I meant "bad" guy....whoops!
But to be honest none of the designs were horrible, its just that none of them screamed "PICK ME!! I AM THE SH!T YOU KNOW I SHOULD REPRESENT YOUR COMPANY"
I have seen logo proof sheets and usually I have a hard time picking my favorite 3, in this case its a hard time finding 1 favorite and I just think it wouldn't hurt to get another round of designs drafted. After all you don't want to re-brand yourself if this doesn't take off how you imagined it years down the road.
I'm just saying get something that your head over heals for becuase at the end of the day this logo will be in your face 24/7....biz cards, web site, letter head, tshirt/polo, vehicle, made into a gobo, etc....
You wouldn't marry an ugly woman to wake up next to everyday! Eventually you'll get sick of seeing her face and get a divorce, in your case another re-branding.....lol