Still doubt the smoking ban's effects?

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

JoeChartreuse

New DJ
Dec 12, 2006
3,934
1
70
Bergen County, NJ
In the last 3 months, SEVEN bars within 20 minutes of me either closed or changed hands. These were long time places with good track records until the ban. I happen to know ALL of the owners, and ALL SEVEN attributed their closings to the ban.

I can't express how angry this makes me. The "poor waitresses that have to work while inhaling second-hand smoke" that were supposed to be a major reason for the ban are on the streets looking for work. Bartenders keep being hired just to quit due to lack of tips- their income. Since distributors are selling less, their prices are up, raising drink prices at the bar, hurting business even more.

This isn't about whether smoking is healthy- it's not. This is about government intrusion on the right to earn a living, and intrusion onto private property. Yup, I said private property. Unlike public property, which is paid for by tax dollars, and is a neccesity ( like police stations, municipal buildings, etc.), bars are private property that the owners open to the public. You go in if you WANT to. These places are paid for by the sweat and work and huge amounts of money that the business owners lay out.

Just so you know: by allowing a law to be passed regulating smoking in these privately owned buildings, the gate has been opened to do the same in YOUR HOME. In the eyes of the law, there is very little difference between privately owned properties. Except of course, if you have the money and resources of say, the the casinos in Atlantic City.

In short, we've been lied to and screwed by the government once again. However, the blame rests not on the government ( we don't expect honorable behavior from that source ) but on A) The voters who listen to pretty speeches but don't do the research to check the facts, and B) Those who would lie and cheat to impose their way of doing things on others.

As far as the bar issue goes: The fair thing to do would have been one of the following:

1) Since it's the bar owner's money invested, let the owner make the choices. If the majority of income comes from non-smokers, and he/she wants to keep them happy, then no smoking would be the way to go. If the money comes from smokers- so be it. Then post large signs outside indicating whether the bar is smoking or non-smoking. Remenber, people go into bars because they WANT to. it's their choice. go in or keep moving.


2) Non-smokers work hard, invest their money, and open non-smoking bars. Wonder why no one tried that????:sqcool:



You know what's funny? Another reason the bars are dying is that the non-smokers aren't coming in, because their not having as much fun, I'm told- because the bars are quieter...
 
Same thing's happening here. I say we tax all the non smokers on all their food items in restaurants to the same 43 cents on the dollar, and use it to retrain all the displaced workers. Smokers will, of course, be exempt. They already pay a similar tax when they buy cigarettes.

Simple law. For every dollar you spend on food, 43 cents more gets added as a food tax. You gotta eat. You made the choice. Now pay for it.

Papa? Sound good now?

Public health is a lame excuse to get rid of something that isn't politically correct. If smoking is bad for you, BAN IT. But don't take money from smokers for the use of tobacco. Ban that too. Eat the billions of tax dollars that tobacco revenues generates, and the tax money that the smoky bars used to put in the coffers. All will be healthier....even if unemployed. Until the government refuses the money from cigarettes, there's no legal, ethical, or moral basis for the law. It's all a two-faced smoke screen (pun intended.)

And before I get flamed, I want to note that I'm a non smoker. But i believe the bar owners have a right to run their business as they see fit. Where are all the non smoking bars, if they make money??

Right.......they don't. Leave my rights alone.
 
...and intrusion onto private property.

Not sure 'private property' exists anymore :sqerr:


When I'm 'elected' Dictator In Chief (DIC), I promise to put a ban on bans!


I don't go to bars in NY anymore, because I can't smoke -- and I order beer by the pallet -- seriously lost revenue, because I would probably be out in the bar...:sqwink:
 
I see the same effects here, Joe. Bars that used to rock until 4 AM (NY last call time) now close at 2 AM and have since the ban went into effect here. 1 or 2 of the local places are still allowing smoking they just put out paper cups and risk getting slammed with a fine.

Smokers are people too. The government's idea to tax them out of our ability to pay for them, is just plain dumb. They're just as bad as the tobacco companies who knew cigarettes were back for you back in the 50's yet still marketed & sold them. Once you're addicted, you're addicted you will buy smokes weather it's $5 or $25 a pack.

I've always said someone else's right to live their life the way they choose shouldn't impede on my right to do the same. Don't smoke? Don't go to smoking restruants.. Don't whine and cry until legislation is passed to ban it everywhere. Where there is consumer demand, business will follow to fill that need.

It's getting worse, you cannot smoke on the grounds of one hospital in my area. You face a $100 fine if you do so.. This isn't at the just at the entrances, this is anywhere, even sitting in your car in the parking lot across the street!

I was at the DMV just the other day, stepped outside for a smoke and was asked to stand in the parking lot and smoke instead of on the sidewalk (by the ashtray) by a sheriff. Luckily, I was in a good mood that day..

It's a dam shame.
 
Hey, check this out -- know those receipts you sign in the bar -- they were printed!

I'm suing, that should be banned :sqerr: :sqlaugh:


How safe is your printer?

lol, read that they other day. Yeeshm wasn't the carpel tunnel thing bad enough? Now the office really is a hazardous work environment. :sqeek::sqlaugh:
 
I've smoked for a long time, but never felt comfortable smoking around others that do not smoke. No smoking laws in clubs and restaurants doesn't bother me in the least. I, like others, just go outside and have a smoke. Yeah, it's a little inconvenient, but....................

There has to be a level playing field, meaning all the bars have to enforce this law so one doesn't have an advantage over the other. This being the case, is everyone going to stay home and not go out and drink or will the law be more acceptable if there is no alternative?

As far as continually taxing cigarettes in an effort to get people to quit, it ain't gonna happen. The person will just spend the extra bucks. By taking more and more out of the smokers pocket, who is really getting hurt? The government is not just punishing the smoker, but his family also.
 
its hurting the local economy by taking economic spending dollars which are lost from the taxed upon taxed smokers.
 
First, I want to state that this is not directed to any one person at all, but in general about the smoking ban.

I am sooooo tired of smokers saying that have the "right" to smoke. No, you don't. Smoking is a choice you make do to. Just like I make a choice to eat a piece of cake or drink a Coke.

The biggest difference is that me drinking a Coke is going to cause my medical insurance to rise, or cause the person I am standing beside to get a disease because of me doing it, or cause me to have to go home and disinfect all the clothes I am wearing. All of which smoking does.

Just as you feel you have a "right" to smoke, I have the "right" to go into a place, enjoy the company of friends, enjoy the atmosphere, band, dj or whatever else the bar may be offering, without getting cancer just by stepping into the place.

Smokers who want to use the domino theory of private property are missing the point. If you think the government is overstepping its bounds by banning smoking in bars and restaurants, then you must be in favor of not letting people in because they are Black, Latin, White or a women. You must be in favor of being able to say "no, you can't come in because I know you don't drink". Or even better, you must be in favor of no bar owner ever being responsible for a DUI which occurs because they have over served someone because after all, it is private property and the owner can do whatever he wants.

As some of you know, I had some medical problems last year (and still do). When I was at the doctor, I was told that I needed to stop smoking because my lungs were working at only 75% capacity. Here's the catch, I have never in my life smoked, drank or done any illegal drug at all. It all came from working in bars for 15 years.

So no one will ever be able to tell me that there is no such thing as second hand smoke damage. And just as any smoker claims they have a right to smoke anywhere they want, I have the right to earn a living, and while doing so, I have the right to work in a healthy environment.
 
It's been much the same since Delaware banned smoking in public places. We can still smoke outside, though. :D

Well, except for Kent General Hospital, that is. They recently banned smoking anywhere on the grounds.

The only exceptions to the ban are taprooms... private clubs like the Moose, American Legion etc ~ and that's for the members-only section. Rented party areas are no smoking.

It has hurt a lot of the bars around these parts. And the slots... boy, the smoking ban really tipped their apple carts over. When people are standing outside smoking they're not inside feeding the slots. Slots patrons are mostly smokers.

I don't care for the guv'mint playing Hitler any more than anyone else. The smoking ban wasn't put up for vote ~ the governor simply said "This is the way it's gonna be" and shoved it through the local legislature. If the stats are to be believed, fewer than half of the voting public smokes. So, were it put to a vote it would have passed, right?

As far as businesses having the choice, that sounds good but it really isn't doable in practice. Even if just 30% of the state's population smokes, that 30% is over 70% of your bar patronage. Opening a smoke-free bar would not be what I would call a sound business plan.

Were this not the case, the bar biz wouldn't have suffered a drop in business after the ban was enacted.

Restaurants are a different story. Smoke-free dining is understandable. Patrons who buy dinner and slip out for a smoke are still buying dinner.

And folks, don't laugh at nor dismiss Rick's sage advice yet. With all the do-gooders jumping on the bandwagon lately, it's only a matter of time before smoking in your home brings you to the attention of child welfare authorities. High schools banned smoking on the grounds many years ago. If you DJ a school dance, don't use a Marlboro grip as a gig bag.

If you have pups and someone in your home smokes, wait for it. Oh you'll be given a choice. Stop smoking in your home or risk being declared unfit parents and losing your pups to foster homes. It's coming to that. :(

That being said, statewide smoking bans are (in my humble opinion) a textbook example of a double standard. States tax tobacco and depend upon the tax income. Then the states ban smoking in public places. What message are our elected representatives trying to deliver? We want you to buy it but we don't permit you to use it?

Here's what I think: The surgeon general has determined that your complaining about my smoking may be hazardous to your health. :D
 
And folks, don't laugh at nor dismiss Rick's sage advice yet. With all the do-gooders jumping on the bandwagon lately, it's only a matter of time before smoking in your home brings you to the attention of child welfare authorities. High schools banned smoking on the grounds many years ago. If you DJ a school dance, don't use a Marlboro grip as a gig bag.

If you have pups and someone in your home smokes, wait for it. Oh you'll be given a choice. Stop smoking in your home or risk being declared unfit parents and losing your pups to foster homes. It's coming to that. :(

And that is exactly how it should be. Smoking around a child is just as much a form as child abuse as beating them. Worse in fact because it creates permanent damage to them.

If you smoke and find my comments offensive, they are not meant to be. But I will not apologize, because the billion dollar smoking industry has convinced everyone that anyone who is against smoking is un-American. But the truth is, there zero, let me repeat, zero benefits to using an type of tobacco. Be it cigerettes, a pipe, or snuff.
 
No offense taken, Pat. You know me well. :)

It's just that I seem to have a problem with people of like mind who form PIRGs (public interest research groups) with an obvious agenda then attempt to force their personal beliefs upon the rest of the country.

Should a pup be forced to grow up in a house filled with cigarette smoke? No, I don't think so. Should the local guv'mint be permitted to usurp a parent's civil rights and take said pup away? Again, I don't think so. The decision, if any cannot be made by me. :)

The only thing that's blocking the road of neo Nazi control is the fact that tobacco is a legal vice. States' taxing of tobacco, ie sin tax is in essence an agreement that smoking is condoned and encouraged.

Tell people to quit smoking then raise the tax on tobacco to subsidize the failing highway department. What the heck kind of message is that? The pols can't have it both ways.

From personal experience, our father smoked. We all grew up with it. One sister had sever asthma as a pup. The other sister developed asthma later in years. My brother and I seemed to suffer no ill effects for some reason. For good or for bad, we all turned out OK.

The alcohol abuse is another story altogether. If only our father's smoking were the worst part, lol. ;)
 
Then why don't we just ban alcohol also. Oh wait they tried that. Think about it though, if smoking is killing people because of second hand smoke what about all the people who die because someone drove drunk and hit somebody killing them. To me its the same thing. Someone is paying the price with their lives or families are being torn apart.

Soda has caffine in it, coffee has caffine in it and medically speaking those things are addictive and have been proven to not be good for us. Do we ban them also. The foods you eat are filled with chemicals or preservatives that if taken in great quantities would/could kill you, yet we will continue to pollute our bodies with these things till our bodies either grow obese or begin to break down slowly.

We as dj dont have to work bar gigs yet we do so its our own fault that we work in that enviroment. Those of you running your own business are doing so why. Most likely some of the same reasons that bar owners are running theirs. The ability to be your own boss yet now the goverment wants to step in and so no no no we know whats best. Sorry I dont buy it. If you dont want to be in a room filled with smoke its rather simple.......leave or dont go in
 
all that said, Joe, I am still all for the ban. When I go into a bar I feel much better.

A) I guess you don't work bar venues

B) You aren't close to people in the bar business

c) You don't care about your personal rights within your own home

D) You don't care about the lying and corruption of a government that bribes the casino industry

Sorry. I hate negative posts myself, but again, this is costing jobs and personal rights. If you're talking health issues, please explain why NJ casino air filled with smoke is healthy, while anyplace else is not.
 
Just as you feel you have a "right" to smoke, I have the "right" to go into a place, enjoy the company of friends, enjoy the atmosphere, band, dj or whatever else the bar may be offering, without getting cancer just by stepping into the place.


No, you don't. You have the right to CHOOSE whether to walk into a place where smoking occurs, or not. You do not have the right to press your will onto others on PRIVATE PROPERTY. ONLY the owner of that property has that right...

The fact is, the owners ( especially in the area of Atlantic City) have a terrific Restraint Of Trade suit to be tried, but none have the wherewithal and time to fight the government. If they did, they should win, if the law were upheld...
 
And that is exactly how it should be. Smoking around a child is just as much a form as child abuse as beating them. Worse in fact because it creates permanent damage to them.

If you smoke and find my comments offensive, they are not meant to be. But I will not apologize, because the billion dollar smoking industry has convinced everyone that anyone who is against smoking is un-American. But the truth is, there zero, let me repeat, zero benefits to using an type of tobacco. Be it cigerettes, a pipe, or snuff.

Nope. I smoke when not training. BUT still won't smoke around kids, don't like smoke when I'm eating, or stale smoke smell in my car or on my clothes. That said, my position on the ban stands. It's illegal, non-constitutional, and an invasion of the rights of private property owners.
 
As far as businesses having the choice, that sounds good but it really isn't doable in practice. Even if just 30% of the state's population smokes, that 30% is over 70% of your bar patronage. Opening a smoke-free bar would not be what I would call a sound business plan.

So non-smokers won't invest in a bar, but are willing to lie, cheat, and steal the income from another so they can impose their will on others. AND THEY GOT AWAY WITH IT!
 
Smoking Ban Very Disruptive...

We have had a smoking ban in all public places in Ca for many years.

I smoked cigarettes for many years, then a pipe...

As any behavior of any kind becomes socially "unacceptable", then those behaviors will change. The unfortunate result is a transition from the old to the new that hurts those in the dining, gambling and entertainment Industries. In this situation

Here in Calif. these bans are not in no way hurting the merchants, bars, restaurants. Problem is this transition to acceptance can take years.......

I quit smoking 9 years ago, it got to be to much of a hassle, pain in the AR**.

I feel for you, those who will go through this, it's not easy.

Public opinion is a powerful force, and as long as it is seen that second hand smoke kills.....you don't stand a chance.......