QSC HPR speakers

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
G

Guest

Guest
I must be the only DJ who hasn't heard the new QSC's yet. My local GC doesn't have them in stock.

Ok, so here's the deal I just ordered a pair of Mackie SA 1521z. I'll be getting them on Friday. What scares me about the mackies is all their reliablity issues. I could get a pair of the QSC HPR 152i for just a little more money. Has anyone heard this speaker? what are your thoughts on this?
 
I must be the only DJ who hasn't heard the new QSC's yet. My local GC doesn't have them in stock.

Ok, so here's the deal I just ordered a pair of Mackie SA 1521z. I'll be getting them on Friday. What scares me about the mackies is all their reliablity issues. I could get a pair of the QSC HPR 152i for just a little more money. Has anyone heard this speaker? what are your thoughts on this?

:bconfused: Your not going to get the RCF's?:bconfused:
 
:bconfused: Your not going to get the RCF's?:bconfused:

The 322a is the best deal in the price range. I just need more output then a 128 db. Thats why I'm getting the Mackies they have a 133 db peak. I also love their bass without subs. I heard the Macks at a outdoor biker rally and they sounded very good without subs. I was about 50 feet away from FOH and I could still feel the bass hitting me.
 
As long as you heard them... Spec's on paper can be a funny thing, they are normally 'calculated', not actually taken live and should be taken with a grain of salt... I would not doubt that the 15" wooden cab Mackie has more bass but mid / high throw is another story...

The new 1521z has 100 watts going to the compression driver and the original RCF 4PRO3001-A only has 50 watts going to it. Could that be because the RCF driver is far more efficient? I would tend to think so...

In my opinion, the 1" exit horn in the Mackie will not 'out-throw' the larger 2" exit horn of the 322A.

Oh Pat... What say you?
 
As long as you heard them... Spec's on paper can be a funny thing, they are normally 'calculated', not actually taken live and should be taken with a grain of salt...

The new 1521z has 100 watts going to the compression driver and the original RCF 4PRO3001-A only has 50 watts going to it. Could that be because the RCF driver is far more efficient? I would tend to think so...

In my opinion, the 1" exit horn in the Mackie will not 'out-throw' the larger 2" exit horn of the 322A.

Oh Pat... What say you?

There goes Maestro stirring the RCF pot again..:sqwink:

Well for what it's worth I do feel confident with my RCF's for large events. But only with a sub or subs involved. The Mackies do handle well and have better lows without the use of a sub. I ran a set of Mackie S500's and S250's at events without a sub and they do sound better alone than my RCF's do alone.
 
I've heard the New QSC 122's. (Granted it was in the tiny demo room at the local music store)

They sounded pretty good to me, (i'm considering the purchase of a pair for smaller bar gig's)
 
The 322a is the best deal in the price range. I just need more output then a 128 db. Thats why I'm getting the Mackies they have a 133 db peak. I also love their bass without subs. I heard the Macks at a outdoor biker rally and they sounded very good without subs. I was about 50 feet away from FOH and I could still feel the bass hitting me.


Yeah, I agree. I bought the 1521's at first, for just that reason, but returned them as soon as I realized i couldn't handle the size / weight by myself.
 
Yeah, I agree. I bought the 1521's at first, for just that reason, but returned them as soon as I realized i couldn't handle the size / weight by myself.

Papa,

Do you run them into limiting at a gig before you returned them? If so, did they sound harsh?
 
Papa,

Do you run them into limiting at a gig before you returned them? If so, did they sound harsh?


I never actually used them at an event. I set them up at home once... :sqwink:
 
Definitely take the HPR over the Mackie. We carry both... but I'm telling you.. that's the way to go.

Incidentally, we have some of our Mobile Beat demos for sale now, and a returned pair of 122s (DJ had to leave the business for health reasons, speakers are still new). So we have some rocking deals on them. We have the ENTIRE HPR series in stock. :)

PM me for details on the deals.

Ben
 




In my opinion, the 1" exit horn in the Mackie will not 'out-throw' the larger 2" exit horn of the 322A.

Oh Pat... What say you?


The 2 inch neo driver is matted to 1.5 inch exit on the 322a. Your right their is nothing under a thousand per cab that can compare to that. If the 322a had a higher output I would buy it.

By the way were is Pat? Out playing golf some where?
 
The Mackie SA1521z is rated for 130 dB continuous output. It has a 15" woofer with a 3" voice coil and ceramic ferrite magnet. The neo magnet high frequency driver is 1.75" diaphragm, 1" exit. Nominal dispersion is 75 x 85. It weighs 101 lbs., has a pole mount but no flyware.

The RCF ART322A is rated for 128 dB continuous output. It has a 12" woofer with a 3" voice coil and neodymium magnet. The neo magnet high frequency driver has a 3" diaphragm, 1.4" exit. Nominal dispersion is 90 x 60. It weighs 51 lbs., has a pole mount, flyware and mounting points for brackets.
 
The Mackie SA1521z is rated for 130 dB continuous output. It has a 15" woofer with a 3" voice coil and ceramic ferrite magnet. The neo magnet high frequency driver is 1.75" diaphragm, 1" exit. Nominal dispersion is 75 x 85. It weighs 101 lbs., has a pole mount but no flyware.

The RCF ART322A is rated for 128 dB continuous output. It has a 12" woofer with a 3" voice coil and neodymium magnet. The neo magnet high frequency driver has a 3" diaphragm, 1.4" exit. Nominal dispersion is 90 x 60. It weighs 51 lbs., has a pole mount, flyware and mounting points for brackets.

Mike, About the 322i the passive version has a sensitivity rating of 99 db. And the 322a has a amp thats rated at 400 watts rms with a 800 watt peak. When I did my calculations that comes out to a 128 db peak. Is the 322a rated for a 128 db peak or is that the continuous rating? Does Bang & Olufsen make the TAD amps for the ART series?

The RCF blows away the Mackie when it comes to dispersion. I don't like the Mackie's 75 degree horizonal dispersion pattern. I have two reasons why I like the Mack. One it has great bass without a sub and two I need its higher output for outdoor gigs. The Mack will peak 133 db and the QSC 152i will do a 135 db peak.

I read a post of someone who owns a pair of 322a was thinking about getting a differant set of tops because they wanted something with more output. This was after they just did a school dance. Another guy who has the RCF TT tops ran his mains in to clipping on his first night out with them. This makes me think that I should get the QSC 152i because of its higher output. I like having the high headroom that the QSC has. When I get my second LS 808 my bass will have a 140db peak when coupled. The QSC should be a good match for my subs.

Mike, If I've gone wrong with my calculations here please correct me, thank you.
 
Hey G, I know selecting the right speaker can be a PITA. If you can, go to a local SamAsh and listen to the HPR and make that thing slam. I think you made the right move with the Mackie for the type of sound you are looking for. The whole made in China and going thermal thing is nothing to worry about with the model you chose. The QSC's are good, but see which one out of the two will give you the best bang for the buck.