Immigration Reform?

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

Fred Wright

Administrator
Staff member
Aug 7, 2006
12,741
1,015
68
Delaware, USA
www.nwedj.com
Folks,

I realize this is a hot topic in Washington right about now. For what it's worth I'd like to add some impolitic thoughts of my own. :)

We all tend to bitch and moan about illegal immigrants. It's an old story... if you're gonna sell me a Big Mac, you'd better do it in English, illegals are taking jobs away from Americans etc.

I'd like to post some thoughts on immigrant labor from an old dog's point of view:

You folks know me. I've been working in industry and manufacturing since, aw... '81 when I got out of the service. I've seen a lot of things. I've seen a lot of illegals working in many industrial and commercial plants over the years.

Stay in a hotel and you expect clean linens. Go to a restaurant and you expect clean tablecloths and napkins. Did you ever wonder how those clean linens, tablecloths and napkins got there? Well, I'll tell you. There's a sweatshop commercial laundry nearby that can't afford to pay a decent wage so they have to rely upon immigrant labor to put those nice, clean, folded linens out there.

Here's where I get impolitic: Anyone who bitches about illegals working here needs to STFU and listen to some facts. The illegals ain't taking jobs away from Americans. Americans don't want to do these jobs. Our young people have refused these jobs and, by default have given them to illegals.

If no one here is willing to do these necessary jobs, where does that leave us? Someone has to do it.

How many Americans are willing to work out in the hot sun all day picking peaches or strawberries? On the same token, how many Americans expect to see their peaches and strawberries in the grocery?

We can't have it both ways. If you wish to have your peaches and strawberries you have two options: Get out there and pick 'em yourself or let illegal, underpaid laborers do it for you. The farmers can't afford to pay a decent, Americanized wage for pickers because we the people don't want to pay anything for what the farmers produce. The farmer has bills to pay, too.

Want to reform illegal immigration? Do away with the need for it. Carry your arse out there to the fields, the factories, the laundries, the convenience stores, the landscaping companies. Toss the shirts and ties and GTF to work.

Before you say Wolfie, put your money where your yapper is, I'm 'way ahead of yas. Been there and done that. Yup, I've picked strawberries out in the sun all day. Yup, I've worked in the sweatshops. They ain't called sweatshops for nothing.

And I could do it again come tomorrow morning. I don't complain about things. I gotta put food on my table.

What say you?
 
Here's where I get impolitic: Anyone who bitches about illegals working here needs to STFU and listen to some facts. The illegals ain't taking jobs away from Americans. Americans don't want to do these jobs. Our young people have refused these jobs and, by default have given them to illegals.

If no one here is willing to do these necessary jobs, where does that leave us? Someone has to do it.

Fred, you know I love you, but outside of drunk driving this is the issue that sends me up the wall, and it is because of statements like the one you made above.

How do you know no one is willing to do these jobs? The employers hiring illegals are doing it for one reason and one reason only: because they know they have almost zero chance of getting caught. Legal workers do not have the chance to turn these jobs down because they are not even offered them.

Here is a portion of the same blog I referenced in the drunk driving thread:

Immigration. My views on this have been laid out many times before in other blogs, so I will condense them down here. I believe we are fighting a two front immigration war, and as good war historian knows, a two front war normally spells disaster. We have the internal battle which is burning within our borders, and then we have the battle of the borders themselves. My personal opinion is simple. Lock down the borders first. The only way to win the battle within the country is to stop the flow of illegal immigrants from coming. If we make it so hard for them to get in, they will stop trying. I am totally for a zero admittance policy, just to get the situation under control. Yes, I know, I hear it all the time: "We all come from immigrants." My response: just because it worked in the past does not mean it works today. Just ask an African-American if they would like to hit the rewind button 150 years back. Once the borders are sealed up, if you are an illegal who is caught in the country, do not pass go, do not collect $200, you are out, period. I don't care if you have a family here, kids here or anything else, they can go back with you. This "we are a country build on immigrants" crap has to stop. You are also put on a government list which denies you access back into the country, even if you try it by legal means. Sorry, you had your chance, and the first act you did when you got here was break a law.
 
Thanks, Pat. :)

Actually, these sweatshop, backbreaking jobs are offered through state labor department job postings: http://www.ajb.dni.us/de. That's how the illegals find them. Americans have the same opportunities.

People who were born and raised here don't want to do these jobs. They'll walk through the plant, take a look around and say "I'm looking for a job ~ but I'm not looking for one in here. :eek:

When I worked at [company name omitted], the superintendent encouraged the illegals to bring more illegals in. They work for peanuts.

Here in DE, the illegal immigrant worker issue is acute. We've got plenty of agriculture and chicken plants Downstate (Perdue, Tyson) to keep illegal workers busy all year 'round.

I wouldn't want to be a chicken choker. But if there was no alternative, well I'd have little choice. :)
 
Fred, I just have to ask because I am a little confused. How can a state hire someone who does not have the legal right to work in the country?
 
Greets, Pat.

As I understand it, the way it's done... you hire a few green cards for documentation purposes. Then, you grab a bunch more undocumenteds. Should there be an investigation by the INS (not likely), you show 'em the green cards and say "Hey, we're in compliance."

The undocumenteds are laying low, btw.

Sometimes they get caught. When I worked at Hanover Foods, a busload of 'em got carted away when the INS busted the place. :eek:

But they're still doin' it. They get smart and learn to hide it.
 
Greets, Pat.

As I understand it, the way it's done... you hire a few green cards for documentation purposes. Then, you grab a bunch more undocumenteds. Should there be an investigation by the INS (not likely), you show 'em the green cards and say "Hey, we're in compliance."

The undocumenteds are laying low, btw.

Sometimes they get caught. When I worked at Hanover Foods, a busload of 'em got carted away when the INS busted the place. :eek:

But they're still doin' it. They get smart and learn to hide it.


OK, I am saying this with a smile on my face as I type it, but you dont have a problem with what you just typed out? lol
 
Pat, my old friend. :)

I don't have problems. Haven't had a problem since '98 when I got divorced. Life is good. :D

I work in electrical maintenance... or did before I got on at Playtex. In this field, there aren't many illegals competing, lol.
 
Pat, my old friend. :)

I don't have problems. Haven't had a problem since '98 when I got divorced. Life is good. :D

I work in electrical maintenance... or did before I got on at Playtex. In this field, there aren't many illegals competing, lol.

Yeah, I am the same way, lol.

Divorce can really make your problems go away pretty fast, hahaha.
 
It seems to me that Congress tried to do the exact thing to "combat illegal immigration" in the late 1970's. That worked real well, in hind sight.

Do I believe there are jobs in this country (the United States of America) that no legal citizen would do? Nope. I believe that people want to work, and make a life for themselves. And with that, I want to believe that if the job is that bad, they want to work their way up out of that job. Maybe with education, maybe with just hard work and an ethic to do the job they were hired to do.

I want to believe that poverty and class warfare is created by politicians. The reality, though, is that it exists in the United States of America. Will I ever fully understand it? No. I am lucky enough to have parents who are still married (we just celebrated their 45th anniversary). I am lucky enough that they cared about my grades in school. They almost cried when I declared I was going back to college at the ripe old age of 24. (Believe it or not, I'm still trying to convince 21-year-olds that college is a worthy path.)

I digress and rant - sorry. As I gather my thoughts (and edit my BS), I'm left with this:

1) We offer the best standard of living in the Western Hemisphere
2) We offer freedom (as much as we Citizens take it for granted)
3) We give workers protection with court orders regardless of citizen status. (Locally, in Minnesota, see http://www.eeoc.gov/press/8-22-06.html) (I know others who didn't get these protections from a Native American Sovereign Territory in MY STATE!)
4) We, as consumers in the United States of America, frankly, don't want to pay the premium of legal workers. [I witnessed this as a child when my parents took the low bid on a roofing job on their house. I was home (working non-standard hours in retail). When the workers (who didn't speak English) were taking a break, I offered them ice water. They were shocked that I showed them hospitality. I was shocked that they didn't just say, "Se, Buena," as if it is a norm of hospitality for workers doing a job for a Midwestern family on their private property.]
 
Illegal immigration will never cease...Why? Corporate America and their greed !

They need these people and their desire to work at low wages. remember to the illegal; these jobs are gold, compared to where they came from. They're also used to hard, back breaking. sweaty work.....How many kids today here in Canada and the U.S. will work hard? I mean hard.....

Honestly, this si a smokescreen design to divert everyone's attention from the real issues.....
 
I say we kick all them damn illegal Canadians out now -- they're nothing but trouble :sqlaugh:


The way I figure it, we've pretty much strip mined this country to death already, let the other folks have it, and we can move to warmer climes... :)
 
Illegal immigration will never cease...Why? Corporate America and their greed !.
And, of course, there's no Corporate Canada and greed. It's a perfect utopia, the Garden of Eden reborn. :sqrolleyes: :sqrolleyes: :sqrolleyes: :sqrolleyes: :sqrolleyes: :sqrolleyes: :sqrolleyes: :sqrolleyes:
 
I was gonna say, the Canucks have it all figured out. I'm really glad that they're here to preach to us lowly Americans with endless criticism about how we should run our country, all the while ignoring any problems with theirs!
 
I call bullsh!t.

The problem is so far out of hand now that it will take years to correct, even if we started now. To me, it NEEDS to be corrected.

Our country has created the greed. We've created kids that don't/won't work at these relatively undesirable jobs because they basically don't have to. I think that sucks. I held crappy, sweaty jobs as a teen. I was happy to be working.

Obviously, the rich folk and their kids will always be spoiled, but what about the lower class? Why, in God's name, do we support their filthy asses through gov't programs? Why do we allow what amounts to free hospital care for illegals? If I were a lower classman, I'd relinquish my citizenship, live here and REAP THE BENEFITS! Why not? We hand them the bennies on a stinking silver platter.

We, as a nation, are muscleheaded and stupid. It's like we're big, dumb jocks at the biggest high school around. Sometimes I'm embarrassed as to the state of affairs our politicians have let this country slip into.

Thank God I'll only be around for another 40 years at best, and thank God I have no kids that will be left to clean up the mess we leave them.
 
Fred Stewart said:
Here's where I get impolitic: Anyone who bitches about illegals working here needs to STFU and listen to some facts. The illegals ain't taking jobs away from Americans. Americans don't want to do these jobs. Our young people have refused these jobs and, by default have given them to illegals.

If no one here is willing to do these necessary jobs, where does that leave us? Someone has to do it.

Fred, not really a point of contention...

More or less a statement and back-handed agreement to this statement.


I went to the Fargo Ribfest last night. Hickory smoked ribs & roasted corn lingered in the air whilst Everclear’s drummer was thumping in the background.

A young gentlemen that I met a few years ago approached me & asked me how things were. It took about 5-10 minutes for me to remember who this person was but it eventually came to me.

During our exchange of pleasantries I asked him how things were going & he said..."ohh..., not so well".

I inquired as to why?

Y'see, he works for a local contracting company & had been given a job that required a certain amount of physical labor that he felt was either a PITA or beneath him. He explained that he called his boss & offered an alternative way to do the job, however, his boss sharply informed him that he is paying him to following simple directions...not to undermine his directions.

The job entailed the removal of some plants or weeds from flower beds that surround a rather upscale house that they were remodeling/adding on. Dilemma: 3 workers had to remove the plants in 6 hours. However, the worker wasted 1 of the 5 hours calling around for an "easier way" & dealing with his boss. All while the other 2 workers were waiting for someone to lead them.

This person I know feels so frustrated with his boss underscoring his position that he's planning on leaving & looking for different work.

Now the next comment that my wife & I silently rolled our eyes at was...

"My generation realizes that life's to short. You have to enjoy things when you can and when your not appreciated...move on."

I asked him: What about company loyalty?

Response:

"There no company loyalty today because the company is out to screw it's workers."

These statements represent a large portion of the philosophy of the middle and younger work force today.

You can hire them one day & they expect the respect of a 20 year veteran by day two.

Mix that with a low unemployment rate & the attitude is reinforced by the ability to flit from job to job.

We've built a culture of prima-donnas that is too lazy to sweat a little anywhere other than a gym or health club. We are in essence... "Rome" in decay.

We don't have a large work force with character. Those willing to sacrifice "a little" for the greater good. UNTIL that... IF that... philosophy ever returns, things will continue to worsen.

Illegals have no business being here. It's not their country. If they want to share in the benefits & the opportunities they need to follow the processes in place for them to become citizens.

So if & when the economy TRULY tanks... where are these Illegals expecting to get county health care & food assistance?

I find it remarkable there are some that treat illegals SO liberally.


Fred Stewart said:
Before you say Wolfie, put your money where your yapper is, I'm 'way ahead of yas. Been there and done that. Yup, I've picked strawberries out in the sun all day. Yup, I've worked in the sweatshops. They ain't called sweatshops for nothing.

And I could do it again come tomorrow morning. I don't complain about things. I gotta put food on my table.

What say you?

Been there...done that.

Rogued sunflowers, done the hayrack & stacked the hay....(by hand), shoveled corn, castrated sheep, cleaned the barns, dug post holes by hand...

Nothings was handed to me... Always a hard days work for a hard days pay.


So I will leave on these two thoughts...

If these jobs that apparently are beneath "Americans" found a shortage in the illegal workforce... Wouldn't that create a greater demand for workers & maybe...just maybe...that worker might be able to bargain for a better working condition?

Doesn't this sound alot like DJs???


Anywhoo...

Gotta go do my DJ sweatshop thingy...
 
There's a great deal of truth to that.

Unfortunately, hired help will always be a necessary evil. If the factories, farmers, merchants etc could make, move and market their products without the burden of a payroll they'd gladly do it.

Seriously, no business is in business to provide jobs. Businesses don't exist to enhance the local economy. They honestly do not exist to provide a product or service. Nossir. Businesses exist for one reason only: to make a profit for their owners. They do what they have to do to enhance the bottom line. Every expense is a necessary evil. Cheap (and often illegal) labor has become a necessary evil as well.

There's a very slim profit margin in food processing. People don't want to pay anything for food. Much the same may be said for the laundries and drycleaners. There really isn't much profit margin. One may mechanize to an extent but mechanization can only go so far.

If one starts his or her working life in a sweatshop or burger barn, there's only one direction to go. That's upward. These jobs aren't careers. There is something to be said for building a resume... any job is better than none at all.

That said, many youngsters today expect to start at the top. Then we moan about illegals who are at the bottom of the ladder. :dontknow:
 
Its interesting....I did a search on my birthdate in 1976 and was amazed that the price of eggs hasn't changed! No wonder many farmers, conglomerates or otherwise, are having a hard time paying people a living wage to work.

Its a crappy issue that I'm sure will lead to, at worst, some sort of Balkanization - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia@@AMEPARAM@@/wiki/File:Balkans_Animation_1800-2006.gif" class="image"><img alt="" src="http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c4/Balkans_Animation_1800-2006.gif/400px-Balkans_Animation_1800-2006.gif"@@AMEPARAM@@commons/thumb/c/c4/Balkans_Animation_1800-2006.gif/400px-Balkans_Animation_1800-2006.gif of areas of the US.

Unfortunately, that's about all I can say on the topic. I'm glad I got my college education...I'm not sure how I can support 4 kids on a teacher's salary and DJ income, but I know it would be a lot easier than slicing bacon 14 hours a day....