Piracy issues and computer KJs

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
I think you need to go back and re-read 17 again both before and after the Bono act.



There are legit uses for a ripper, and as far as I can tell there is no law against producing it, just against using it for illegal purposes. But if you have found something in the copyright laws that state that it is illegal please post it here.



The law states that a recording can not be copied, transfered fixed or broadcast without expressed written permission from the copyright holder of that recording.




You are right! Within the confines of commercial use.


COPYRIGHT ACT
Home > Legal Research > MegaLaw Topic Index > Copyright Law > Copyright Act
« 17 USC Sec. 106A | Index | 17 USC Sec. 108 »

17 USC Sec. 107 - Limitations on exclusive rights: Fair use



Notwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright. In determining whether the use made of a work in any particular case is a fair use the factors to be considered shall include -

(1) the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;

(2) the nature of the copyrighted work;

(3) the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and

(4) the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work. The fact that a work is unpublished shall not itself bar a finding of fair use if such finding is made upon consideration of all the above factors.

exweedfarmer:
You see, copying for any purpose other than educational is not covered under "fair use." But you're looking at the whole thing wrong. Conversion to MP3 is a step in playing, not copying. It is a more karaoke friendly interpretation.

As for legit uses for a ripper. In keeping with your way of thinking, name one.

I'll keep digging on the rest of it.
 
Ripping........

If I want to put a song that I have written and produced onto the internet.

Legit use.........
 
Ripping........

If I want to put a song that I have written and produced onto the internet.

Legit use.........

You recorded a song of your own, then put it on a CD in CDA format so you would have use a ripper to get it off? So you intentionally create the problem so that there is a need for a ripper. Noooooo! That won't fly, try again.
 
Try again since the desk system I use as well as most others burn directly to CD format there isn't any other way to do it.

Unless you have a secret way of doing it on Yamaha, Tascam or Roland recorders, if you do tell me about it.

BTW they all record and burn direct from WAVE.
 
I did a quick search at Musicians Friend and it seems most of their hard disk recorders ( i.e. TASCAM DP-01FX/CD ) have USB out so you can bypass the CD. You don't need a ripper for a WAV file (it's data). You only need a ripper for Red Book audio, which is to say CD music. PCM, WAV, and CDA are all pretty close to the same format I'm told although I generally only deal with WAV because I'm a Windows guy. Keep swinging.
 
I did a quick search at Musicians Friend and it seems most of their hard disk recorders ( i.e. TASCAM DP-01FX/CD ) have USB out so you can bypass the CD. You don't need a ripper for a WAV file (it's data). You only need a ripper for Red Book audio, which is to say CD music. PCM, WAV, and CDA are all pretty close to the same format I'm told although I generally only deal with WAV because I'm a Windows guy. Keep swinging.

I own a Tascam 2488 and it does have USB I also know that it can transfer the data to the computer as a data file for back up purposes unusable as a playable file it can import both the data file and wav. When you finish a song out and mix it down the only place that it can be sent is to the burner, which when it comes out it is red book. I also own a Roland 2400 it also has the very same problem that the Tascam has it's output is wav and has to be converted to some form of compressed file for internet use. But if the Tascam or Roland units you own will do it, perhaps you can walk me through the process. You certainly may be a lot more familar with them than I am, I have only been using them for 5 years.

Aparrently you are no longer familar with dial up internet connections. It takes me 20 minutes to up or down load a 128 MP3 file and I don't do 128's.
 
I looked up the 2488 (neat machine!) and it has a USB 2.0 connection that will export a WAV file according the the folks at Tascam. So what's the problem? No MP3 encoder?
 
Again Weed, give me the step by step instructions on how to get my completed mixed down song from the Roland or Tascam to my computer in MP3 format so that I can send it by e-mail. That's really all I need to know on the subject of recorders.

The Discussion has drifted far away from the threads subject here, but I am interested in your solution to my problem.

By the way getting back to the meat of the thread. Rippers are not illegal, products that are intended to break encryption are what you mistakenly confused with rippers
 
Steps to make an mp3....
1. Download the freeware LAME mp3 encoder.
2. If the Tascam will not export your mix as a stereo wave, bounce it to a couple of empty tracks first. (I doubt that will be necessary)
3. Transfer WAV file to computer via USB
4. Run LAME.
5. Play MP3 track to make sure it survived the process.

Yes, rippers are illegal. I would have written one and put it out with my playing software if they weren't. I'm kinda busy but I will find the statute again eventually but I'm trying to get my new player out by the middle of next month and the time is slipping away quickly.
 
Ok I just tried to send a mastered song from the Tascam through USB to the computer, it won't send the file as it is. It will send all raw track files as recorded for a particular song but it won't send them once it has been mastered, from that point the only place I can send it is directly to the burner.

Now I can pick up the raw files with Pro Tools and master there and rip the wav to mp3.
 
I hate to even get involved in this thread, but technically I don't think converting a wave to mp3 constitutes "ripping." I think ripping is just .cda>.mp3, correct?
 
I hate to even get involved in this thread, but technically I don't think converting a wave to mp3 constitutes "ripping." I think ripping is just .cda>.mp3, correct?


Ah converting WAV to MP3 is not the same as converting CD to MP3.
 
Back to the original topic...

There's another solution. Why don't we all stop doing karaoke. Just stop.

That means nobody's buying even one disc except maybe the home user and that really isn't a significant market.

So then where does that leave the karaoke companies?

Me, I do private parties only. I can take karaoke or leave it. I offer it as an add on and most of the time people say no because they don't want their drunk realtives that can't even lift a tune driving everybody away.

Just my 2% of $1.00.
 
Good idea GoodKnightDJ, but it would have to be all the Pro KJs or it would be meaningless. Just don't buy any new disks for a month.

Steve:
AWDJ is right, WAV is supposed to be data (although it is almost identical to CDA) and is not protected against copying as is CDA except by special software (the ripper) so WAV to MP3 is not an issue.

You might try e-mailing Tascam about exporting the master via USB. I have always been impressed with Tascam products and can't believe they would have left that out.

Here's, something slightly off topic but VERY interesting in the matter of copyrights. As Glenda the good witch of the North said. "It is usually best to begin at the beginning. " So, I went to the very first copyright law which is still in force and can be found in Artical 1 (Legislative Authority) section 8 of the US Constitution:

"To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries;"

Copyright belongs to the person, not the person's estate. Until a Constitution is amended, copyrights die with you.
 
Back to the original topic...

There's another solution. Why don't we all stop doing karaoke. Just stop.

That means nobody's buying even one disc except maybe the home user and that really isn't a significant market.

So then where does that leave the karaoke companies?


$70,000+ of my company income is from Karaoke bar shows (everyone may not be the greatest singer but there are a lot who are damn good)

Honestly I believe the home market is a larger share of the sales than KJs are.
My supplier told me that 80% of her disc sales are to non-KJs

It leaves them without a bunch of KJs ripping off their product and selling it on loaded hard drives to others who will become "instant" KJs who delute the market even more.
 
Honestly I believe the home market is a larger share of the sales than KJs are.
My supplier told me that 80% of her disc sales are to non-KJs

It leaves them without a bunch of KJs ripping off their product and selling it on loaded hard drives to others who will become "instant" KJs who delute the market even more.
That is a good point however, I don't believe that all of those home buyers are purchasing disks so they can sing to their walls all by themselves. They are practicing to come out and wow the crowd. If that is the case, if we stop buying new disks they will stop buying new disks or bring their disk in and ask us to play it. We simply decline and briefly explain our problem. It will hurt for a while but let's face it all those "singers" aren't the ones who buy all the booze. We don't really need them. The party will go on.
 
COPYRIGHT ACT
Home > Legal Research > MegaLaw Topic Index > Copyright Law > Copyright Act
« 17 USC Sec. 106A | Index | 17 USC Sec. 108 »

17 USC Sec. 107 - Limitations on exclusive rights: Fair use

exweedfarmer:
You see, copying for any purpose other than educational is not covered under "fair use."
I'll keep digging on the rest of it.

Thry this one:

Act34 AHRA, an amendment to the federal copyright law.