Piracy issues and computer KJs

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
As far as calling any of it a gray area the pirates who have only purchased copied hard drives feel the same way, someone somewhere purchased the music so it is only copies and is covered under the fair use rule.

Apples and oranges my friend, apples and oranges.
 
Jay,

What is apples and Oranges?

They are either copies in use or they are origionals in use. Doesn't really matter how the copies were obtained using copies in a commercial venture is still the same violation of the copyright law.
 
KJ 1 bought all of his CDGs legally and converts them to mp3+g
KJ 2 bought a loaded hard drive illegally, does not own the CDGs.


Apples & oranges
 
Fees not royalties technically! Those fees are paid for by the venues you are playing in. Now if you are producing a show then yes you should be paying them and it is ASCAP, SESAC and BMI.

These are performance fees and really don't have anything to do with the "COPY"right law.

What about weddings and school dances?
 
Why does everyone assume some sort of gray area in the copyright law.

It isn't gray it is black and white!

You can make copies of songs from one format to another for your own use, it is covered under fair use.

You can not copy or transfer from one format to another for commercial gain!

There isn't anything gray about the wording. The only thing gray about this issue are those of us who do so and want to feel like we aren't violating the law.

As far as calling any of it a gray area the pirates who have only purchased copied hard drives feel the same way, someone somewhere purchased the music so it is only copies and is covered under the fair use rule.

Say it ain't so, tell me DJs really aren't that stupid!
Got to disagree here. There are a lot of gray areas. In the issue of format shifting. It's digital on the CD it's digital on your computer, the format does not shift until it becomes analog audio. Copyright law specifies "Fixing" a sound recording. I wouldn't call magnetic flux on a hard drive "Fixing."
The courts make the law up as they go along so we'll just have to wait and see. This, of course, is also illegal as it is "Expost Facto" and contrary to the federal constitution which the government has been ignoring since the civil war. It's one big gray area.
 
KJ 1 bought all of his CDGs legally and converts them to mp3+g
KJ 2 bought a loaded hard drive illegally, does not own the CDGs.


Apples & oranges


KJ 1 bought all of his CDGs legally and converts them to mp3+g for illegal commercial use.

KJ 2 bought a loaded hard drive illegally, does not own the CDGs.

Apples and apples they are both using products converted to another medium from the origionals for use in a commercial venture.
 
What about weddings and school dances?

What about them?

The vast majority of wedding receptions take place in venues such as Hotels, halls, etc. where the venue already pays ASCAP SESAC and BMI fees.

Again the venues and producers are responsible for those fees unless you are the producer you are not going to be hit by ASCAP and the others.
 
Got to disagree here. There are a lot of gray areas. In the issue of format shifting. It's digital on the CD it's digital on your computer, the format does not shift until it becomes analog audio. Copyright law specifies "Fixing" a sound recording. I wouldn't call magnetic flux on a hard drive "Fixing."
The courts make the law up as they go along so we'll just have to wait and see. This, of course, is also illegal as it is "Expost Facto" and contrary to the federal constitution which the government has been ignoring since the civil war. It's one big gray area.

it is still not gray to me the law says you have to use it in it's delivery form. To me that means as it is purchased. If it is purchased on a CD then it must be played from that CD.
 
What about them?

The vast majority of wedding receptions take place in venues such as Hotels, halls, etc. where the venue already pays ASCAP SESAC and BMI fees.

Again the venues and producers are responsible for those fees unless you are the producer you are not going to be hit by ASCAP and the others.

Cool....thanks for clearing this one up.

I've confused Copy with Fees.....
 
Fees for ASCAP,BMI, SESAC are performance fees for the legal right to play the music "in public" at a for profit establishment.

If you DJ/KJ only private events then you are not effected.

If you DJ/KJ in a bar, or nightclub etc for them, then the establishment is responsible for these fees.

If you are sponsoring your own DJ/KJ event that is open to the public and you charge admission, then YOU as the PROMOTER are responsible for the payment of these fees.

These fee have absolutely NOTHING to do with making copies of music. That falls under "Mechanical Reproduction Rights". Those rights are negotiated on a song by song basis based on the number of copies you wish to make. Most mechanicals are handled by the Harry Fox Agency.

Because of contractual obligations between artists and record labels, some songs are NOT available for licensing.

I hope this maybe clarifies things a bit.
 
it is still not gray to me the law says you have to use it in it's delivery form. To me that means as it is purchased. If it is purchased on a CD then it must be played from that CD.
It cannot be used in it's delivery form to produce analog audio which is the intent of the CD. It format shifts through 8-14 error correction, it format shifts through interleaving, it format shifts through two levels of Reed/Solomon error correction. Those are the required steps before it gets shipped out to the DAC which converts to analog audio. Better players have more shifting steps. What's the difference if one of those shifting steps is to MP3? It's not music until it comes out of the speakers. That's the gray area.
 
Then what is the problem with just playing the CD to begin with?
 
it is still not gray to me the law says you have to use it in it's delivery form. To me that means as it is purchased. If it is purchased on a CD then it must be played from that CD.

i'm no lawyer, but if some can argue and win in court that OJ didn't do it, or someone can argue that a twinkie made them kill someone, or someone can argue that someone shouldnt be allowed to drink from a fountain based on the color of their skin, then i think someone can successfully argue that transfering cd's to a computer is within the right of the beholder.....i would call it gray. Escpecially until someone gets prosecuted for buying legal cd's and/or cdg's and converting them. That's where the rubber meets the road. They all rely on past verdicts. Very few verdicts are ground breaking.
 
Scott,

I am no lawyer either and I don't want to play one on TV!

However if you are willing to take on the challenge to the Copyright law I for one will stand behind you and uphold your right to do so! ;>)
 
thanks Steve,
but the reality is no one is going to choose to fight it. If it ever happens, It's gonna be one of the people that get arrested for buying legal music and converting it. No one that i know of has been charged with such a crime that i know of. When it happens, i will be watching intently. Selfishly, i hope it isn't me. I can certainly understand where you are coming from and your arguement certainly makes sense. However, i do believe DJ's that buy legal music and convert cd's to computer are either not breaking the "spirit" of the law, or perhaps are, but are so far down on the scale of people to go after that DJ's need not worry. Maybe it's because so many people are outright stealing music that converts are not a priority.

An analogy is speeding. In truth, most of us break the law every day by sometimes going over the posted speed limit. But the reality is most times if you just go over the speed limit but drive safely and in control, odds are you are not going to get a ticket. The law there is not gray, but the spirit of the law is to make people drive at a safe speed. The enforcement of it is certainly gray.