Congrats..Jordan Sparks Idol 2007

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
Yea in pb!

Her voice is great....but she is a boring singer! She slipped under the radar since she wasnt a "stand out" performer!

If she gets lessons in "entertaining" and showing more movement like Shania Twain...for example.....yes she definitely has a future!
 
Yea in pb!

Her voice is great....but she is a boring singer! She slipped under the radar since she wasnt a "stand out" performer!

If she gets lessons in "entertaining" and showing more movement like Shania Twain...for example.....yes she definitely has a future!

She's only 17. She'll get better.
Shania was probably working at Dairy Queen when she was 17.
 
Since it was a singing competition, I can not argue with the choice. BUT, from a pure PR and image standpoint, I see her going the way of Rueben and Fantasia. In 5 years, I think we will be going "Jordin who?". I just don't see any long term potential in the popular music biz. Maybe Broadway.

I also think the show itself will start a downward slide (which it already has) starting next year. The Sanjaya debacle killed any legitimacy AI may have had.
 
I think the key with Jordin is personal management. I think Clive Davis will be producing her first album. Jordin will be fine. She may not find herself initially appealing to the teen market, but she should appeal to the rest of market. She's only 17 and again with proper management she will make her impact.
 
Hopefully she can be "molded!"


Otherwise she will be wasted talent!


Like last year...I knew Daughtry had a career! This was a no brainer!

But yea...God bless her singing career....and help her find the market she deserves with a voice like hers!
 
Daughtry put out one cd...hardly a career. ...I don't think he'll have the staying power...

Speaking of Idol, what's with Kelly Clarkson? Janis Joplin phase?



Maybe, but it has sold, what, 2 million, 3 million? I'd like to have had that career.


I like Kelly Clarkson's new sound. I would much rather her do this than the ultra lightweight pop.
 
MODS.....why don't you merge this into the AI thread........


Jordin will be the 3rd most successful AI right out of the box.



There is no bigger AI fan on ODJT than I am... My thoughts are the exact opposite. She will be the worst selling AI, IMO.... except for maybe Ruben, who actually does extremely well in his genre -- gospel. Possibly Fantasia, but she has sold a ton too.... it's just that many of us middle aged white guys never noticed.
 
MODS.....why don't you merge this into the AI thread........


Jordin will be the 3rd most successful AI right out of the box.


This doesn't prove your point or mine, but look at the chart near the bottom of the page..... she sure would have big shoes to fill....


American Idol - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia@@AMEPARAM@@/wiki/File:American_Idol_logo.png" class="image"><img alt="American Idol logo.png" src="http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/3/3c/American_Idol_logo.png"@@AMEPARAM@@en/3/3c/American_Idol_logo.png
 
Au contraire.....mon Patrique......

the ratings dwindled because the show became predictable.

After April 6th, it became pretty obvious we were headed for a Melinda - Blake - Jordin final three.

As I recall, the ratings were still pretty level with last year, prior to Sanjaya being eliminated. Once the San-Man got booted, the ratings started to taper off.
 
While that may be true, I think the biggest concern is the second part of the article. Ad buyers do not want to invest millions in a show that does not appeal to that golden 18-35 age genre.

As you and I both know, shows like Studio 60 would still be on the air if the rate cards went by total ratings instead of just focussing on the 18-35's. I think this really is something to be concerned about. Plus, the show is not a strong a lead in as it had been in the past.
 
There is no bigger AI fan on ODJT than I am... My thoughts are the exact opposite. She will be the worst selling AI, IMO.... except for maybe Ruben, who actually does extremely well in his genre -- gospel. Possibly Fantasia, but she has sold a ton too.... it's just that many of us middle aged white guys never noticed.

I'm gonna go out on a limb on this one (not just because she is from my city)

This girl is gonna have a huge singing career. She is only 17, I put her right up there with other young ladies that had outstanding pipes for their age...LeeAnne Rimes, Karen Carpenter, Whitney Houston, Etc. I think with proper guidance, she'll be around for a while.
 
I'm gonna go out on a limb on this one (not just because she is from my city)

This girl is gonna have a huge singing career. She is only 17, I put her right up there with other young ladies that had outstanding pipes for their age...LeeAnne Rimes, Karen Carpenter, Whitney Houston, Etc. I think with proper guidance, she'll be around for a while.



Long term I probably agree... Matt had her as 3rd right out of the box.
 
Long term I probably agree... Matt had her as 3rd right out of the box.

Look at how much Deejay Dan adores her. I think that sums up the market for Jordin (18-24 y/o males). Plus she has a very mature voice, and can make Old Standards new again (Rodgers & Hammerstein, Cole Porter, C/W, etc).

There's no way she will duplicate Carrie's 6 million sales of a first CD.

But there's a good chance her first CD will match Daughtrey (not an Idol, so he doesn't count in top three).

If you count Daughtrey (4th place) and Clay Aiken (2nd place), then Jordin will be in FIFTH PLACE IN TOTAL SALES by the end of 2009.

When I said 3rd, I meant among First Place Idol Winners. She will smoke Fantasia, Ruben, & Taylor. When the dust settles in 2 years, with the right management and production, Jordin will have a stellar career.