Wow, Talk About Being Brutally Honest...

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
I blame the "music video" promoters for this nonsense. :rolleyes:

Sorry, but I do not need "video" to enjoy music. I don't know what the artists look like nor do I care. I listen to radio and CDX discs. I don't need scenes of pickup trucks, tractors, overdone special effects, Barbie doll look-alike models etc. That's just a fantasy. Gimme the music any day.

But I'm not sixteen years old, either. The music industry isn't marketing to me anymore. ;)
 
[Female Singer Rant On]
Gee, I've been hearing the same thing about Ann Wilson for the last 20 years. Great voice, don't look at her; it's all Nancy....

Like ... anyone from Limp Bizkit, Staind, Godsmack, Daughtry... is anything to *look* at.
[Female Singer Rant Off]

So, Paris and Brooke get the recording contracts?

[In Mr. Roger's voice:] Can you say Director's Couch, children? I knew that you could.
 
There should be a contract put on Paris not given to her

Melinda Doolittle will end up OK. I dont watch alot of Idol its little more than a popularity contest but from what I seen she had talent and that will prevail in the long run
 
Out of the... 0... seasons of AI I've watched, I still follow the "winners."

This is the 6th Season, right? I think two "winners" are still "on the charts." I think about four (six... eight...) "losers" are on the charts today? (R&B, T40, AC, Country, AN ACADEMY AWARD, whatever....)

Yep, I've (ignored) enough to know why Simon's record label failed. (Simon Cowell - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia@@AMEPARAM@@/wiki/File:Simon_Cowell.jpg" class="image" title="Cowell at the National Television Awards at the Royal Albert Hall, London, October 2006."><img alt="" src="http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a1/Simon_Cowell.jpg/220px-Simon_Cowell.jpg"@@AMEPARAM@@commons/thumb/a/a1/Simon_Cowell.jpg/220px-Simon_Cowell.jpg)
 
Paris should just fade away. Talk about no talent at all.
 
Here are excerpts from an outstanding interview of Frank Zappa by Steve Birchall for the October 1984 and November 1984 issues of Digital Audio magazine:

If you want to be honest about it, modern music is a sick puppy.

I can write good music. The only problem is that I can't get people to play it.

I don't think anybody in America has heard an accurate performance of anything except dead people's music in the last 50 years.

The most reactionary music on this planet is popular music. Its restrictions are even more rigorous than in classical music. In order for it to be popular music, it must be this, this, and this. Those rhythms. These chord changes. This type of lyrics.

You're talking about the single most useless thing an American can do: Write music. Unless you're writing a song to be a hit record or writing a jingle for a product, there's no reason for anybody in America to write music. It's useless. It's literally without function in this society. People should just stop doing it - and stop teaching it.

What stops progress in the U.S. is that there are too many lawyers and too many accountants. Aesthetic decisions in music and the other arts have all been placed into the hands of these people, so we're now at the mercy of their taste.

I notice how kids listen to records, and they don't listen to the music. I mean, they hear it and then if they've seen the video, they already know what the thing's supposed to sound like. They make a snap decision about whether or not they like it, and the amount of involvement with the music as a composition is very small. It's like they're saying, OK, I've consumed it. Quick - where's the next thing? It's all over; it's gone. I remember the records I used to listen to when I was in school. I played them till you could see through them. And I loved it just because it was music; I didn't care.

But I don't see the same type of consumer patterns today. The material the kids are listening to is disposable. It has no content, and it really doesn't mean anything. So probably it's not worthwhile for them to sit and gyrate over it anyway.

If they ever come into contact with any music that has some depth, or something above and beyond the backbeat of the Simmons snare and the handclaps and all that other cliched-to-death stuff, they won't know how to deal with it. It'll be dealt with the same as the disposable material.

And adding to the misery of the whole thing is the idea of video music as the approved modern way to consume music. It's not even music anymore - you don't hear it, you see it. You can stand to look at it six times maybe before you've seen every cliche' on the screen, and then it's useless.

I made one video. Just to show you how far we've come, rock 'n' roll on television to be when Don Kirshner's cameraman would take a picture of the lights. Remember that? You get the shot of the lights, and the cameraman pulls back to show the group. We've come so far since that time that it's unbelievable. Science is so wonderful the way it's made life so perfect. And that's where you should end the interview.
 
[Female Singer Rant On]
Gee, I've been hearing the same thing about Ann Wilson for the last 20 years. Great voice, don't look at her; it's all Nancy....

Like ... anyone from Limp Bizkit, Staind, Godsmack, Daughtry... is anything to *look* at.
[Female Singer Rant Off]

So, Paris and Brooke get the recording contracts?

[In Mr. Roger's voice:] Can you say Director's Couch, children? I knew that you could.


I'm gonna have to disagree on Daughtry but I see where you're going with this.
 
An interview with Martha Wash about her "real" thoughts and feelings in relationship with Black Box and C&C Music Factory video non-involvement would be an interesting read.
 
Out of the... 0... seasons of AI I've watched, I still follow the "winners."

This is the 6th Season, right? I think two "winners" are still "on the charts." I think about four (six... eight...) "losers" are on the charts today? (R&B, T40, AC, Country, AN ACADEMY AWARD, whatever....)
[/URL])

Kelly Clarkson - 10 million CDs sold
Carrie Underwood - 5 million CDs sold

(4th place) Chris Daughtrey - 2 million CDs sold (on way to 5 million)
(2nd place) Clay Aiken - 3 million CDs sold
(7th place) Jennifer Hudson - BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS OSCAR
(2nd place) Bo Bice - 2 hit singles (including "Inside Your Heaven")
(4th place) Kimberly Locke - 2 hit singles including "Eighth World Wonder"
(?) Joshua Gracin - gospel & Country hit songs
(5th place) Kelly Pickler - Country songs & TV personality
(?) Bucky Covington - just released his first C/W disc.

Idol Winners that are underperforming:

Fantasia Barrino (on Broadway doing "The Color Purple"_
Ruben Studdard (worst performing Idol so far)
Taylor Hicks (disappointing 1st album)

Idol contestant likely to become a teeny pop/Disney channel fave:

Sanjaya Malakar!

Altogether, a pretty decent showing for a Talent Show.

Overall, I'd say BETTER THAN STAR SEARCH:

Star Search ran for TEN YEARS, and the best they could come up with?
Sinbad
 
With the advent of the "video" replays, it should be no surprise to anyone...."Sex Sells". Let's face it Advertising controls what you see and when you see it. Hopefully they continue to find both the Talented as well as the those with the "Eye Candy" appeal, or the industry will be in big trouble.
 
Melinda...

...was the best singer (IMO) that ever appeared on AI. Who screwed with the ratings?
 
Kelly Clarkson - 10 million CDs sold
Carrie Underwood - 5 million CDs sold

(4th place) Chris Daughtrey - 2 million CDs sold (on way to 5 million)
(2nd place) Clay Aiken - 3 million CDs sold...


...Overall, I'd say BETTER THAN STAR SEARCH:

Star Search ran for TEN YEARS, and the best they could come up with?
Sinbad

Well yeah and let us not forget William Hung and She Bangs which sold 200,000 copies. It goes to show you can sell almost any dreck to the American public. I'll leave the better/worse judgment to you as it is too painful to watch AI for more than a minute or two. It is basically a manner less Ted Mac Amateur Hour.

There is no argument that given your metric it is better than the other dismal attempt. Still, you have to wade through an awful lot of excrement to find a gem on AI.

This isn't a challenge to your contentions MC, just someone who can't understand why it is popular. Arrrggh, shudder.

And damn it! I agree with Fred. The visual should not be an issue in music. I don't give a rat's tucas what the hell they look like.