This is just wrong!

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
Why do automobile companies put 120-mph on the speedometer when the speed limit is 70-mph max...:sqconfused:
So you can take them to the track and void the warranty :D:D:D:D:D or you live in Mexico where you can drive by a cop on the highway at 150 MPH and he won't even move because:
1. There's no way in hell they can catch you
2. There's no other cop around for hundreds of miles :D:D:D:D
End of high jack ;)
 
By the letter of the law, Rick is correct. Yet, all mobile DJ companies work with retail CDs. Well, those of us who are still CD-based, anyhow. Since we do private shows, we're good.

As to the ipod or robo-DJ stuff, this is not news. It's no competition with professional DJ companies. DIY music has always been with us. If some people want background music they can control, there's your market. Rick is right ~ renting music is a no-no in this country.

There will always be a market for the human aspect of entertainment. Machines will never make music, movies, comedians etc. It takes people to do these things. :)
 
It's also a violation to play it as a DJ. You CANNOT legally play store bought CDs, MP3's, etc., for anyone other than yourself.

I truly believe there in a misinterpretation of "not for commercial use"

I believe that "not for commercial use" simply means that purchasing this music doesn't eliminate venue fees such as ascap and the like, when they are due. Or if someone buys it and puts it in a juke box, they would still need to pay the bmi or ascap.

Since i've never heard any official government or group saying it's illegal for a dj to play legally purchased cd's or online music, and i've never heard of any dj getting in trouble for playing legally obtained music, it's not something i am the least bit worried about...they've got plenty of thieves to go after.

If I owned a company like promo only, and the only "legal" way for dj's to obtain music was through record pools like this, I certainly would be broadcasting that, wouldn't you?

but, since there has been no case that truly defines what "not for commercial use" really means in this instance, it's all speculation.

I forget the legal name of it, but there is legal term for not enforcing something and then calling it illegal. Record companies have sold 100's of millions and millions of copies of cd's and mp3's to dj's and dj companies....for them to let it go on and then suddenly argue that "not for commercial use" means dj's that have been buying and playing cd's for 20 years should suddenly not be allowed to use them....i think that would have a hard time standing up in court...if it ever got there.

If anyone thinks that this should be considered legal advice...think again....i am not a lawyer, it's simply my opinion
 
I truly believe there in a misinterpretation of "not for commercial use"

I believe you are correct Scott -- but the misinterpretation seems to be on the DJs side.

You can ask for someone to define "commercial" if you like, sorta like Uncle Billary asking to have "if" defined ;)

Just because you may not have seen any court judgments, does not mean it is not being enforced. Cease and Desist letters regularly get sent out, and are often answered by ceasing of the party that got the letter! That equals enforcement.

Even the DJ/Radio subscription services, have had to remove collections from their catalogs, as they were not in compliance.


True though, they usually only go after the big fish.


But the bottom line is, we all know exactly what commercial use means -- making a profit off of something. In this case, someone else's work!


Do I worry? No, I don't DJ anymore. Would I worry? No.

Just a technical point (unless the record companies get too hard up for cash flow) :)
 
Just because you may not have seen any court judgments, does not mean it is not being enforced. Cease and Desist letters regularly get sent out, and are often answered by ceasing of the party that got the letter! That equals enforcement.


:)

Rick,
do you know any dj's that have received a cease and desist letter from anyone telling them to stop playing store bought music or music purchased online?
I would love to talk to one of them or see a letter...because i have been wrong before...but it was so long ago, i cant remember what i was wrong about.:sqwink:
 
On the other side of this, how many times has a guest come to you asking who that song was by and what album was it on so they could go get it? It happened to me on Saturday.
 
DJing is a gray area of the law. As long as you didn't get your music bootleg, don't sweat it.

By looking at the latest RIAA stories so is downloading music :sqrolleyes: