We're talking about micro-managing clients who want to "DJ by proxy" then blame us (the DJs) if their ideas didn't work.
Yeah, I got that - it's called fear and a need to control and you're not even aware of how well you preach it. Read you're own words above - you're afraid of blame and you want to micro-manage (another word for control.) You said that - not me.
One, the girl gave an full, exact list, even down to specific versions of songs. I spoke to her about it, she didn't like what I had to say, then we did it the way she said. Her event sucked rocks and came off precisely as I told her it was going to happen.
Sounds like a self-fulfilling prophecy.
You should not have taken the event if you knew you could not deliver what she was asking for. You told her you would fail and then you proved yourself right. What's not controlling about that?
Had another one where the girl had a sucky list but in this case, when I spoke with her about it and asked her point blank "Do you want a dance party or do you want your list? You can't have both." she backed down (somewhat) and gave me latitude. Her party was a huge success and she sings my praises.
"My way or the highway." What's not controlling about that?
There is a time where you have to find a way to tactfully let the client know when they're stepping on themselves. Past that, you do what they demand, smile, and do everything that's within your power to do. Past that, you do have to just smile and realize you've done everything you could.
That sounds like you're willing to be really fake and phony with people. There is also a time to admit that a particular client is asking for something you don't know how to deliver and rather than take something away from them - decline the job and refer them to someone who knows how to give them BOTH their list and the party they want.
I've been handed lists over the years that I thought were crappy only to discover that the client knew their crowd in ways that I would likely never have anticipated with songs I would not have gone to. To be given a guided tour in other musical directions is valuable experience and is likely the difference between your confidence level and mine. You need to stay with the familiar and I don't. It's that simple.