Piracy issues and computer KJs

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
... really when is the last time your pc crashed out of the blue... never... it's usually the result of downloading some malicious software from the all powerfull internet we all love... if your pc never sees the internet the chances of it crashing are almost nil short of user error.

As an electronics engineer who repairs computers pretty much all day every day, I can't agree with this at all. Correct, the majority of computer problems are user/software related. However, I work on/replace (on a weekly basis I should add) many hardware problems such as replacing/resoldering power jacks on laptops (many! - and yes, technically avoidable I know) to failed motherboards, fans (which would render a laptop useless), optical drives (a TON), hard drives - especially in laptops!!! and many countless miscellaneous other problems.

I would NEVER in my life even THINK of relying or counting on a laptop (or desktop) alone, even if it has never seen the internet. Things always have a tendency to fail when you need them most... and I'm NOT going to wager that chance with clients.

I do use a laptop quite often during a show, for the quick requests or "do you have this song" 's, but I still play much/most from CDs. If I went completely digital I would have two laptop/desktops available whenever performing.

Lather, rinse, and repeat as desired.
 
As an electronics engineer who repairs computers pretty much all day every day, I can't agree with this at all. Correct, the majority of computer problems are user/software related. However, I work on/replace (on a weekly basis I should add) many hardware problems such as replacing/resoldering power jacks on laptops (many! - and yes, technically avoidable I know) to failed motherboards, fans (which would render a laptop useless), optical drives (a TON), hard drives - especially in laptops!!! and many countless miscellaneous other problems.

I would NEVER in my life even THINK of relying or counting on a laptop (or desktop) alone, even if it has never seen the internet. Things always have a tendency to fail when you need them most... and I'm NOT going to wager that chance with clients.

I do use a laptop quite often during a show, for the quick requests or "do you have this song" 's, but I still play much/most from CDs. If I went completely digital I would have two laptop/desktops available whenever performing.

Lather, rinse, and repeat as desired.

Point taken... however you are talking about failures that could be as much human as hardware... and could be power related... and i'm at a kj's level one user conditioned powersupplies....

Of course powersupplies and other hardware can fail... at inexplicable moments... however... these kinds of catostrophic failure are rare... when you have a fleet of computers that are maybe on questionable power supplies and being used by people that are basically power on power off types of people you will see higher failure rates... that I do not dispute....

I have been running the same pc for the last 2 1/2 years... never a crash never even a hint of disaster...

Now that said... let me put this in perspective for you... Amplifiers can blow... cd players can jam or quit.. and the list goes on...

anything man made will fail sooner or later... the point is the digital medium has a better track record over cd, records, and even tapes for reliable replay over and over and over again... it never chages it never skips it never gets degraded... its digital....

BTW, I don't travel without a backup pc and I also travel with a CDG player. But have never had to use either except for the CDG player to play a customers disc... I always have my discs with me for that just in case scenerio...

Thing of it is CD's are an outdated media and have lived far past their true usefullness...

The point I was making was that PC's can and are more reliable than the old media's that are easily scratched warped and otherwise mangled.... and in some cases irreplaceable.

Why should we be forced to use old outdated methods when better ones are available just because the manu says so...
 
crap i can't amend what i wrote... please disregard it... for the moment... what was said in the previous post is crap and i can't change it...

What I ment to say was this:

Any and all electronic devices be they, computers, amps, speakers, mixers, etc...

The real point I was trying to make but apparently it was taken the wrong way is this:

The digital media contained on a computer is less likely to fail or as likely to fail as is true with any electronic device. The thing is it is digital and well it will sound the same as the day it was recorded to the pc as it will years from now... CD's can't claim that.... they degrade with time, a long time. Which is great that was the point of CD's.

So why be afraid of it... you don't hold the same fear with your amp, speakers, etc... why fear the pc. if your amp fails and your pc is still running and you don't have a backup amp you still can't continue the show... I have a backup system both pc and analog.... I always carry two pc's and a cdg player... and as soon as I can I will also have a complete backup to every other piece in my rack. As should all jocks.

So don't fear the pc because it might fail.... protect yourself in case it does.

Whats really at issue here is manu's telling us we are criminals simply because we choose to use a media that is easier and probably better than the old school way of presenting our shows... and its about money....

The way the laws are written they don't include CDG's and it is not well defined as to what is legal and what is not because of that... so SC/Stlr's take is their opinion... no case law to support either side of the argument... so fellas and ladies we can argue the legality of 1:1 ops all day and all night and never resolve a thing.
 
Very good points. One thing about a spare PC is that it's not nearly as easy to grab a laptop out of the trailer and toss it in to use as an amp or mixer would be.

There's a lot more configuration with the laptop, and things change so much between shows - adding music, new playlists, etc.

That's why I purposefully keep my laptop VERY basic. All music is in a folder on the desktop, as are playlists. Easy to clone between computers.
 
Very good points. One thing about a spare PC is that it's not nearly as easy to grab a laptop out of the trailer and toss it in to use as an amp or mixer would be.

There's a lot more configuration with the laptop, and things change so much between shows - adding music, new playlists, etc.

That's why I purposefully keep my laptop VERY basic. All music is in a folder on the desktop, as are playlists. Easy to clone between computers.


Sure it's easy to pull out a laptop and throw it online... if you have everything on an external drive and you maintain both your show computer and your backup computer the same why wouldn't it be just as easy to change out a mixer vs a pc?

Sure you'd have to rebuild your show... for a kj thats simply means restoring your rotation and songs enqued which can be a PITA if you have too... or you can just let your singers relist the songs they wanted to sing... reallistically you could be back up and running in the time it takes to boot up your backup... if neither works well if your like me you also have a cdg player on hand...

This really belongs in its own topic and is really far off from the topic at hand... which is piracy.

I would like to continue this discussion tho I think it could benifit newbies and us old timers alike don't you?
 
Sure it's easy to pull out a laptop and throw it online... if you have everything on an external drive and you maintain both your show computer and your backup computer the same why wouldn't it be just as easy to change out a mixer vs a pc?

<snip>

I would like to continue this discussion tho I think it could benifit newbies and us old timers alike don't you?

Yeah I apologize for the off-topicness of this all. I guess my main point with that last reply you actually hit on the head: You need to maintain your backup as well as your #1.

With just about any other piece of backup gear, you basically plug it in and go. Maybe turn a dial or two. Not HARD to do, but a little more of a pain, especially in the middle of a busy show.

If more interest is shown I would continue this in its' own topic... If not let's get back to PIRACY!!!
 
Yo ho ho and a bottle of rum! If you have a back-up computer or hard drive using the same source CD, that's piracy. Use the computer as a player not a copier and all will be well.

But, I had a thought in my brain (yes, it did hurt) on this whole piracy issue.
Would anybody use a computer system that allowed you to cache a certain number of songs (say 20) instead of having your whole collection ripped to the hard drive? This would fall under the heading of "Ephemerol Recordings" which are permitted under US copyright law. You would have to haul the your CDs around but you could load them whenever you had time rather than when someone is pulling at your arm. You could still have your rotation sorted and your automatic bumper music and all the other computer goodies but the manus would't have a gripe. Would you use such a system?
 
Yo ho ho and a bottle of rum! If you have a back-up computer or hard drive using the same source CD, that's piracy. Use the computer as a player not a copier and all will be well.

Uhh no,

Piracy denotes distribution to non licensed / purchased parties. Backup is backup. If you keep your backups to yourself and don't share them, that doesn't make it piracy... Not one bit.
 
Uhh, yeah....

The only way computer based karaoke might be legal in the US is if you're using the computer as a player. COPIES ARE ILLEGAL. You bought a license for the life of the CD. It could be argued that it is necessary to have the tunes on your hard drive for purposes of playing, but having an extra hard drive is clearly archiving. Now, if you bought an additional CD, that's another thing entirely. The music can't be in two places at the same time.
 
Uhh, yeah....

The only way computer based karaoke might be legal in the US is if you're using the computer as a player. COPIES ARE ILLEGAL. You bought a license for the life of the CD. It could be argued that it is necessary to have the tunes on your hard drive for purposes of playing, but having an extra hard drive is clearly archiving. Now, if you bought an additional CD, that's another thing entirely. The music can't be in two places at the same time.

OMG my head hearts....

So your saying that if it were legal to shift my cdg discs to a hard drive that if I backed up that hard drive to another hard drive I'm in violation?

Dude that makes no sense at all. Now if you meant that if I use both at the same time that's a different story.

Copyright law as it is written today does allow copying of your cd's for archival purposes but doesn't allow for you to play from said copies in a comercial environment. It is perfectly ok if you are only using them for private use in your own home as long as your not profiting from their use or distributeing them.

So really weed what you said is not entirely accurate in regards to multiple copies.

If I misinterpreted what you posted I apologize.
 
I have one that happened Thursday night would one of the computer experts try to explain it for me.

I am running off of a laptop and external hard drive. I have not even had a glitch in the system since I started using it.

I am doing a private show Thursday night and this lady comes up to ask me a question and leans down near my LT suddenly it completely blanks there is nothing, no sound no video not even desk top just a blank screen. I freak and hit the reset and the screen pops back on I restart my progam and continue for 45 minutes, no problems. The same lady comes back up leans across my LT and bam! same thing happens. I run for another hour no problem. Many other people in the mean time have come up to talk to me, then the same lady returns and bam! it happens again. I tell her "do not come back up here you are screwing up my computer" she laughs and says she won't I had no problems the rest of the night nor any on Friday night.

I will tell you the rest of the story after the experts explain it!
 
OMG my head hearts....

So your saying that if it were legal to shift my cdg discs to a hard drive that if I backed up that hard drive to another hard drive I'm in violation?

Dude that makes no sense at all. Now if you meant that if I use both at the same time that's a different story.

Copyright law as it is written today does allow copying of your cd's for archival purposes but doesn't allow for you to play from said copies in a comercial environment. It is perfectly ok if you are only using them for private use in your own home as long as your not profiting from their use or distributeing them.

So really weed what you said is not entirely accurate in regards to multiple copies.

If I misinterpreted what you posted I apologize.

Well, you didn't misrepresent but I don't think you quite got the idea eather.
When you buy a karaoke CD it's different from a music CD in that it is aimed at professional KJs. Let's face it the only reason a non-kj has for buying a karaoke disk is so they can practice and wow them at the bar later. You don't need karaoke to sing. Karaoke disks are for KJs. No KJs-no market.

Now as to backing up a hard drive: It is necessary to place a music on a hard drive in order to use a computer as a player. Therefore, it is not a copy it's a cache. All digital players cache. A second copy of a hard drive however shows an intent to copy for purposes of extending the life of the music license beyond what which was intended. The license is for the life of the CD in normal use. While it's not supposed to wear out from playing, it is supposed to wear out from handling. That's why you can't make a copy of the hard drive, that's the way I see it anyway.
 
Well, you didn't misrepresent but I don't think you quite got the idea eather.
When you buy a karaoke CD it's different from a music CD in that it is aimed at professional KJs. Let's face it the only reason a non-kj has for buying a karaoke disk is so they can practice and wow them at the bar later. You don't need karaoke to sing. Karaoke disks are for KJs. No KJs-no market.

Now as to backing up a hard drive: It is necessary to place a music on a hard drive in order to use a computer as a player. Therefore, it is not a copy it's a cache. All digital players cache. A second copy of a hard drive however shows an intent to copy for purposes of extending the life of the music license beyond what which was intended. The license is for the life of the CD in normal use. While it's not supposed to wear out from playing, it is supposed to wear out from handling. That's why you can't make a copy of the hard drive, that's the way I see it anyway.


Your first point is correct and incorrect in a way... yes cdgs are primarily marketed to professional KJ and no there not. Have you ever read the piracy statements on them? They actually state:

"WARNING: This material is protected by federal copyright laws. Unauthorized duplication, public performance, or broadcast is a violation of applicable laws."

This statement both supports and debunks your entire argument. Take for instance "...Unauthorized duplication,..." That covers both digital shifting to a hard drive and coping to another CD.

Also look at "...public performance, or broadcast..." those cover professional KJ's in essance saying it is illegal for us to even play the disk in a public place and designates it for home or private use only.

EVERYBODY that converts to hard drive and then uses it in a commercial environment or uses the discs in a commercial environment is in violation according to SC anyway.

The laws do state the backups for archivel purposes are legit however, they then say you can't use them in a commercial environment. Really a catch 22. This is what has to change, this contradiction in terms of use.

As for your second point that a hard drive acts as a cache for the purpose of playing digital music... WTF? You're a computer guy a cache by definition is volital and anything stored in it once the power goes out is gone until you or your computer loads it again. I wouldn't try that argument in a court of law if the judge knows anything about computers.

So I'll say it again backing up a hard drive for archival purposes only is both illegal and legal. Its illegal because its still a format shift from the original cdg and legal because it is not being used it is simply a backup.
 
I have one that happened Thursday night would one of the computer experts try to explain it for me.

I am running off of a laptop and external hard drive. I have not even had a glitch in the system since I started using it.

I am doing a private show Thursday night and this lady comes up to ask me a question and leans down near my LT suddenly it completely blanks there is nothing, no sound no video not even desk top just a blank screen. I freak and hit the reset and the screen pops back on I restart my progam and continue for 45 minutes, no problems. The same lady comes back up leans across my LT and bam! same thing happens. I run for another hour no problem. Many other people in the mean time have come up to talk to me, then the same lady returns and bam! it happens again. I tell her "do not come back up here you are screwing up my computer" she laughs and says she won't I had no problems the rest of the night nor any on Friday night.

I will tell you the rest of the story after the experts explain it!

A little off topic but interesting... did she have any kind of electrical device such as a pacemaker?
Does your computer use bluetooth or infared technology to connect to other devices?

It's possible something on her person either had enough strenght to tell your pc to power down or at least go to sleep... like say a cell phone with bluetooth I've never heard of such a thing but stranger things have happened.

I think you need an exorcist.....:sqlaugh:
 
You hit it pretty close

I think you need an exorcist

I talked to her after the event, she can't wear any kind of watch even windups die on her in less than an hour.

She can't use computers they shutdown in seconds.

She can't use an Ipod or cell phone because of the buzzing noises.

And this is all from her body no other devices in or on her, she has been this way all of her life. She knew this when she came up to talk with me the first time.

And it is off topic but I thought the topic needed to be diverted LOL
 
Your first point is correct and incorrect in a way... yes cdgs are primarily marketed to professional KJ and no there not. Have you ever read the piracy statements on them? They actually state:

"WARNING: This material is protected by federal copyright laws. Unauthorized duplication, public performance, or broadcast is a violation of applicable laws."

This statement both supports and debunks your entire argument. Take for instance "...Unauthorized duplication,..." That covers both digital shifting to a hard drive and coping to another CD.

Also look at "...public performance, or broadcast..." those cover professional KJ's in essance saying it is illegal for us to even play the disk in a public place and designates it for home or private use only.

EVERYBODY that converts to hard drive and then uses it in a commercial environment or uses the discs in a commercial environment is in violation according to SC anyway.

The laws do state the backups for archivel purposes are legit however, they then say you can't use them in a commercial environment. Really a catch 22. This is what has to change, this contradiction in terms of use.

As for your second point that a hard drive acts as a cache for the purpose of playing digital music... WTF? You're a computer guy a cache by definition is volital and anything stored in it once the power goes out is gone until you or your computer loads it again. I wouldn't try that argument in a court of law if the judge knows anything about computers.

So I'll say it again backing up a hard drive for archival purposes only is both illegal and legal. Its illegal because its still a format shift from the original cdg and legal because it is not being used it is simply a backup.

The warning on the CD is just a CYA sort of thing. Kinda like, "Okay kid, I'll sell you the beer but you promise to take it home to your dad right?" Whose kidding who? Like I said before, no KJs-no market.

No, a cache is temporary storage. What form that storage takes is irrelavent. There is no such thing as digital music. People have analog ears. It's not a copy until you call it a copy. Violation of copyright is not a crime unless you knowingly violate copyright.

The intended purpose of the karaoke CD is to reporduce a copyrighted analog sound in a single instance in time and place. So long as that intended purpose in not altered I, for myself, see no infringement of copyright.
 
The warning on the CD is just a CYA sort of thing. Kinda like, "Okay kid, I'll sell you the beer but you promise to take it home to your dad right?" Whose kidding who? Like I said before, no KJs-no market.

ummmmm No. Ask them yourself. While they do condone home or private use they have a clear stance on public performance.

No, a cache is temporary storage. What form that storage takes is irrelavent. There is no such thing as digital music. People have analog ears. It's not a copy until you call it a copy. Violation of copyright is not a crime unless you knowingly violate copyright.

Ummm again, wrong. You are right a cache is temporary however, since the music is stored on a hard drive that is called storage just because a computer might push the data from the hard drive to a cache to play from does not make it legal and anyone that uses that argument is either (deleted).

Actually the sound that issues from speakers is neither analog nor digital its movement of air. You are argueing with an Ex-Navy Sonar man you can't win this argument.

Now a mp3+g IS a digital representation of the original digital CDDA+G but in a different format hense, format shifting. This is what the debate is about really, do we have the right to make this shift? SC and Stlr say, no. Is that fair? In there eyes it is to me it's not.

The intended purpose of the karaoke CD is to reporduce a copyrighted analog sound in a single instance in time and place. So long as that intended purpose in not altered I, for myself, see no infringement of copyright.

How can you say it hasn't been altered... . If you take CDDA+G and convert it to mp3+g you have already violated copyright laws as they are currently written. There is no middle ground no matter how you slice it.

I'm just as guilty as the next guy in doing this but I continue to do it because like you if I am a 1:1 KJ I don't see the problem.
 
ummmmm No. Ask them yourself. While they do condone home or private use they have a clear stance on public performance.
I did ask Sound Choice myself. Many times, publicly, on their forum. They declined to answer. At all, in any way. What can they say? Karaoke itself is illegal from that prospective. That puts them out of business.


Ummm again, wrong. You are right a cache is temporary however, since the music is stored on a hard drive that is called storage just because a computer might push the data from the hard drive to a cache to play from does not make it legal and anyone that uses that argument is either (deleted).
I am a "computer guy" and I cache where ever I find it most convienient. What do you think all those *.tmp files are for?

Actually the sound that issues from speakers is neither analog nor digital its movement of air. You are argueing with an Ex-Navy Sonar man you can't win this argument.
Kindly read what you wrote again ex-sonar guy. Don't you feel a little sheepish? Analog or Analogue refers to any continuous event in real time such as the movement of air. Sound is analog.

Now a mp3+g IS a digital representation of the original digital CDDA+G but in a different format hense, format shifting. This is what the debate is about really, do we have the right to make this shift? SC and Stlr say, no. Is that fair? In there eyes it is to me it's not.
No. MP3 is digital information. A binary file. An arrangement of truth table elements. A partuicular arrrangement of these can be copyright but not all arrangements of them. The sound is copyrighted, the graphics are copyrighted. Until it becomes sound and graphics again they haven't got a gripe.
 
obviously we can agree to disagree....

Any way you try to spin it you are wrong... and if you try to argue that cacheing your stored mp3 files is legal cause that's what a mp3 player does or even a cd player does is going to fail misserably.

The thing is this if you convert from CDG to mp3+g that is called format shifting and that is what they are saying is not legal.... no shifting doesn't make you a pirate but it is by definition illegal.

I know your arguement is this: If a cdg player converts from digital to analogue and back again over and over this is the same as format shifting... not quite but close see the difference is when you move it to a hard drive that is permanent what happens in the cdg player is temporary.

Oh and by the way I was refering to electrical signals when I stated what I did about air movement.... what I mean is the air movement is the physical interpretation of the signal and is not analogue in nature. Analogue for our purposes is an electrical signal. Consider this: why do you think they call it SPL instead of APL?
 
obviously we can agree to disagree....

The thing is this if you convert from CDG to mp3+g that is called format shifting and that is what they are saying is not legal.... no shifting doesn't make you a pirate but it is by definition illegal.


I know your arguement is this: If a cdg player converts from digital to analogue and back again over and over this is the same as format shifting... not quite but close see the difference is when you move it to a hard drive that is permanent what happens in the cdg player is temporary.

CD information shifts format at least 4 times before it hits the ADC. If format shifting is illegal, playing a CD is illegal.
The sequence of pits and lands on a CD can be copyrighted. The sound produced by playing the CD in normal operations is copyrighted. The processing I use which does not affect these copyrights is not a violation of these copyrights. There is no other copyright involved.

Oh and by the way I was refering to electrical signals when I stated what I did about air movement.... what I mean is the air movement is the physical interpretation of the signal and is not analogue in nature. Analogue for our purposes is an electrical signal. Consider this: why do you think they call it SPL instead of APL?
Sound Pressure Level is a term the speaker companies made up to sell speakers. Percieved sound does not relate well to electrical power. 20 watts at 20,000 Hz is enough to set every dog for a mile howling. 20 watts at 20 hz isn't even enough juice to move a good sized sub woofer. When you're talking electrical signals once again you are talking analogue. Nothing in the real world with the possible exception of Californium is instantainious and therefore is by nature analogue. The patern of the signal may be digitally described but the signal itself is analogue.