An analogy is speeding. In truth, most of us break the law every day by sometimes going over the posted speed limit. But the reality is most times if you just go over the speed limit but drive safely and in control, odds are you are not going to get a ticket. The law there is not gray, but the spirit of the law is to make people drive at a safe speed. The enforcement of it is certainly gray.

What i do know for is that if i am forced to use discs, i will no longer be in the business and will no longer be a customer of theirs.
The computer has simply become too good of a tool for me to give it up.
i certainly understand their concern for protecting their interest, but making legimate business people use discs will not even slow down people that are intent on stealing copyrighted materials. Disc copying has been going on for years.
amen brother....forget the details, the larger picture is that you are law abiding and speeding 2mph over limit....
burning the cd is like 4mph over limit
stealing is like stealing the car and speeding

Where is the control for "US" as businesses?? We still need to incorporate among ourselves to create some leverage no matter what we decide to do for our businesses. Waiting for the speed gun to stop us wont work. Waiting for the companies to dictate their rules and pricing wont work, We as businesses should be making the decisions for ourselves and working alongside eachother and our counterparts that make our businesses profitable or we all will lose.
Just my opinion....MV![]()
JT,
You are looking at it wrong!
When we copied the disc to a new format we are speeding at 10 mph over the limit, just as the guy who burned the disc, he too is speeding 10 MPH over the limit. The guy who bought the stolen car and got caught was still doing the same thing speeding 10 MPH over the limit, although he is in a stolen car, all three are still guilty of the same crime "speeding 10 MPH over the limit". The difference is that now he not only faces the speeding charge he also facing the receiving stolen property charge as well.
But honestly we are focusing on the speeding issue, if you already know a cop is setting up to catch speeders are you going to continue speeding in that area?
Does the computer count as "backing up" the material then?


righto steve, now I understand. Gosh, have you had to reteach this so many times? thanks for clarifying. I sure hope the RIAA has fun getting blood out of this turnip!
Mike,
Everybody did sit down years ago and decided what was fair. If you read it, it is called the COPY RIGHT LAWS.
Steve, how is it then that ASCAP/BMI can triple royalty fees in the clubs for their own benefit, but we cant raise our rates to make a decent wage.
Companies like Sound Choice and Stellar, decide who can and cant download their music etc,
We keep saying that we are ok, but that doesnt solve the problem or outcome each time it happens. Until we know the rules inside and out, each time will make it even harder on all of us.
That speed limit is really moving along now isnt it?? I dont see any cop with his speed gun out, but I see a lot of people ignoring the speed limit and getting away with it, and all we can do is go along for the ride.....MV![]()
My donkey.... USC 17 as well as all other laws are as clear as mud. What was 23 years from publication is now life plus seventy (Thank you Sonny Bono). Yeah, it used to be public domain but it's not public domain any more .... unless it is that is. Here's a good one. "The Jungle Book" published in 1897 but Kipling didn't die until 1946, is it public domain?
Microsoft wrote a ripper and put it in MediaPlayer. Now the way I read the law writing a ripper is a fellony so are we going to see Mr. Bill behind bars any time soon?
The law specifies that the information cannot be "fixed" to another media. I wouldn't consider a hard drive fixing. It's just another step in playing.
By the by, you can't rip music for private use either unless it is being used for educational purposes under "fair use." Even then you had better be a library just to be on the safe side.