Music List - How we'll get there - the process. Please comment.

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

Balanced Line

New DJ
Aug 14, 2006
855
0
72
An outline for creating the OurDJChat community music list

Let’s be clear that the list as I’ll call it from here on is not a playlist. It is the stuff from which a playlist is drawn. It is a collection of music that you believe represents the most popular OR fun and unique music. It is the stuff that allows you to satisfy the standard requests yet also has selections that make your performance unique. As Carl Malden used to say, Don’t leave home without it and you don’t

Preliminaries
We’ll discuss the road map. Where we want to go. What we want to get along the way. How we’re going to get there. How many fields of data in the first go round? What data? Track and Artist is the minimum. Genre? Date? BPM? Anything else? The floor is open for discussion. My preference is to have four fields for submission. Include the genre and date as this will allow easy division of the list as it grows.
Track,Artist,Genre,Date

How do you eat an elephant? One bite at a time.


Round 1
Throw everything anyone suggests into the pot. Whatever you believe should be in the kit of the well rounded DJ goes in. Every suggestion will be accepted and entered. There will be no editorial deletions. As the list grows it will be subdivided so that it can worked on in sections more easily.

Round 2
We vote as a group on what should be kept and what does not belong. We can do this by Australian ballot if everybody or anybody prefers. Right now I don’t have any idea of what the criterion will be. It depends upon the number of submissions and the number of participants.

Round 3
A dash of character, quirkiness and local flavor are reintroduced. Each participant will get a set number of additions that will not (cannot be vetoed except no Roobie Breastnut, PM me for details if you don’t know, oh hell, she isn’t that bad, well, we’ll discuss it) be challenged. The idea is to have some percentage of tunes that are different and unique but not too many. Stuff that just would not show up on a mainstream list by Billboard or Mobilbeat or any other national group.
 
Ok, Balance after receiving ur PM I took this all into thought. The first time I heard a collobaration of songs compiled together to make one bad ass music list, I was thinking MS Word in a Table format just because I cringe on the thought of spreadsheets such as excel, mostly because I don't use them and further don't know how to use them. Regardless of what I can or can't do, I think if we make it very simple Such as Artist in column A, title in columb B, and Genre in Column C that would make for much ease. There are plenty of artists whose names have changed over time, perfect example is Sean Combs, how many names did he go by over the years? We will have to deal with these in a one by one basis since I don't believe there are too many of them. I don't see a need to include year as a catgeory, unless you need to pick a song from a certain year, and even than you would only really do this from the 80's and older, at least in my opinion. As far as the genres go, make it simple, rock, hip hop, r&b, country, reggae, pop, and so forth. Making it really detailed is going to make it a hell of a lot of work, and when it is that much work we are going to want to try and short cut around it and make for a not so great list. I only am saying this because I have tried to do things that I want completely detailed oriented, and it ends up taking forever, I get frusturated, and usually in the middle change the format completely and basically have to start all over. It will be much easier to go back and add information than to go back and erase information.

This is just my opinion, regardless of what we all decide on, I think it will be for the best of all.
Josh
 
Yes - You are absolutely right

I want to make this as easy as possible for you guys. At the same time I don't want to swamp myself. The most important thing to me is that whatever we do, we do the same thing.

Regardless of what everyone decides, everyone doing the same thing is the most important thing. It is to be our list and it isn't up to me to dictate so everyone should have their say. Sorry for the detail. Dictators can be shorter because they just tell you what to do not why.

All you have to do is submit the suggestion in the post. I'd like the format to be:

Track|Artist|Genre|Year

The character between the fields (Track, Artist, Genre and Year) is called the delimiter. It tells the software I use, new field dummy! A carriage return [ENTER] indicates a new record (line).

The delimiter I've suggested is the pipe ( | ). It is the uppercase backslash. It was chosen because it is rarely used in standard use unless you use command line UNIX or DOS. It will free up use of more typical delimiters such as dash ( - ) and comma ( , ) for use in the list's tracks and artist names.

Funny, my first inclination is to put the artist first but most submissions have the track first so I followed that convention. You just have to know when you are the dog or the tail:sqlaugh:.

As for you second question, Eric Clapton is another good example. If the group is of sufficient significance it might be listed twice. Cream might be an example. Otherwise the obvious solution is to put a note at say Derek and the Dominoes SEE CLAPTON, Eric.


So no one needs special tools Just submit as you usually do in text. I'll compile the list and tabulate, remove the duplicates. OurDJChat does not want to bore you stiff. We just want to pick your brain. We just have to keep the format consistant.

But yessss Rockint, we want one badasssss list.

Thanks, hope that helps.
 
One more thing!

If you guys say stuff it! Too much! I say I'll take it (the song suggestions) anyway you're willing to give it to me. It'll make a lot more work, but it is better than not getting it done.

I'm not [too] proud.
 
I was thinking of easier ways for lists to be bulk submitted, last night.

How about csv (comma seperate values). It's a standard from way back. Excel can import them. It may make work easier for Bob.

Artist,Title,Genre,Age group

I'm going to search for a database powered script for submission, that should cut down on management time signifantly if I can find a decent one.
 
Commas will work but there is a down side.

Yes Dan, the comma delimiter is a very common standard. Unfortunately in certain instances depending on how the guys want to format the list it may be problematic. If for instance we decide to list individuals name’s last name first as in JOHN, Elton there will be a comma in there that will start a new field. Some first names can be fairly common and long lists can have many common first names in succession.

I’ve been fairly well impressed with the way some of the Billboard books present names (last names first) and thought it might be the best way to go. Nonetheless I look forward to the membership telling me what they want. The pipe is used very infrequently and therefore makes an excellent delimiter if the members are willing to use it. Most import tools will allow the user to stipulate any delimiter. So commas and dashes are very common as well. Dashes drive you nutz when you get to the artist Sir Mix-A-Lot and the track L-O-V-E, l is for the way you look at me.

As I said in the previous post, I'll take it anyway I can if this technical stuff ticks our members off. That said, it will cause me a lot of work.
 
What about my idea for excel? Just make a list in excel, where you can copy and paste lists in the mass's and should be able to find duplicates with no problem..... I will search the web tomm nite at work and see if i can find ne cool programs.. one of the guys i work with might help me as well.... ill be back tomm nite..
josh
 
Yup! That is why I said you are absolutely right

Josh,

What you suggest is in fact what I do to compile submissions. It isn’t hard to see that there is a lot of detail the answer to your original post. I made a judgement call not to cover that detail as it was something no one except me had to deal with. My reply was already a little bit long winded and didn’t want to confuse people with any more detail than they need or want.

Thanks for your input
 
i have some of that book i suggested typed. wanna throw that in??? it is the 1955-1959, up to the 1990 playlists i think???? o well......those are the best of that year in the artist's opinion........just a thought
 
Well....

While I really appreciate the suggestion, that may be considered plagiarism. The list has to reflect what you have in your kit or believe belongs there. Not what others believe belongs there. I wouldn’t want to see a verbatim extended wholesale copy of another’s work even if you feel their selections are worthwhile.

Thanks for the idea.
 
ok,
here is my format that would be easiest for me since this is how I just fluently write it out:
Artist (first name last name) - Title - Genre
I guess I could teach myself to use the | key but that really isnt that big of a deal. I still really don't see the need of a year. Can someone else besides me an Balanced ring in on this. Do we want a year or popular year or some sort of year determination for these?.....
JOsh
 
I still really don't see the need of a year. Can someone else besides me an Balanced ring in on this. Do we want a year or popular year or some sort of year determination for these?.....

I don't want a year. And I'll tell you why. REISSUES/MOVIE SOUNDTRACKS. Sometimes, some "obscure" song (for example, LUST FOR LIFE) is resurrected by a movie. How many people thought LUST FOR LIFE was a NEW song (the fact that Iggy Pop made a music video for this 20 years later didn't help). The point is that year is often inconsequential.

Another example is songs that come out and they're in the "underground" and loved until some promoter picks it up and makes sure it's played thirty times a day on the radio and TV until people hate it. These songs are usually older than most people know.

And, sure, we can talk about when it was popular, but what about timeless classics? When OLD TIME ROCK AND ROLL first came out (1976?), I was too young to know, but then Tom Cruise dances in his underwear and it becomes the greatest song on Earth. And it still is to many people, especially middle-aged men at my events. What's its year?
 
ok,
here is my format that would be easiest for me since this is how I just fluently write it out:
Artist (first name last name) - Title - Genre
I guess I could teach myself to use the | key but that really isnt that big of a deal. I still really don't see the need of a year. Can someone else besides me an Balanced ring in on this. Do we want a year or popular year or some sort of year determination for these?.....
JOsh

I agree with this. The Year isnt as important. Title - Artist - Genre....is probally the best way.

IMO

-Brian
 
What if it were the real date?

OK, fellows, I hear you but the dates I have ALWAYS used and I think I explained here somewhere that'd want to supply would be one of the following:

Date of original publication
or
Date the track charted
or
Date of peak popularity

The sources I use would cite one of those. Those dates are useful. If the person making a submission cannot supply that either leave it blank or put ??? after the detail in question.

Vinyl, you are correct in your assertion. The position you assert is the reason the auto [on line] lookup services are almost useless. They reflect the date of a re-issue or god knows what. Those dates have no use. In fact, they are worse than no dates as they are misleading.

If it is the real date, one of the dates I cite above, which are usually within a year of one another, that is something of value IMHO.

The point of a date is to fix the track in an era. There are always exceptions to the rule but does that mean there is no value to an issue date? The date allows quick scanning to find tracks of a similar point in time - which has many times been an issue with my customers. I want my music from my era!

Brian - although I value your input, almost all the music you deal with on a regular basis comes from the last six years. If your situation were common to all of us, the date could indeed be removed without penalty.
 
Date of original publication -- Sure, that could work (I am assuming that this would be made clear for the reader of the list)
or
Date the track charted -- TOO MUCH work for us (unless, of course, we limit this to, say, THE BILLBOARD TOP 100 chart--but would that not add at least a tinge of "commercialism")
or
Date of peak popularity -- like trying to measure GDP in Third-World countries