The Knot.com?

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

bkthedj

New DJ
Jun 5, 2007
12
0
43
Alexandria, VA
www.bkthedj.com
Anyone advertised on the knot? It's a lot more expensive than anywhere else I've looked at for online advertising, but when my girlfriend and I were talking about wedding stuff the first place she went to was the knot, as do all of her friends.

To me, having her and all of her friends going there does tell me that people go there just wondering what peoples success have been with it.
 
I never advertised on the Knot and here's why:

Their message boards are unmonitored and allow the Knotties to mercilessly slam a vendor, the vendor cannot do a thing to state his case or clear his name, and everyone who reads the board doesn't give that vendor any consideration.

The boards are populated by DJs posing as brides. Case in point. Every so often, the Boston board will ask who's a good DJ and the same 4 or 5 names pop up all the time. Never anyone else. Coincidence?

Finally, if you do advertise, rarely do the Knotties ever mention any of the advertisers whose money keeps the site afloat! They'll promote or slam their own personal favorites, while the Knot just takes the advertisers money. I'm not saying that the advertisers should get only glowing posts, but they rarely get any posts, while those not paying a dime get all the exposure.

Trust me, more people will read the Knot boards than will ever click on a link to a vendor. I've had photographer friends around here pull their ads because they got tired of being number 200 on the list of local photographers. Now good marketing says that you want to be seen in the places with lots of advertisers because if the current advertisers weren't getting results, they'd pull their ad, but you do get lost in a sea of competitors.

For the money, invest in a good website, make sure it is properly indexed for the leading search engines and consider a more local website for your ads. Here we have a couple of regional sitess, one I created and recently sold (South Shore Weddings.com) and another called the Mass Wedding Guide. Both are local in scope, are much more cost-effective than the Knot and are able to give advertisers a bit more attention than the Knot.

I am sure that such a local site exists in your area. Give them primary consideration before taking such an expensive chance on the Knot.

That's my opinion.
 
I agree with John about their message boards with their (s)Knotties, but I just ignore that. My brides who come from the Knot tell me they don't visit the message boards.

I've been with the Knot for a number of years, and over the past couple, it has been my best ROI.
 
John is correct about TheKnot.

I haven't visited the site in some time now, mainly due to the poor treatment vendors receive. The bbs forums are (were) not well-regulated and people could post pretty much anything at all, for good or for bad.

Also, there were vendors posing as brides who were in cahoots to promote each others' businesses at every opportunity. I think that's just plain dishonest. :(
 
I'll admit it. I lurk on the Knot from time to time. I never post though. It's funny, but I see the same girls going on about DJ XXXXXX. He was the BEST at my wedding. And only $XXX.

The advertising on the Knot is a little spendy for my blood, but it works for some.