Problem with Mixer

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
Aug 9, 2006
2,367
8
51
Phoenix, AZ
Here's the Delema,

My Tascam X17 Mixer is having some Issues
(I have recently email Tascam, waiting for response)

Anytme I 'Y' my output to run Mono I Lose Bottom End.
This weekend I noticed that when I hooked both L & R to the Sub
I lost Bottom End, Unplugged either L or R and worked fine?

Solution for this Weekend I Ran Left to Sub & Left Side of Speakers
Then Ran Right to Right side of Speakers (Not through Sub)
This worked fine for the Time being.

Any thoughts?
 
Sounds like it could be a phasing issue. Try reversing the polarity of either patch cable (not both) and see if that takes care of it.

That being said, you need only one feed for lows. Stereo isn't needed for bass frequencies. I'm not familiar with your mixer so I will ask: does it offer a summed sub line out jack?
 
No Sub Out,

Here's the Mixer... Tascam X-17

I was able to use only one for the Sub, but.... it should work
Also having Issue when tryong to Y the L & R together
 
Wye Not - a recycled "classic" answer from October

Q: Can I wye?
A: Maybe.

Q: Can you be more specific?
A: The devil is in the details

Q: Are you always so helpful? Never mind, the question was rhetorical.

Q: Can I wye two powered speakers (or another type of input) to one output?
A: Maybe, uh usually

Q: You are just a font of info today. Mind telling me when I can and can’t?
A: No I don’t mind at all.

Q: So? What is the answer?
A: The answer to what? Oh, you mean to connecting one output to multiple inputs? Did you realize you wasted a question there and these answers don't come cheap? Generally but depending upon the output and input impedance. More than one input may be driven by one output (you may wye them). To answer the question with certainty you need to know the output and input impedances.

At this point the answer man goes into a trance. He repeats over and over in a mantra “Low impedance outputs drive high impedance inputs. Low impedance outputs drive high impedance inputs.”. After a time the answer man’s eyes open again and more questions follow.

Q: So that sounds like I can tie my two outputs (L & R) to drive this one big sub.
A: Never connect outputs directly together.

Q: So, I can never connect outputs?
A: Maybe.

The answer man goes back into a trance and for a time is lost to his mantra.
_____________________________________________________________

The two outputs are bucking one another. Each one is loading down the other. You may wye the outputs with a resistor network to sum the two outputs. You can [possibly] damage the output circuit(s) by directly connecting the two together.
 
Output Device - Tascam X 17 Mixer - Balanced L & R Outs

Imput Device - in this case was a SWA 1801 Sub with Balanced L & R Inputs



In this Setup no Y was Used
 
EK you've lost me.

If you don't wye the outputs it works.

Regardless, of any result, you should not directly wye outputs.

Is there something I'm missing?
 
The wye was a second example when I lose Bottom End,

Two Issues...

1. Wye so I can Go Mono Just to One Top (example)

2. No wye, L & R from Mixer to L & R to Active Sub (XLR)



Sorry Hard to explain when Typing!
 
Mackie recommended connections.

I was in the process of answering this thread when interrupted by one of the now legendary globe trotting calls by Ed the Salk.

Back to our regularly scheduled program:

In issue one, unless there is stereo/mono switch on the mixer you will need a summing circuit to properly provide a mono output.

In issue two, the sub has [should have?] a summing circuit built into it. I believe your 1801 does.

Connect the mixer to the sub first. The output of the balanced mixer should be connected to the 1801 sub's full range input. Use the sub's high-pass output to go on out to each 450 monitor on a stick. This configuration allows the lows to be reproduced by the 1801 sub and only the mids and highs to go on to the 450's.

This is the configuration is shown in your Mackie manual and provides the most efficient use of the equipment and available power. I believe you indicated that you connected the mixer to the 450's first. Connecting them first makes the 450's have to try to reproduce the lowest octaves making the low frequency amp in the 450 work much harder than it needs to when you have a sub to do that grunt work. Since a sub first connection is the way Mackie recommends it be hooked up when using one sub, it will most likely take care of the low frequency problem as well.

If this does not work, I believe there is something wrong with the 1801. As mentioned by Fred, the lows are largely omni-directional. You could if necessary just hook up one side of the mixer output to the sub. You shouldn't notice too much difference on most tracks and will provide you a temporary work around for the problem.
 
Balance, Thanks for you time in answering....

but,

No tops included....

Just Mixer to the Sub (Full range Input)
I lose the Botom end when only both XLRs L & R are plugged in

When I have Either L or R in the SUb Works fine, once I plug the Second XLR into the Sub thats when I lose the sound.

(Not a Sub Issue, as this setup works with other Mixers)

Strictly an Issue with the Mixer

(I should just call and describe the Issue
What are you doing around 3, 4 or 5 pm Eastern Time?
(I'm going to Sleep right now)

I'll check later, if anyone wants a call PM me with your TN
I call and describe the Issue later tonight (morning for Me)


Also please continue posting for additional thoughts
 
Before going any farther we must check out what Fred suggested earlier. If one of the cables from the mixer to the sub is reversed the signal will be summed 180 degrees out of phase. This will effectively cancel out the base. Be sure the XLR connections are as specified in the Mackie 1801 manual.

1 shield
2 hot (white) (+)
3 cold (black) (-)

Either ring them out with a meter or physically confirm the pin out on each by taking each connector apart.

Good luck EK. Let’s hope it is that simple. I apologize if some of the things we suggest have already been tried by you. Problems like this have to be gone through methodically not taking short cuts. This seems to be the most likely problem after re-reading your posts.
 
Mono the outputs from the player with a "Y" and then back again with another "Y" at the mixer inputs and see if you still have the same problem. If you do it would appear that there is a polarity problem on one of the channels in the Mixer itself. By monoing the from the players both left and right outs will supply mono combined signal with less chance of damaging anything.
 
Steve,

Under the circumstance I think that might complicate matters more than illuminate. First, it is possible to damage outputs by combining them with a wye connector. You may get away with it 99 times out of a hundred but that last time will cause grief. Inputs are high impedance. Outputs are low impedance. Each of the low impedance outputs tries to drive the other. If it exceeds the design you may pop an output driver chip. It isn’t good practice.

The design of the Tascam mixer in question is unbalanced inputs and balanced outs. It is unlikely to get a mixup on the unbalanced circuits so I’m unsure how that will help EK trouble shoot his problem. If all the ins and outs were balanced then I could see the logic not withstanding the previously raised advisory to not directly connect outputs. The easiest safest route is to either double check the cables as advised OR as Fred suggested simply reverse one of the cable’s wires on the # 2 & 3 pin to see if that eliminates the problem. The reason I suggest checking the cables is that I want to eliminate the possibility of this happening again if a standard cable is introduced to a non-standard set.

But yes, you are correct Steve, it too occurred to me that the mixer’s outputs could be out of phase but that is still less likely than one cable being reversed. It was not mentioned in an attempt to KISS or keep it simple stupid.

OR STEVE thinking of your suggestion simply unplug one side of the program source (CD player etc.) and see if that makes a difference as the sub will be no longer have a second channel 180 degrees out of phase with the other.

Whadaya think Steve?
 
[QUOTE=Under the circumstance I think that might complicate matters more than illuminate. First, it is possible to damage outputs by combining them with a wye connector. You may get away with it 99 times out of a hundred but that last time will cause grief. Inputs are high impedance. Outputs are low impedance. Each of the low impedance outputs tries to drive the other. If it exceeds the design you may pop an output driver chip. It isn’t good practice.


Actually the outputs of the player are high imp and the inputs of the mixer are high imp. I would much rather combine the outs of the player for a mono signal than I would the balanced outs of the mixer. With that said it is very easy to put together a "Y" using a resistor on each leg of the "Y" to prevent any damage. Personally I don't have that problem since my mixers have either a mono out or a mono switch.

By monoing from the player instead of the mixer he would be minimizing any chance of damage since the players will not be ampng the signal like the mixer does. the advantage is he will have two mono signals coming from the mixers outs (both left and right)

To the contrary if he is looking for ilumination on his problem monoing the players will give him the light. Then monoing the mixer if the same problem pops up he more than likely has a phasing problem with the mixer. Although it could be the problem comes entirely from combining the outputs from the mixer to begin with.
 
Just played around today with 6 Sets of XLR to XLR Cables
From Mixer to Sub (That's it right now, no wye)

Left to Left
Right to Right

Crossed
Left to Right
Right to Left

Attempted with 12 choose 2 (Factorial Combinations) XLR Cables
Still loosing Bottom end once I hook up the Second XLR
(BTW - Sub works fine with the same setup with a Numark 300 mixer)

I am currently awaiting a response from Tascam
But again, I am very interested in what you have to say,
so, if there is more, please continue.







-----------------------------------------------------------------
The wye attempt thing, I have only attempted this twice & right away
I knew there was something wrong, hasn't been attempted again.

The Only Reason for me wanting to wye in this situation to drop into mono was a 3 Speaker Setup, 2 Inside, 1 Outside, the one outside I wanted to parallel from one speaker, wasn't able to.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
 
EK hang in there kid -

Steve was suggesting a more complex test but how about something simple? Just play a CD with some base and pull one side of your signal source. You know, the RCA connector off the mixer input. Run it with only one side being input. Let's see if the base increases when you aren't summing two sides.

But leave both L & R XLR's connected.