Another Sign American Idol Is Losing Steam....

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
I only like the auditions. I can do without the rest. However I will say that Catherine McPhee was freaking hot! (My uh wife watchs...and I uh, may have caught, um, cough...a few episodes.)
 
We love the show, and we have been to the concerts they put on for the last 3 years........It's good family entertainment............
 
Question, since they are using percentages...are the sizes of the venues this year smaller, larger or the same? Just curious.


Mostly the same. But I think Patrick doesn't understand the whole situation, as I bet he he rarely, if ever, watches AI.

This year's batch of contestants were TERRIBLE compared to those in prior years. Absolutely abysmal. And most had ZERO personality to go along with their lack of singing skills....

And thus, you have less attendance. This was an aberration.
 
Mostly the same. But I think Patrick doesn't understand the whole situation, as I bet he he rarely, if ever, watches AI.

This year's batch of contestants were TERRIBLE compared to those in prior years. Absolutely abysmal. And most had ZERO personality to go along with their lack of singing skills....

And thus, you have less attendance. This was an aberration.

Actually, I have watched every episode since the inception of the show.

And (ssshhh) after the tour is over, I will be announcing a very special new client.
 
Actually, I have watched every episode since the inception of the show.

And (ssshhh) after the tour is over, I will be announcing a very special new client.

But you don't even really ever seem to like the show, IIRC?

In any case, I think last season was a fluke, and we all knew it early on. Think about it... a beat box guy came in 2nd, for crying out loud... :sqerr:

Simon Cowell?
 
But you don't even really ever seem to like the show, IIRC?

In any case, I think last season was a fluke, and we all knew it early on. Think about it... a beat box guy came in 2nd, for crying out loud... :sqerr:

Simon Cowell?

I like the concept of the show. I just don't think it is done right.

I hate the circus atmosphere of the auditions, and I don't think that people who are in the industry (ie, professional back up singers) should be allowed to compete.

I also hate how one day, the judges put through people who they say "are the best singers I ever heard" and then the next day, they are bad they make them sick. I hate the over the top nature of the judging.

Yes, I would agree that this year was by far the worst year for talent.
 
actually I seem to see better over all talent on Canadian Idol though its not so much the circus act of AI. The only thing I dont like is at times the judges are too nice to all of the singers.
 
Although I personally can't stand the show or it's competitive aspect, it has certainly been a bit of a boost for Karaoke. Guess I HAVE to root for it....
 
I don't like the fact that the show caters to the "instant celebrity" pop culture mindset.

Give me an artist who has honed his or her craft over the years and been in the trenches of the music biz, not some neophyte who has been a shower-singer all of his or her life and suddenly wants to be a star with a recording contract!
 
I don't like the fact that the show caters to the "instant celebrity" pop culture mindset.

Give me an artist who has honed his or her craft over the years and been in the trenches of the music biz, not some neophyte who has been a shower-singer all of his or her life and suddenly wants to be a star with a recording contract!

I am hoping the new one they have starting this next week, The Next Great American Band, is more like this concept.
 
I'd like to clarify that said singer or band should have paid his or her dues by playing the bar/club circuit for a few years first, not by going from the shower stall to the recording studio!
 
I don't care if they spend 5 minutes in their whole life paying dues. If they have "it", then I want to hear "it". Bryan, how else would you have any younger pop singers?

Still, I'm sure all the young singers sing whenever given a chance. Christina Aguilera was only 8, in 1988, when she appeared on Star Search. She has been a pop star for about 10 years now, correct?
 
Chuck: By paying their dues.

BTW, I can't stand to hear Christina Aguilera sing! I think her vocal style is horrendous.