Stu...I guess my first question to you is, "are you a parent?"
Frankly, I'm glad my parents interfered in my social life. That's what parents are supposed to do. Yes, as kids we don't like it but their interference can be the very thing that saves us from tons of heartache later down the road. I can only speak for my own parents. Some people have horrible parents and I can see how they would think differently.
I laugh my ass off when people justify a parent's/school/authority figures "non actions" by saying, "hey they're just going to do it anyway!" What a great way to look at life. No thank you...I'm not going to put my parental duties (or school official duties if I was in that position) on the shelf just because they're going to "do it anyway." Sometimes you have to make tough decisions in life and being a parent is not for the faint of heart.
I can't speak for Bogart/Bacall as that was waaaay before my time but I remember my mom talking about it with disdain numerous times. Are you really painting an accurate picture regarding the social acceptance of it at the time? As has been mentioned....times have changed drastically since our grandparents dated. They got married at much younger ages but they actually STAYED MARRIED! And that's a whooooole 'nother subject. So many things have screwed that up but suffice it to say that the average 17 yr old girl in the 40's and 50's had a hell of lot more sense then ones of today.
Ashton Kutcher was not in high school when he started dating Demi Moore. Who cares. If he wants to date an old broad when he can get any young hot piece of a $ $ in Hollywood that he wants...that's his business but he's incredibly stupid for doing so.
If this girl was out of high school I don't care what she does but the fact that she isn't makes all the difference in the world to me. Sure it's only a matter of a few months but it's the principle.
Suffice it to say that I have some parenting experience.
That said, we're NOT talking about KIDS. If you were referring to 12-year-olds, then I most certainly would agree. But we're not. We're talking about 18. That magical number when society says we're fully capable and accountable. And that also means that your legal duties as a parent are over. You can toss 'em out of your house on their butts and the law is cool fine n' dandy with it.
It also doesn't matter what decade it is: people remain the same. Our attitudes have changed, but attitude is only relevant to the person who has it. If you think that dating older women is repulsive, then that's your head trip. If you think that dating much younger women is repulsive; ditto. (And I'm talking WOMEN here, not kids.) Tastes, fashions, trends and attitudes are always in flux. They're also cyclical. The "times" only change because of these factors. It won't matter if, in a thousand years, parents are on a starship orbiting a planet in another solar system, there will STILL be fights with their teenage kids over who they're dating!
Once our kids -- PEOPLE -- have reached adulthood, your love doesn't stop. That's a given. But your "duties" -- and your ability to dictate what is orthodox in their lives -- are over. Legally and morally. Your opinions and advice at that point may be welcome or not, but your offspring have the right to accept or reject your advice and make their own decisions. It's a fact of life that goes down hard for some parents. They get used to being "THE authority." Well, get over it.
Yes, it would be a great world if our kids could learn from our mistakes. Sometimes they even pull it off! But quite often there are times when a kid must learn for themselves. (And, let's face it, sometimes our parents WERE full of crap!) It's understandably hard for a parent to watch their kids fall flat on their face, too. But we gave 'em the advice -- we do our best. It's up to them at that point. If you can resist the snide "I told you so" and, instead, be there to help dust 'em off for the next round, they might have gained enough respect for your opinions to listen next time. Or the next.
Oh, and yes, they WILL "just do it anyway." You can take all kinds of drastic action when they're little, but when they're 18+ and have the legal right to make their own decisions, they WILL use that right. They will make choices that you might not. They'll choose things you specifically warned them about, maybe out of spite or maybe because they disagree with you. Again, there's nothing you can do about it. Think back to when you were growing up. Can you honestly tell me that you didn't reject your parent's advise on occasion... and everything was still OK? The world didn't end, the sun still comes up in the morning...
Personally, I think ol' Ashton did pretty good. When I was 12 years old, I was always attracted to older women. When I was 18, my GF was 29. People thought that was odd, but not illegal or immoral! I didn't marry until I was 28, and by then my age had "synched" to my tastes. Now I'm near 50, and the 30-somethings still turn my head. Today, some might still see that as odd, but for the opposite reason! Today, it's attitude that drives the obsession with youth, sometimes to the point of extremes.
Lastly, people didn't stay married any moreso than they do today. There was the "free love" blip in the '60s, but that's all it was: a blip. Then as now, about half of all marriages fail. Kinda like restaurants. And guess what? It's NOT THE END OF THE WORLD!!! People survive and move on. If you've never had emotional hurt, you haven't lived. Parents: let your kids live.