Randy, I'm copying you. Not just stealing your idea (and verbage) but I'm doing a 2-week post boost to see if this method works across the board or to see if it's a fluke to your market. I'd like to compare notes with you (and anyone else who wants to follow suit) and let's see if we can all help each other out to hone it down to the most effective method we can find.
In looking back, some of my most successful craigslist ads were where I painted a visual, just like you did. I've somehow diverted my approach and fallen into the "talking about my product" pitch instead of tapping emotion. I took your great opening visual, tweaked the wording slightly, then made a post on my business page with a coupon photo included (offering a $250 discount). I boosted it with a $50, two-week run, my geographical area, women 20-55 (to catch MOBs), interests which include several "wedding" keywords, and either single/in-a-relationship/engaged. Here is a copy of the boosted post.
Ryan Photo-DJ-Lighting
I currently have 649 likes, which are mostly that same target audience that I've built with "Get Likes" ads over the past several months. Not sure if this boosted post will hit my existing "Liked" users or if it will deliver to a completely different audience. I hope you won't mind me using your opening visual. If you do, just say the word and I'll pull it, create my own, and keep the results to myself. If it's okay with you though, I'd like to run this, then compare notes to see if we come up with similar results. I think if several guys here would run their own version, and coordinate results, we might be able to help each other out. What do you think?