Had one off the hook great last night. Everything worked, energy through the roof. Tonight's adventure begins last week, first time I'd seen any requests from the B&G. Instead of filling out my Online Planner, she sends me a 5-page Word doc. Bunch of prelim dances; mom/grandma, 2 "first dances" (I dunno), mom & dad, etc. Weird, and I predict it's going to feel like forever. Then we get into the requests. First thing off, she says "definitely don't want played"; Baby Got Back, YMCA, Cupid, Dougie, Wobble, Cha Cha Slide, "or any of those group type dance songs". I got on the phone with her and spent about 20 minutes, gently telling her "You can either have your list or you can have a dance party, but you can't have both." (I was diplomatic). She said she understood, wants a dance party and agreed to let me shift several of the "must plays" into the dinner set. Problem is, this is a monumentally-bad list of songs. Worst I've ever seen, no contest. We're talking things like "Angel From Montgomery" Susan Tedeschi, "The Seed" The Roots, "Dudley's Kitchen" The String Cheese Incident, "Got It All" Portugal The Man. I wasn't familiar with about half her selections and took the time to listen and categorize each. She swears that her crowd is not your typical wedding crowd and they won't be requesting the mainstays and I made sure to assure her that I only wanted to please her and try to make as much work as possible. Problem is, I can't say that I see even one single selection that will even remotely work on the drunkest of crowds. Who knows, I might be completely surprised but I'm predicting a train wreck. My question, when posed with a perceived "no win" situation like this, do you just strictly play the list or do you try to sprinkle enough of the list into the middle of stuff that works (of course, avoiding a large portion of your go-to list)?
Last edited:
