Piracy issues and computer KJs

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
This Should Help Answer The Question

ok folks I was really did not want to get into this because I don't get into politics but this is the response that I got DIRECTLY from ASCAP and BMI (with whom I deal with on occassion due to the fact we hold benefit concerts)

Per ASCAP customer service
If you are creating copies of the original discs(whether purchased or stolen) and are selling them to the public it is considered "COMMERCIAL GAIN" and is illegal in all sense of the word. However, producing a copy of someone singing the song and giving it to them personally is NOT considered an illegal purpose to them unless you are producing that same recording with that same person in a mass productive way such as hundreds of discs. It is also not illegal per them if you have charged a small service fee to cover the cost of the disc and time.

If you purchased the music legally from a licensed vedor or service even though your means of transmission of this music is through a digital medium such as a computer program which stores the music prior to you playing it then you are not committing an illegal act even though you are publicly playing the song as a business unless you are making copies of that song and producing it in mass production for sale. If you pirated the song however again you are illegal in every sense of the word. This includes getting your music from a newsgroup p2p networks and so on. If you didn't buy it legally you are committing a crime.

Per BMI licensing agent
You as a dj/kj are not responsible for any licensing of the venue or music that you perform IF the music was purchased LEGALLY regardless of your choice of transmission unless you are promoting the show then you are required to purchase through them a promoters license which has a graduated fee scale but no less than $198.00 that is charged on a per show basis and can be found on the BMI website. Other than that it is the venues responsibility.

In both instances you can only play the music you purchased during one show at a time unless you legally purchased multiple copies of the same album . If you have stored the music on multiple machines for playing different shows at the same time and it came from only one original it is illegal and considered piracy for commercial profit or gain. The rule of thumb one disc one machine, twelve discs of the same album then twelve machines. You must be able to produce upon demand a disc or copy of a receipt that proves purchase of the album or song if you are using it on a machine. NO GRAY AREA, cut and dry, that is how both companies see it and I know this because as a BUSINESS owner it is my resposibility to ask questions if I don't know and not from someone who may not have the right answer but from the source themselves.

Neither company wants to harm the legitimate businesses that exsist. They only wish to stop those who would operate in our industry using illegal pirated music and those who would sell the music that they sold. It is bad business to run the majority off that are operating legally. This in my opinion is good business for all of us. Who wants to try and compete with a thief. Not me I can't keep my business running if I can't make the money and if someone stole all of their music and I purchased mine legally who suffers me or the thief? As a side note the purchase of hard drives containing music is illegal unless you purchased each track from a licensed vendor and have a detailed receipt to prove the purchase of each track which I might add is provided from any vendor that is legally licensed to sell music. I hope this settles the argument if not please call BMI and ASCAP yourself they are more than willing to assist you in learning the answer. They have contact numbers on their websites.
 
I agree with you completely.... but I bet Sound Choice and Steller would agree to disagree with most of what you said.... their stance is if you aren't playing thier cdg's as they were produced (ie form disc) then they say you are running illegally and in their opinion there is no grey area... they claim that moving the cdg from disc to mp3+g is format shifting and there for illegal if used in a commercial environment. They do not distiguish between a 1:1 user as you sugest... I don't agree with their opinion, period. I agree with you though.
 
I agree with you completely.... but I bet Sound Choice and Steller would agree to disagree with most of what you said.... their stance is if you aren't playing thier cdg's as they were produced (ie form disc) then they say you are running illegally and in their opinion there is no grey area... they claim that moving the cdg from disc to mp3+g is format shifting and there for illegal if used in a commercial environment. They do not distiguish between a 1:1 user as you sugest... I don't agree with their opinion, period. I agree with you though.

and there in lies the question.....is it sound choice's decision on how to interpret the law?....or because they made it, are they allowed to say how it can or cannot be reproduced?
 
and there in lies the question.....is it sound choice's decision on how to interpret the law?....or because they made it, are they allowed to say how it can or cannot be reproduced?

No they did not make the copyright laws this is just how they interpret them to their own needs.... all the while they are and have been developing everything from On Demand karaoke thru cable tv services to the DOPi or iPod karaoke... and even downloadable video karaoke from google video and other sources... they claim that it's not really merely that playing from a PC is illegal it is that if you take a disc and convert (or format shift) to what a PC can read and play that you are then playing their music illegally if in a commercial enviornment... yet if you are doing it for personal use then they don't care... they also don't care if you maintain a strict 1:1, they don't care if you are buying their music either... basically they want the market all to them selves and will state anything they can to stunt the growth of what we already know should be and is to an extent already legal.

Here's the rub though... until it's tried in court. I mean a real case of a KJ who has maintained a strict 1:1 ratio they have no real leg to stand on and it's all just propaganda until then.

I am all for manu's going after those that download from p2p's, sell loaded hard drives and or CDR media, and multi-ops that choose to maintain only one set of discs or none at all and run multiple units with the same song libraries loaded... those are the true pirates!!! Make them walk the plank!!!

We legit owners and ops that purchase a set of discs for every unit we run and run them off PC are still supporting the manu's and when they start attacking us they are simply shooting themselves in the foot.... I know many KJ's that refuse to buy SC or Steller products opting for other brands that are PC friendly such as Zoom, Panarama, Chartbuster and others all equally as good as SC or Steller... maybe better.

End Rant....
 
and there in lies the question.....is it sound choice's decision on how to interpret the law?....or because they made it, are they allowed to say how it can or cannot be reproduced?



Simply: No. By the way, as far as making backup discs ( not for distribution)- completely legal. Under the law, Software discs, DVDs, music CDs, and karaoke CD+Gs are treated the same way. However, one must remember that they all all licensed for single location usage. It IS illegal to make 5 copies to be used at 5 locations simultaneously, for example. That is considered distribution.
 
I can't publically say the big thing going on, Jokerswild is in on it (cause he's on the autokdj inner circle) but lemme just put it this way...

If SC and STLR don't start playing ball soon, they're going to miss the boat. In a really bad way. There's something huge coming out of our camp soon that's going to change how everything is done in karaoke.