What's Your Bit-Rate?

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

What's Your Bit-Rate?

  • 96

    Votes: 35 100.0%
  • 112

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 128

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 144

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 160

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 192

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 224

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 256

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 320

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other - Please specify

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    35
K

Kirby Ball

Guest
What bit-rate are you ripping your music onto your hard-drive?
 
Used to be VBR 32-320K. I always thought that the sound could be better, and the thought of sonically deficient music just because I'm a CPSDJ bothers me. Earlier this year I did yet another test with different CBRs and settled on CBR 320K. Sure, more disk space is eaten, but I want as close to the original signal as possible.

Can people tell the difference? I'd venture to say that 99% either can't or don't care. But I can and I do care. And that settles it.
 
so if you want as close to the original why not just use the wav file thats lossless.

What would be the difference in the amount of hard drive space used comparing 320 bit rate to wav?

Just curious, because I sure don't know the answer.


Thanks

Kirby
 
CBR (constant bit rate) records every part of every song at the same rate.


VBR (variabloe bit rate) records parts of the song at different rates. Just off the top off my head because that's the last CD I listened to, take Pearl Jam's "Better Man." It starts off low with a simply guitar playing. If you ripped this song in VBR than this part of the song would be recorded at something like 100. When the song starts picking up and more instruments, bass and vocals come in then the bit rate jumps to a much higher number.
 
Only problem with VBR, is some decoders have issues with them, and occasionally "burp" on VBRs when they transition. More work internally for the decoder (hence the CPU), so I prefer CBR for stability reasons.

I use CBR 320 for all my MP3s now (although 192 or better seems to work just fine and dandy for most DJ applications).

I prefer WAVs, but most apps don't support WAV tagging (our new library system can read and write basic ID3v1 type WAV tags though). Not the best if you need album art and lyrics though...
 
I've never had a problem with VBR using OTS. I ripped everything using OTS's ripping program.

I even converted my OTS files to mp3 for use in VDJ and again no problem.

I only have a problem when I play these mp3's in Winamp. A 3 minute song will show as being 22 minutes long in Winamp for whatever reason.

I also have no problem when importing these mp3's in Windows Media Player, ITunes, Sony Vegas, DVD Architecht or Iomega Hotburn.
 
This is interesting, I would have guessed that most would be using CBR, instead of VBR.

In the past, I have been ripping at 192 CBR and am thinking about bumping all new rips to 320 CBR since external hard drives are really affordable.
 
same here Kirby most of my new stuff 320. The thing is above 192 its all very similiar to a CD.......though some claim 320. A really crappy CD will still sound crappy at the highest CBR and a true quality digital recording will sound better than most even at 160.