Quite possibly the most interesting thread ever on ODJT. Worth a read.

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

Who do you think was right?

  • Driver A

    Votes: 6 100.0%
  • Driver B

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    6

Papa Deuce

Mac Daddy DJ
Aug 8, 2006
19,843
594
64
Valley Forge Area
OK, This is a cut and paste from something I posted on another board a few years ago. It ruined a friendship I had.


Ok, I am going to try to put this in a way that you don't know which side I favor. I am friends with one of the particpant. I do not think he is in the right. He's angry that I told him he is wrong IMO.

Here goes;

Driver A hits Driver B's parked car.

The damage to B's car is miniscule.

Driver A leaves a note with phone number to call if Driver B wants to be compensated.

Driver B calls Driver A and says "Yes" I want to be compensated.

Driver A says OK, "get an estimate and if it is less than $300 I will personally pay you without insurance companies getting involved."

Driver B agrees to that.

Next day Driver A sees that Driver B's car has been in a fairly extensive accident that totally ruins the part of the car that Driver A ran into. Remember "minuscule" damage had been done.

Later that day Driver B calls Driver A and says, "Just give me $200 and we'll call it even".

Driver A says "No way. I saw your car and what I did is totally ruined by whatever happened after I hit your car. Do you even have an estimate for the damage I did?"

Driver B says he does not but still feels driver A owes him $200.

Driver A says to B that since you can't even prove what my damages were, and since insurance is going to pay to have what I hit fixed, the whole deal should just be forgotten.

Driver A says "Take me to court if you want any money".

Driver B says "I might just do that".

I am friends ( for now ) with one of the participants.

Who is right or wrong?


The reason I bring this up today, is that I found out that "Driver B" died in a car accident yesterday.
 
To me, Driver A is right. The damage done to car B after the fact will be covered by Driver B's insurance, and this would include the damage done by Driver A. Driver B was trying to take advantage of Driver A.

I deduce that you are friends with Driver A. If you just found out that Driver B died yesterday, you wouldn't have said that you're "friends (for now) with one of the participants." Right? ;)
 
It ruined a friendship I had.

If it ruined a friendship, because you said what was on your mind -- then the person wasn't a real friend.

So, whoever ruined the friendship was probably wrong (if wrong exists)...
 
Both are wrong... but driver A broke a few serious insurance laws when he left the scene without letting driver B see it.

This is another reason why its so important that there is a disposable camera in every glove compartment box. (Along with a 9mm, but that's another thread altogether.)

Papa, I'm not sure who's driver A or B, but if it was one of your friends then I'm sorry for your loss.
 
For future reference, many insurance policies have zero deductible on parked vehicles. Someone backs into your car in a parking lot, contact your agent and they'll walk you through the procedure.
 
If one of the guys died, it doesn't matter now who was right or wrong. It only matters how you dealt with your friend that counts....
 
To me, Driver A is right. The damage done to car B after the fact will be covered by Driver B's insurance, and this would include the damage done by Driver A. Driver B was trying to take advantage of Driver A.

I deduce that you are friends with Driver A. If you just found out that Driver B died yesterday, you wouldn't have said that you're "friends (for now) with one of the participants." Right? ;)


Folks - this may be a first....

Incorrect, Mr. Durio.....

When questioned regarding the 2nd accident; provided B is honest, he would tell his insurers that there was previous damage to his vehicle as a result of a previous accident. That amount would be deducted from the claim for accident 2.

You cannot claim for old damage.....

So ultimately you still owe Driver B something, although with no photos or estimates the amount is certainly up for debate....

Btw...In my "other life", I am a claims adjuster (26 years)......
 
Bottom line is driver A ran into driver B so he/she should face up to their responsibilities and pay driver something. I don't think that it is a matter of how much now that additional damage was done, but driver A owes driver B something just because he/she ran into their vehicle...thx
 
Bottom line is driver A ran into driver B so he/she should face up to their responsibilities and pay driver something. I don't think that it is a matter of how much now that additional damage was done, but driver A owes driver B something just because he/she ran into their vehicle...thx

Exactly, driver A is totally in the wrong.
 
Folks - this may be a first....

Incorrect, Mr. Durio.....

When questioned regarding the 2nd accident; provided B is honest, he would tell his insurers that there was previous damage to his vehicle as a result of a previous accident. That amount would be deducted from the claim for accident 2.

You cannot claim for old damage.....

So ultimately you still owe Driver B something, although with no photos or estimates the amount is certainly up for debate....

Btw...In my "other life", I am a claims adjuster (26 years)......

Insurance laws vary from state to state.... although it would surprise me if they allowed old damage to be repaired... but then again, if a big dent is made on a smaller dent... who's to say "we're going to fix the big dent and then put a little dent back on."
 
I was going to add two more cents to this but Arnoldo beat me to it!

So Mr. LeBlanc, as an adjuster you would have no problems with fixing the damage and then restoring the car's condition to what it was before the second occurrence? That would include the dent made by Driver A. The area that dent was in was further damaged in the second incident. I can see your point about the cost of the first incident being deducted, though.

Given Driver B's disposition, I don't think he would be very truthful to a claims adjuster.

Makes sense to me...NOT.
 
Notice in the OP I said the damage was miniscule...... From what I gather, the guy I knew - B - may not have even noticed the damage if "A" hadn't said anything......

I still think "A" was right.

BTW, IMO, had B not had his car hit a 2nd time, and from what I gather about the amount of damage, I think B would have taken the cash and never bothered to fix his car. In fact, in my mind, I KNOW he wouldn't have fixed it.

He would have bought BEER with it.. ;)
 
i think driver b is correct(at least more correct than driver a). He should be compensated for previous damage.
Driver a told him he would pay up to $300.

Driver b should have collected the money from driver a and let the insurance company know to deduct $200 from the claim. The insurance company should not have to pay for previous damage.

What driver b does with the money is his business....it's his property.

what driver a should have done is took a picture of the intial damage....let the guy know he would fix the damage(whether he uses insurance or not is of no consequence). When the second accident occured...driver a could say...i will give you the $200 only when i know you have let the insurance company know about the previous accident. Driver a would have proof of "minimal" damage.

the reality is...Driver A caused some damage to someone else's propertyy....and should compensate the damaged party......the fact that another accident occurred only makes it more difficult to determine the value of the damage....it doesn't relieve driver A from responsibility.

The other reality is....driver b "may" have been trying to collect full value from both parties...which is wrong....that's why i suggested driver a make sure the insurance company know about the previous damage.

Sorry to hear the guy passed...sounds like he didn't have a lot of luck with automobiles.
 
....
the reality is...Driver A caused some damage to someone else's propertyy....and should compensate the damaged party......the fact that another accident occurred only makes it more difficult to determine the value of the damage....it doesn't relieve driver A from responsibility.

The other reality is....driver b "may" have been trying to collect full value from both parties...which is wrong....that's why i suggested driver a make sure the insurance company know about the previous damage.

Sorry to hear the guy passed...sounds like he didn't have a lot of luck with automobiles.

1. Impossible to determine, really.

2. Almost guaranteed.

I do "THINK" that if B had asked for 100 bucks, the whole thing would have been settled. BTW, I am not sure how it ever settled. Like I said, B got so pissed at me that we never really spoke again.
 
They are both wrong.

Briver B said he wanted to be comspensated; but now driver A sees a way to back out the agreement.

Meanwhile, Drviver B wants to collect $200 under the table while an insurance company pays to restore the car to it's original condition.

Driver A is correct to think Driver B is making advantgae of this - but it is NOT Driver A that is getting screwed.

Driver B is correct to think Driver A is going back on his word, but it's ironic given the lack of integrity shown by Driver B - who is not going to let either the insurance company or Driver A off the hook for the original dent.

For future reference:

Driver A should learn to drive more carefully, and do a better job of picking out parking places.

Driver B should also drive more carefully and learn not to offer compensation before someone asks for it.

You should take a ride with neither of them, and find some better friends.
 
Well, I am going to have to dust off the Insurance hat....................

Both are wrong.................

1st off, was driver "B" legally parked? Even if the "legally" parked has nothing to do with the accident......it sets up what is called "contributory negligence", that will impact the % of liability driver "A", has.......this would not directly impact settlement in a no-fault state.....unless loss exceeded the "No fault" threshold........

Drivers "A and B" can jeopardize ultimate coverage for either, by failing to report to their Insurance Companies in a timely manner.

Are you located in a "No Fault" state?

I didn't throughly read Ace's response because.....Florida is a "no-fault" state.......so "tort" liabilities differ.

This is a very good example of what can happen when you try to settle these accidents yourself, to avoid driver point charges........!!!

I have seen numerous claims get escalated, when one driver admits liability at the scene of an accident.......that's a "No-No" !!! Never admit liability...period!!

It's amazing when this scenario occurs how after several days additional damage, loss occurs??

My advice would be for Driver to report this to their carrier, and to "fall on their sword" and apologize for the late reporting..........this could get very ugly with Driver "A" taking the worst of it...............
 
I'll go back and read what everyone else thinks after I post this...I don't want my words to be j-j-jaded....(Aerosmith! yeah, baby! I'm a DJ!)

I wouldn't be as big as a "d" as driver A was about the whole thing (go ahead and sue me!) but I agree with driver A. The whole point seems moot if the car was creamed and the original damage that driver B did to the car disappeared.

The only thing that is not mentioned is anything about the second accident. Perhaps the driver of THAT car (driver C?) didn't have any insurance and maybe that's why driver B is forcing the issue?

I'm extremely disappointed this "interesting thread" had nothing to do with hairy backs!
 
Quite possibly, the dullest thread ever, on OurDJTalk.Com :sqlaugh:


IMHO, insurance is the biggest scam to come down the pike, get legalized, and made mandatory :sqerr:

Pots illegal, yet gambling on peoples lives and property are not...

So, I vote for C