and you are now pirating anything you download.

Simply copying a disc that you own to your computer is not pirating a disc.... sorry but the Fair Use Act tells me so.

Before you get huffy I know that, that is suppose to be for personal use only not for commercial use.

The point is there is a fine line between transfering a disc you own to use it on a PC and sharing/pirateing music.


As for the KJ making money: If you mean charging for downloading a requested song, it might. However, some PC KJs are already doing this from pirate sites- ALL profit. Illegal, immoral, and still being done.

Not all KJ's download from illegal sites. I for one can get music for my customers legally from Tricerasoft on the spot and if they want it, RIGHT NOW it will cost them.... if not I'll buy it later for the next show.

From a business standpoint, it's something else. If you charge for a download, you really don't have much of a product to sell. It depends how many are willing to PAY YOU for a song that they can ONLY SING AT YOUR SHOW. You are asking them to pay for something that ultimately benefits YOU.

Another good reason for them to return to your show... they can sing that song they just bought for you... again this is done in my case for those that must have their song that night... otherwise it purchased later by me.

Of course, if you make them a copy, you become a pirate yourself. One other thing. If it's available to you, it's available to all, or at least on the web where it can be found.

I completely agree with that...

BTW- Many singers come to a disc based show and wish to use their own discs, with THEIR favorite versions of a song. What happens when they start bringing memory sticks? Do you want to take a chance on infecting your computer?

At my shows memory sticks are not allowed for the very reason you pointed out. If they have a favorite version that I don't have then they can give me a disc.


And on a side note: Why the hell do most of the PC hosts I've run into insist on deleting mfrs. disc numbers in their books? Except for the most inexperienced singers, this makes the books almost useless. I mean,don't get me wrong. If the books are like this, with no version indicators, AND the PC host can't play personal discs, the host is just PUSHING their singers at me! I love it, but so you know, that is the number 1 most heard complaint. #2 is that many KJs just lie when asked what version a song is ( "oh, all my stuff is Sound Choice", or "trust me, it's the version everyone knows"). The singer gets up, it's not the version specified, they don't do as well as they think they should- and they come to me.

Who knows maybe they had their own way of catalogueing their music before they converted to PC and decided to continue doing it that way... or they are pirates (most likely reason) and just have no clue what manufacture is for each track...

HELPFUL HINT: If nothing else, include the mfr. in the book, or be capable of playing customer discs.

Fixed that for ya... very good point.

Bottom line here is if you own your discs and have them ripped to your PC... yes the letter of the law says you can't use that in a commercial environment per se' but lets be realistic here.... your not a pirate until you share or recieve files or burned copies of music...

And Joe as you've pointed out... who's to say those discs you just bought aren't illegal to begin with because the manu didn't license them properly...
 
Bottom line here is if you own your discs and have them ripped to your PC... yes the letter of the law says you can't use that in a commercial environment per se' but lets be realistic here.... your not a pirate until you share or recieve files or burned copies of music...

And Joe as you've pointed out... who's to say those discs you just bought aren't illegal to begin with because the manu didn't license them properly...

Tough to quote you since you answered WITHIN my post, but:

1) I never said digital music CAUSED piracy. The point I was making was that, contrary to the original poster's claim, it most certainly WON'T reduce it, and will probably increase it.


2) Yes, the purchased download MAY bring a singer back to your show, but that wasn't my point. From a business standpoint, why would a singer wish to PAY for something that YOU will own, and they won't? Why would they pay to benefit YOUR show?

Don't get me wrong. There are some stupid or drunk people who might, but the fact is that you would actually be trying to convince people to pay for songs to add to YOUR collection, with no real benefit to them. I'm thinking ( or hoping there are still enough working minds out there)that most will catch on to that, making it a tough sell. However, the sheep population is growing, and I could be wrong.....:sqrolleyes:


3) I am in complete agreement with your last statement. NO one truly knows- but the manufacturers- whether a song is truly licensed or not, whether it be disc or MP3


And now, after all of that ranting, I have to look like an idiot and ask for PC expertise. Much as I hate the things, you know I do small house parties with my laptop when I'm room challenged. What is your choice for a top end sound card? Geez, I'm so embarassed.....:sqembarrassed:
 
Tough to quote you since you answered WITHIN my post, but:

1) I never said digital music CAUSED piracy. The point I was making was that, contrary to the original poster's claim, it most certainly WON'T reduce it, and will probably increase it.

That's certainly what it sounded like you were saying that if it weren't for digital music there wouldn't be piracy... and that couldn't be further from the truth... people have been coping other peoples LPs and Tapes and CDs since the dawn of recording devices... Digital music is just easier to pirate on a grander scale. Nothing is going to stop that if some one wants to get something for free they will find a way.... digital or not.

2) Yes, the purchased download MAY bring a singer back to your show, but that wasn't my point. From a business standpoint, why would a singer wish to PAY for something that YOU will own, and they won't? Why would they pay to benefit YOUR show?

Don't get me wrong. There are some stupid or drunk people who might, but the fact is that you would actually be trying to convince people to pay for songs to add to YOUR collection, with no real benefit to them. I'm thinking ( or hoping there are still enough working minds out there)that most will catch on to that, making it a tough sell. However, the sheep population is growing, and I could be wrong.....:sqrolleyes:

Let me ask this.... how much does it cost to play video games these days... the good ones? $1, $2 or more depending on how into the game you are right.

So, why is it such a stretch that a singer would pay to get a song they want to sing now and pay for it to get it. That's the benifit to that singer they don't have to wait for you to get it next week.... instant gratification..... trust me if it's available they will pay. Drunk or sober doesn't matter.... and then they will continue to reap the benefits of buying a track for your show buy coming back to sing it next week, the following week and weeks beyond that.


3) I am in complete agreement with your last statement. NO one truly knows- but the manufacturers- whether a song is truly licensed or not, whether it be disc or MP3

I guess we have to take their word on it don't we....:sqwink:


And now, after all of that ranting, I have to look like an idiot and ask for PC expertise. Much as I hate the things, you know I do small house parties with my laptop when I'm room challenged. What is your choice for a top end sound card? Geez, I'm so embarassed.....:sqembarrassed:

If ya want just a simple sound card to use instead of the built in one I'd go with a Turtle Beach USB sound card.... or if you can find one a Gigaport (sp?)
 
1) That's certainly what it sounded like you were saying that if it weren't for digital music there wouldn't be piracy

2) So, why is it such a stretch that a singer would pay to get a song they want to sing now and pay for it to get it. That's the benifit to that singer they don't have to wait for you to get it next week.... instant gratification..... trust me if it's available they will pay. Drunk or sober doesn't matter.... and then they will continue to reap the benefits of buying a track for your show buy coming back to sing it next week, the following week and weeks beyond that.



3) If ya want just a simple sound card to use instead of the built in one I'd go with a Turtle Beach USB sound card.... or if you can find one a Gigaport (sp?)




1) Well, I hope I cleared up THAT misconception. Pirating goes back to the invention of recorded media.....:sqfrown:



2) It;s a stretch in that, once again, a thinking person will understand that THEY are paying for something that benefits YOU. Where they might willingly pay for a one shot for their use, many would take umbrage at buying a track for YOU.

Note that I said a thinking person. Would you be able to sell songs in a bar? You will probably find some customers. However, if you already HAVE a decent collection, there probably won't be very many times when you NEED a new song. THEN you have to convince that singer that it's worthwile. Even if you convinced EVERY singer that it was for them-somehow- the rule of diminishing demand applies. The more songs you have, the less demand for a missing track. At $2 per song, how much are you, or any single host going to make in a night?

My other problem is strictly mine. I work in high end places. Both the singers and I would feel like I was nickel and diming them. THIS IS JUST CONCERNING ME. No knock on anyone else...



3) Many thanks! I'll check it out after work tonight!
 
Joe,

I am one of those digital karaoke host who does not list the manu in the books. I have had only a couple of people request a song by a particular manu, and that is all they have to do if I have it I play that manu's song.

If someone request let's say Crazy by Patsy Cline on Chartbusters I can pick that one just as easily as I can Pioneer, Sound Choice, JVC, SAV, All Hits, Zoom, Legends or Easy. If I only have a song by one manu then that is the only one I have, that situation wouldn't change even if I had the Manu listed in the book.

As for a patron bringing their own disc I don't have a problem with it, I check and if I have the same version (manu) I simply play it, If I don't I rip the song and play it takes about 30 seconds to do it.
 
Joe,

I am one of those digital karaoke host who does not list the manu in the books. I have had only a couple of people request a song by a particular manu, and that is all they have to do if I have it I play that manu's song.

If someone request let's say Crazy by Patsy Cline on Chartbusters I can pick that one just as easily as I can Pioneer, Sound Choice, JVC, SAV, All Hits, Zoom, Legends or Easy. If I only have a song by one manu then that is the only one I have, that situation wouldn't change even if I had the Manu listed in the book.

As for a patron bringing their own disc I don't have a problem with it, I check and if I have the same version (manu) I simply play it, If I don't I rip the song and play it takes about 30 seconds to do it.


Sounds mostly ok by me. I was actually talking about hosts who do NOT have the capability of playing customer discs.

The only little glitch in your system for me is that I use slips, which means I would be the one to look up the customer requests if I didn't list manufacturer numbers. I would also have to take take the time to answer a LOT of version questions. Nothing horrible there, but I could use the time for better things.... I realize that not everyone's customer base is the same, but mine, in all seven venues- is very version oriented. Besides my magnetic charm and studlitude :sqrolleyes: many are there specifically because I not only list the mfrs. but keep ALL versions in the book.

I mean, believe it or not, the most popular version of Total Eclipse.. is SGB! Go figure.

Anyway, my original question stands. What is the benefit of removing the mfr. numbers? I'm not being a wise-a**. Since I don't run shows with a PC more than once or twice a year, I genuinely don't know. A little info?
 
"And now, after all of that ranting, I have to look like an idiot and ask for PC expertise. Much as I hate the things, you know I do small house parties with my laptop when I'm room challenged. What is your choice for a top end sound card? Geez, I'm so embarassed....."

Going back to Joe's question on this: I use the Behringer USB interface - $30 on
all of my DJ systems for computer interface - seems to do a great job - just plug
into a USB port, and rca or optical out put to your mixer.............
 
Anyway, my original question stands. What is the benefit of removing the mfr. numbers? I'm not being a wise-a**. Since I don't run shows with a PC more than once or twice a year, I genuinely don't know. A little info?

The short answer: None

Some folks are just more comfortable with whatever system they used before they went digital and well... ya know it's hard to teach an old dog new tricks.

As for me I like haveing the manu's numbers on my listings for the very reasons you have sighted already.
 
The short answer: None

Some folks are just more comfortable with whatever system they used before they went digital and well... ya know it's hard to teach an old dog new tricks.

.


Well, as a Luddite, I still notice the many of the songbook generators ( I use KJ Pro) would normally use the mfr. numbers. One would have to purposely go in and manually change each disc number.....unless one of the freebies just sorts discs numerically, starting from 1?
 
Well, as a Luddite, I still notice the many of the songbook generators ( I use KJ Pro) would normally use the mfr. numbers. One would have to purposely go in and manually change each disc number.....unless one of the freebies just sorts discs numerically, starting from 1?

Assumeing they are using a book making software... I don't I can export straight from my data base to a CSV file and import it into Excel and have a songbook in minutes. I can even import it into KJPro and bypass their database and use the songbook format features...

But, yes if someone is using just the book making software they would have to override the softwares disc numbering system for their own.... not a hard thing to do.
 
1) I can even import it into KJPro and bypass their database and use the songbook format features...

2) But, yes if someone is using just the book making software they would have to override the softwares disc numbering system for their own.... not a hard thing to do.



1) Yeah, I can import to KJ Pro direct from Excel as well. Just a point and click.


2) Exactly. So if one took the time to do that, there should be SOME reason..... Steve?
 
1) Yeah, I can import to KJ Pro direct from Excel as well. Just a point and click.


2) Exactly. So if one took the time to do that, there should be SOME reason..... Steve?

Actually my point about importing directly into KJPro was this.... say you have your collection catalogued with a unique taging system and you import it into KJPro... your taging system would follow and be the same. See when importing the data KJPro could give two craps what system you use... your own or it's system.

So say a person like Steve has his books already in excel format and imports it as is or with slight mods to make it compatible his unique disc numbering system would import as well.
 
Actually my point about importing directly into KJPro was this.... say you have your collection catalogued with a unique taging system and you import it into KJPro... your taging system would follow and be the same. See when importing the data KJPro could give two craps what system you use... your own or it's system.

So say a person like Steve has his books already in excel format and imports it as is or with slight mods to make it compatible his unique disc numbering system would import as well.


Joker, thanks. I apparently brushed my teeth with dumba** or I would have caught that...:sqembarrassed:
 
Correct regarding all of the above. It's certainly technically as easy to pirate a disc as an MP3. However, to pirate a disc, you must first have it in your possession. To pirate an MP3 one just need to find it on line and hack in. I believe that digital music has, and will continue to cause an INCREASE in piracy.

As for the KJ making money: If you mean charging for downloading a requested song, it might. However, some PC KJs are already doing this from pirate sites- ALL profit. Illegal, immoral, and still being done.

From a business standpoint, it's something else. If you charge for a download, you really don't have much of a product to sell. It depends how many are willing to PAY YOU for a song that they can ONLY SING AT YOUR SHOW. You are asking them to pay for something that ultimately benefits YOU.

Of course, if you make them a copy, you become a pirate yourself. One other thing. If it's available to you, it's available to all, or at least on the web where it can be found.

BTW- Many singers come to a disc based show and wish to use their own discs, with THEIR favorite versions of a song. What happens when they start bringing memory sticks? Do you want to take a chance on infecting your computer?


And on a side note: Why the hell do most of the PC hosts I've run into insist on deleting mfrs. disc numbers in their books? Except for the most inexperienced singers, this makes the books almost useless. I mean,don't get me wrong. If the books are like this, with no version indicators, AND the PC host can't play personal discs, the host is just PUSHING their singers at me! I love it, but so you know, that is the number 1 most heard complaint. #2 is that many KJs just lie when asked what version a song is ( "oh, all my stuff is Sound Choice", or "trust me, it's the version everyone knows"). The singer gets up, it's not the version specified, they don't do as well as they think they should- and they come to me.

HELPFUL HINT: If nothing else, include the mfr. in the book, or be capable of playing customer discs.

Actually a PURELY digital source would be harder to pirate. How many people do you know that can hack a 128 bit encrypted server? Not impossible by any stretch of the imagination, but it isn't exactly a common skill either.

Most of the pirated sources for karaoke start with a disc. And yes, it is possible for someone to get something they want and charge for it, but it isn't as easy.

Let's take the most common sources for karaoke. Usenet, KAZZA and Limewire.

With USENET the only thing you can do to get a specific disc you want is hope that someone has already uploaded it AND it hasn't been deleted from your ISP server. 9 times out of ten, i have tried to download something from there only to have one part of the download missing or corrupted, making everything totally useless. Or you can post a request and wait. No instant gratification there.

Kazza and limewire you can search for exactly what you are looking for, but they may or may not have it. Hit and miss at best and you have to contend with crappy copies and possible viruses.

With the place I went to, yes you could get virtually everything, but it was a private, invite only network so not available to the general public. Plus the newest releases were usually only available from one or two people, so it could take as much as three weeks until you found them online to get a download. Still a bit hit and miss.

Or i can go to a place like tricerasoft, get EXACTLY what i want, when i want it, and I know its 100% legal and virus free. Option A may be free but I choose option B because its a hell of a lot easier and hassle free.

As for people with their own discs, that's very simple. I can get a $5 video switcher, hook up my computer and a karaoke player and switch back and forth. No big deal there.

In fact, it looks like in order to satisfy Canadian law, I will have to keep an mp3 file for every karaoke track, make up a cdg that says something to the effect of "Due to liscensing restrictions, this track is not availble on computer. Please wait while the KJ loads your disc" and pair those up for every track that I did not buy the download for *or have permission to copy, like I got from Zoom* and play the discs exclusively.

That way I can still use my computer for rotation and queing songs, but I'll have to use my player with the disc to actually play the song..

All I need is a digital music liscense which are relatively inexpensive. The hassle will be converting all the karaoke tracks i have..

As to manufacturer codes. I switched to my own numbering system because listing by manufacturer seemed to confuse the heck out of the kj who rented my music. She could never find the right disc.

Personally it was never an issue for me, i've never had anyone request a specific disc, altho i have suggested one when they ask.

For the software i have, its easy to include a manufacturer code along with the numbering system i use. Most of them are standard *ie sc = soundchoice cb= chartbusters etc*
 
The last part first: Many PC based shows do not have the capability to play discs AND mix them properly. These are the completely PC based shows I was referring to. Some can play discs, but their virtual mixer has no effect on player output, so they can't mix sound. If you are only using a video switcher, and don't have an actual mixer, you would be in this situation.

If you CAN play and mix, I guess the problem of version listing MAY be reduced. However, in my case, the singers are very version concious.


As for the rest: To repeat, ANY digital source can be hacked. As for the rest, I have learned in another thread that both Sound Choice and Stellar seem to see it the same way I do, and will no longer offer didtal releases. I defer to their expertise and experience in the business.....