Don't know if I'm allowed to ask, but....

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
Status
Not open for further replies.
With all due respect, Chris... what about the posts making fun of Yankees? What about redneck insults? What about the bashes against PM?

Those are still there.. while I understand your POV, I don't see why it's onyl certain topics.

At the same time, if we censor every joke, then there's an issue...

You can't compare a Yankee fan to a practicing Catholic. A Yankee fan does not live their life according to the Yankees. They wouldn't die for their team.

A Catholic lives their life according to the Bible. Every facet of their life is affected by their beliefs and people have and will die for their beliefs.

That's my answer.

If you want to talk about jokes on this board then I will let you know that I haven't received angry PM's from anyone over a redneck, polish, blonde or similar type joke. I have received messages from members being angry over Yo Momma (a large part due to the sheer volume of them posted here I'm sure) and Catholic jokes. If our members start complaining then we know there's a problem somewhere.
 
To me there's a difference as well between; "There was a priest and a Rabbi in a bar......a light hearted joke versus something derogatory and demeaning.

The same holds true for women, rednecks and so on.....

Arnoldo...if the demeaning comment was directed towards your ethnicity, i'm sure you'd feel different.

As for who draws the line..it's Dan and the mods....it's their house...
 
To me there's a difference as well between; "There was a priest and a Rabbi in a bar......a light hearted joke versus something derogatory and demeaning.

The same holds true for women, rednecks and so on.....

Arnoldo...if the demeaning comment was directed towards your ethnicity, i'm sure you'd feel different.

As for who draws the line..it's Dan and the mods....it's their house...


Exactly. The "jokes" in question were not really jokes at all.
 
Wow, this feels like dejavu. I understand both sides of this thread and I hope that everyone figures it out before it gets ugly (again). I agree that certain things should be off limits (race, faith, sex, politics). If everyone just used their common sense, I believe that moderation wouldn't be necessary.

I get what the mods are trying to accomplish and what their vision of what this site should be. I get the members that are feeling out of sorts because they want to be funny, make off topic comments, and get shut down for it.

I'm done with trying to get it or change it, I'm just going to deal with it.
 
I really don't feel anything should be "off limits".

When it turns "ugly" is when someone can't accept their belief being challenged then makes it personal.

I'm a Catholic - I appreciate a good catholic joke (i.e. a priest and a rabbi). I recognize we all have different sensitivities.

It does not however take a rocket scientist to figure out when a particular joke crosses the line and becomes unfunny...

The "momma's mouth" comeback recently crossed that line.....

Kelly had nailed it on the head; we ll just need to deal with it....
 
Good thread....

I love you, and you , and you, and you... not you, and you and you.

I've said this before... I like jokes just as much as the next guy/gal. As mentioned above, when a joke crosses the line, everyone (most everyone) knows it.

I'm all for having a good time and just chatting about anything... but I can't believe someone would screw something up, then say "what did I do?" with out a clue. I don't buy it.

If you're a trouble maker, then I'm sure you know you are, and usually get watched a little closer. Funny thing is, the real trouble makers get more latitude than everyone else. The mods talk continually in the back room and go round and round about issues generated from trouble makers.

We have come to the conclusion that we are going to tighten things up a little more than we have in the past. If you cause trouble, rest assured that you're going to spend some time away from this forum. Yes, we can have fun... but don't be an idiot about it.
 
I'm really trying to think of something smart-arce to say here, but I can't think of any..... I don't think of it as "The Mods House"... I think of it as "Our House", and it's a might mighty might fine house....

Please come in a visit....or not......"come or stay, but do it because it is what you want to do!" (who said that?,or something real close? I know do you?)

Am I off topic yet? No? Okay?

Maybe people don't live or die for the Yankees,, I understand that,,,, but they do for the Raiders!!! WHOO HOO!!

Okay. a Priest, a Rabbi, a Pagen and a Rastafarian are sitting around a table........

Deal with the fact that joke posts are gonna get more responces than serious posts.... why? It's more fun and we all to have a lot of fun.

More people know how to have fun, than know how to program DMX.

I would have thought there would have been more posts to my informative Bellydance post. But "opps I did it again" made a post nobody cared about.

Are you still reading this? Geezzeee... any of it make ya smile? Not take yourself so seriously? I can keep going untill it does you know....

"Mr Spicoli, just what the hell do you think you are doing?! Having some food and learning about sound cards" :)

It is "OUR" time.......
 
Why would members send complaints to mods about certain posts? Treat it like a TV and change the channel.

Why do mods have to take everything so personal? Hi def is the only person I see complaining about Matt's post..

As for the comment about the good old boys club. I agree 100%. The # of members will be decreasing and then the Mods will be talking to just each other here.

TOS, TOS. That's all I keep hearing about. Not once have I seen this brought up on any other board like it is here. Dan you have to many chefs in the kitchen.

Yes before any of you mods get your panties tied in a bunch. I do like it here. I am allowed to state my opinion. Or is that against the TOS? I don't want to get the club and the sponsors mad.:sqerr:
 
First off, we never set out to be an ole' boy club, we started ODJT to get away from the favoritism often showed on other boards. Yes, the staff is often like minded but we do have our disagreements, believe me -- I think the staff forums could double as "Big Debates" at times. What matters is in the end we let the majority of mods rule. I've had my own posted deleted or edited more than a few times and I own the joint. Yeah I could be a arse and jump on whoever edited/deleted my posts but in hindsight they were right. Dare I admit it, I don't even want to visit my own forum at times due to the wars in the mod forums -- Yet I do most of the times kinks work out -- once in a blue I moon, I have to go -- This isn't going to fly and patch things up.

Bottom line: No one is stupid, they know when they've crossed the line. Us being a fair new forum, I noticed a lot of people have to test the waters -- That's okay we'll continue to be the coast guard. :)

You'll notice a lot of other sites don't mention the TOS (community guidelines, rules, etc) because it's selectively enforced. Kiss up to the boss and you're in, agree with a super mod you're in, etc etc. Here, we try our hardest to enforce equally. On other sites, they don't mention the TOS because when one of then "in" guys violate it, they staff doesn't want to be called on it.

In The mod house, if you could see it, you would see, we're a democracy the majority of votes rule. My opinion has been overruled many a times. Sure I could "pull rank" but that's not what ODJT is about. I like us as the "zany, off topic, we don't like you but we'll still visit" DJ board. :)

All in all guys, I personally respect each and everyone of you for one reason or another. :) But, I'm easy, I'm a bleeding heart and can empathize with just about anyone.

99.9% of the times when a moderator, super moderator or admin makes a statement publically (in the forums) about a member or membership issue, it's already been discussed in the mod house. The guy talking about it publically, is "the face" for the majority of mods.

For what ever my .02 is worth. I'd rather have 40 regular happy posters than 4000 posters at each others throat. That's why I was so hesitant to take on sponsors. But at the end of the days, bills need to be paid and it cannot always come out or my pocket or those that were kind enough to donate.
 
Why would members send complaints to mods about certain posts? Treat it like a TV and change the channel.

This is not something that happens on a daily basis and for the most part we let things slide. I'll give you an example though.

There were recent battles between 2 members going back and forth about Yo Momma jokes. These battles were waged in any and all forums and topics on this board. There were no limits. It really got out of hand and many threads were driven into the ground with this battle.

So is the staff supposed to sit back and relax and allow this board to become a locker room? No. We owe it to ourselves and our members to create a great networking site for all.

If some members leave because they feel we are "over moderating," don't you think other members will leave because they find the place filled with immaturity?

It really comes down to damned if you do, damed if you don't. We usually try to side with the lesser of 2 evils and any punishments agaisnt members are talked about in the mod areas for some time before administering anything.


Why do mods have to take everything so personal? Hi def is the only person I see complaining about Matt's post..

Members complain about posts because they actually interfere with a conversation they are having. Our members don't always publically say they have a problem. That's where we come in. They send the staff a message and then we deal with it.

You see me complaining about Matt's post because I am the one who received the angry PM from another member. I wouldn't have brought this matter up publically but Matt is the one who brought it up and I wanted to set the record straight.

Also, the matters are discussed in the mod areas for some time and when you see one staff member speasking he is speaking for the ENTIRE staff, not just himself.


As for the comment about the good old boys club. I agree 100%. The # of members will be decreasing and then the Mods will be talking to just each other here.

Show me evidence. We are consistently at around 120 unique visitors per day. That's well over 25% of our membership base visiting daily. That's pretty impressive.

TOS, TOS. That's all I keep hearing about. Not once have I seen this brought up on any other board like it is here. Dan you have to many chefs in the kitchen.


You don't see it brought up on other boards like DJ Chat because those threads get locked and/or deleted by the forum staff. Try having this same conversation over there and see how far it gets before the staff gets hold of it. That's why we are an OPEN DJ Community.


Yes before any of you mods get your panties tied in a bunch. I do like it here. I am allowed to state my opinion. Or is that against the TOS? I don't want to get the club and the sponsors mad.:sqerr:


Hope it helps.
 
And just to add to my above thread, how many times have you had a thread on a site like DJ Chat that was like this? There have been many threads where the members have questioned the mod staff and then 2 things happen.

1) The mods don't answer or simply delete the thread.

or

2) A mod will respond with something like "We do XYZ because that's the way it is so like it or leave!" and then they close the thread so the members can't respond.


We don't do that. We respond to you guys and work together.
 
Dan, for one so young,...... you have an incredible knowledge of people, and experiences. I really respect you and your intelligence.

And.....I don't have to kiss anyone's ASS, Including Yours.....

What you say here, is so pure in thought.....I commend you for being the one who you are, ODJT will survive, because of "Yours" and "OUR" dedication to the Professionalism, of "OUR" trade.

Please Don't wavier......You have got it "RIGHT"...................
 
I think he just hit the nail on the head... I've heard (even from other mods) that there is too much confusion as to who can do what.

Perhaps only ONE person should ban whereas the rest of the mods have "restricting" priviliges.

If there's any confusion it's because we're still trying to get our hands around everything. Simple as that. With each new occurrance we're setting new precedents.

FYI, there are only 2 members that I know are permanently banned and both were spammers.

We have in infraction system setup that all mods can use. Members are allowed 4 strikes. (5 if you really want to get into it.)


Pre Strike - The member is usually asked to refrain from his trouble making and such. This is for small mis steps. Any large mis steps and you go right to Strike 1.

Strike 1 - It's simple a verbal warning from the staff. It's basically the same as the pre strike but this one goes on your record.

Strike 2 - This is a temporary 7 day ban from the boards.

Strike 3 - This is a temporary 30 day ban from the boards.

Strike 4 - This is a permanent ban.

If you count the pre strikes then you have FIVE strikes before getting the boot. Any idea how many violations are allowed at other sites? No, you don't cause they seem to do it on a whim with no real plan.

If a user already has one strike against them and then does something to warrant another strike then the result is a 7 day ban. It's not the mod's fault for the ban, it's the users fault for not heeding the warnings.
 
Overmoderation? No. Overstupidation? That sounds about right. Various members are CONSTANTLY trying to push the limits around here.

Members are putting words in the mods mouths and making false accusations all the time.

This is yet another record-breaking thread--about the mods and this forum and how everything is not right and how we're going to be left with four members.

Let's stop wasting our energies then, report the posts that we think are "unfair", and send these forums into the right directions by posting something a little more relevant.

We are still here, griping and moaning. But we're still here. We are still here, still talking about how these forums stink and how they're going to fall. But we're still here. Let's do something constructive.

I get the feeling that if we WERE just as bad as the other sites, where there IS more controversy, we WOULD have MORE traffic. Judging by threads like this, which are generally the MOST VIEWED ones, perhaps we should just stop giving a crap.

IF YOU TRULY BELIEVE YOUR WORDS THEN YOU WOULD LEAVE BUT DEEP DOWN YOU KNOW THAT IT'S BETTER HERE AND THAT'S WHY YOU'RE STILL HERE. ALL OF YOU. I DON'T CARE WHO YOU ARE--ALL OF YOU WHO "DISAGREE" WITH THESE FORUMS.

FREAKING LEAVE. BUT YOU WON'T. BECAUSE IT'S TOO FREAKING GOOD HERE.

LEAVE.
 
Chris, thanks for the quick response... why Does Chris's ban say forever?

This is his first time being banned... so why wasn't it for 7 days?


Cbarron has 3 infractions so he is sitting for 30 days. Where does it say forever?

Not to delve too much into it, but he had a strike in March.

Then he got 2 quick strikes for insulting the board and staff members RIGHT AFTER READING THE TOS. There is proof of this.

If it was only one strike last week then it would be a 7 day ban. Instead, he lashed out multiple times so he received strikes for separate incidents, hence the 3rd strike and 30 day ban.

And Ace, we don't ban members. We give strikes or "infractions" as they're called here. 2 infractions equals 7 day vacation, 3 infractions equals 30 day vacation.

Get a 4th infraction and I hope you enjoy your stay at another chat board. lol
 
Easy, guys... easy. It's all good. :)

As to cbarron's removal, the TOS were indeed crossed via some rather unflattering comments in PMs to the staff. Yup, Dan got nailed too. Flaming via PM is still flaming. I hope this helps to explain the ban.

As admins, Dan, Jon and I are rather off-hands when it comes to that... we prefer to let the mods manage their forums. They do a fine job, I may add. :)

Off-topic comments and off-color jokes have a place here. It's called the Pub and Funny Farm. These forums were created for us all to let our hair down and remove the greasepaint. Members may opt out of these forums if desired.

My question: How many staff members can you name on the "other", mainstream forum sites who would take the time to PM one on one with a member over issues and get said issues resolved? While we're at it, how many of the site admins and webmeisters have been overruled by by the desires of the staff and members?

In my experience, few. I've had issues with "other" industry sites over the years. Issues addessed: None. That's why I'm here. That's why most of us are here. ODJT is not a dictatorship where staff rules by fiat. The rules apply to everyone from the webmeister to the newest member.

Here's some meat to go with yer taters: Had this thread been posted at the corporate sites, it would have been locked down pronto. No explanation, no go-to-hell, nothing. Case closed, next case.

And don't you just love it when the forum mod gets the last word in by talking down to members like they're a buncha little children? :rolleyes:

But I digress. ODJT may not be all things to all members. It helps to bear in mind that some members bring agendas of their own to our camp. :)

We have no agenda here. Because of this, we have members from several camps. This has put staff on the spot a time or two. Some of you guys don't get along too well with members of other camps. That's understandable. All I'm askin' is for you'ns all to refrain from flame wars.

The fact that this thread is open for comment speaks volumes for ODJT

Behave, will yas?. ;)
 
DJ JohnThe1 : I too,am tired of all this TOS TOS chatter. Blah blah ba-blah.

Ironically those bringing it up the most are the amongst the most troublesome, seem to lack the sensibility and decency to respect the feelings and moralities of their colleagues, and cop an attitude like everybody owes them something, as evidence by the time-outs being given by the mods.

For example:
Yes before any of you mods get your panties tied in a bunch. I do like it here. I am allowed to state my opinion. Or is that against the TOS? I don't want to get the club and the sponsors mad.
Do you really think this is a productive post? Reads more like another tantrum.

KellyS:
I agree that certain things should be off limits (race, faith, sex, politics).
It's good to see you agree, but that yardstick belongs to the Forum owners and adminsitrators.
If everyone just used their common sense, I believe that moderation wouldn't be necessary
How very true, yet unfortunately not all creations are given equal measures and suffer a deficiency of that particular vitamin.
I'm done with trying to get it or change it, I'm just going to deal with it.
Amen. Now if only that message would be embraced by everyone, this ba-lah ba-blah, me, me, me, crap would dry up and blow away.

Tyrone Blue :
If you cause trouble, rest assured that you're going to spend some time away from this forum
Your previous civil disobience, crowd control, and command presence training is showing!! ;>)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.