Most Overrated Artists Or Songs

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

Jeff Romard

Administrator
Staff member
ODJT Supporter
Sep 4, 2006
22,673
22,936
56
Sydney, Nova Scotia
In response to chucks thread...Who do you think gets way more credit than they deserve?
 
I'll go first...Bob Dylan. I've always felt that he was WAY overrated. He did some stuff that was good mabye even great but gets alot more credit than he deserves.
 
You all are gonna shoot me for this post but I reckon I'll just have to be full of holes, lol.

In this old dog's humble opinion, Peter Frampton has got to be the most overrated recording artist ever.

There. I done gone and said it. :D

If it's any help, I grew up with Dylan's music. He's a great poet but a lousy singer. Two songs he released I like ~ Knockin' On Heaven's Door and Lay, Lady Lay. All the rest are nasal-sounding.

Feel free to shoot me fulla holes. :D
 
You all are gonna shoot me for this post but I reckon I'll just have to be full of holes, lol.

In this old dog's humble opinion, Peter Frampton has got to be the most overrated recording artist ever.

There. I done gone and said it. :D

He would be on my list too Fred. he got credit for alot more than he ever achieved
 
Where's "Jeremiah's Can O Worms" when we need it! :sqwink:

I'll avoid the obvious (hard-core rap) and stick within the rock realm.. :D

In no particular order...and don't flame me, this is just my "biased-opinion".

I've listened to these bands numerous times and just find them boring.

Pearl Jam
Oasis
Smashing Pumpkins
Sex Pistols
Coldplay
 
Ill add Nirvana to my list
 
I would have added them, too...but I didn't want to write a book...so I figured I'd stop right where I was....

Carry on! :D

I am going one at a time...Saves the head and ups the post count :sqwink:
 
Ok, I just recovered from the heart attack of Kirby saying Oasis is over rated. Hands down the best pure rock band to come out in the last 25 years, if you have never seen them live, you will not be able to understand it.

Now, onto the topic. My list starts, begins and ends with Nirvana. Horrific musicians, cliched songwriting and built completely and totally on marketing and not originality. They in no way started a trend (Pearl Jam's 10 was released 8 months before Nevermind, not to mention bands like Screaming Trees and Mother Love Bone/Alice In Chains had been around Seattle forever). I have said it before, and will always say it (and here comes the wow you are being way to harsh and cold statement): you want to become immortalized in rock? Kill yourself. You are instantly a God.

I also think The Doors are completely overrated. They simply took what had been around England for years and commercialized it for America.

On the country side, without a doubt my over rated nod does to Faith Hill. Her voice is just completely grating to me, and she is a horrible live performer.
 
LOL, sorry to give you heart failure Patrick! :) I'll be more careful with my posts in the future....:sqwink:

True, I've never seen them live and that might make the world of difference. :sqbiggrin:
 
Nine inch nails (down a chalkboard)
 
I agree that Faith Hill and Shania Twain are overrated as artists. But their performer meters ain't too shabby. People buy it. :)
 
I'll go first...Bob Dylan. I've always felt that he was WAY overrated. He did some stuff that was good mabye even great but gets alot more credit than he deserves.


I'll go one much further.... most of that stuff from Hippies in the 60's.... That whole decade was overrated, IMO, with the exception of Motown, and "possibly" the Beatles....

And I am a HUGE Peter Frampton fan... I say he is UNderrated.
 
Au contraire!!

Peter Frampton is a hell of a guitar player. Admittedly, he hit his peak in 1976 with Frampton Comes Alive, but he deserves acclaim, nonetheless.

Have you ever seen him live? I have, several times, and he's an excellent showman too. Like Papa, I am a HUGE Frampton fan!!