There's a great deal of truth to that. The BBB does not recommend specific businesses nor direct business leads to proprietors. All they are is a de facto clearinghouse for consumer inquiries. If a consumer inquires about a specific business that's not a BBB member, the BBB can't help.
Likewise, they can't log a complaint against a company that isn't a member. Legal issues...
In the old days, a BBB plaque hanging on the office wall meant something to consumers. They were everywhere then ~ doctor and dentist offices, grocery stores, dry cleaners... And many of 'em made mention of it in their YP ads. One doesn't see that much anymore.
They've become unnecessary today. The Internet has superseded the need for the BBB. One may find out all he or she wishes to know about a business with just a few keystrokes.
To be honest, I can't recall the last time I saw a BBB plaque. It's been a long time.