The RIAA's Next Step: Music Prohibition

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

What will the RIAA's next method of discouraging illegal downloads?

  • Re-release "Feelings" as a mega-mix hit single

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Outlaw music completely, as this thread suggests

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Start selling good music in a format that would make it worth paying for

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Re-animate Elvis and send his corpse on tour

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    13
From an article linked today, it looks like some are starting to challenge the RIAA's bully lawsuits. Personally, I'm worried about what this could mean for the future of DJ's and music in general.

Once this "scare tactic lawsuit" method of discouraging illegal musical distribution is exhausted, the only option left will be complete prohibition. Like alcohol, drugs, and guns...the only truly effective way to combat the problem of illegal music distribution is by OUTLAWING music completely. All music sales will stop completely. Playing any copyrighted music of any kind will be against the law. CD-R's, MP3 players, and computers will all be confiscated as sound reproduction "paraphernalia."

I know that this step is drastic and scary, but what other option does the RIAA have?

(/sarcasm)
 
I think even with the losses the music industry would be lynched by all the artists. I think the Canadians are doing something about this by adding a surcharge to CD-R/CD-RW's that are sold. Maybe increasing the fee a little bit and channel this money to the labels would offset things. Let's face it there's no way piracy will be stop. Even with all the technology to try to prevent it.

Once the new antipiracy technology is implemented, one will find a way around it. So a surcharge on sales of blank media should help some.
 
Yeah, let the gangs, guns and drugs rule the streets, the illegals drive cars and vote, etc, but for God's sake, STOP THE PIRACY OF MUSIC!

That other stuff is too hard to deal with.

[/sarcasm]?
 
knowledge is power my friends.... and it isn't a crime to use it...


Quotation #9999 from Poor Man's College: "Creative powers can just as easily turn out to be destructive. It rests solely with the moral personality whether they apply themselves to good things or to bad. And if this is lacking, no teacher can supply it or take its place" Carl Jung Swiss psychologist (1875 - 1961)
 
Way over the top dude!

None of that is ever going to happen. First and formost the thing to realize with all of the RIAA stupidity is that there is one motivation behind all of :I]Save our jobs![/I] The record companies and the RIAA itself are a bunch of dinosaurs in the digital age and they know it and the lawsuits are nothing more but an attempt to stave off the inevitable.

The record companies see their control of the product slipping from their fingers. An artist can sell far fewer songs yet make more money off of their own work if they promote themselves on the internet and not sign any record deals. Prince once said after he got out of his contract with Warners that even though he only now sold 100,000 + units of new music he still made as much or more than he did under contract from a record company. You will also notice that a couple of years ago shortly before the real stupidity started a record company signed prince at a staggering amount that isn't justified by his actual popularity today. The idea was to remove him from the independent market where he was promoting to artists how to do for themselves. The industry threw money at him to shut him up but unfortunately the for them the word is out.

No one has ever satisfactorily proved that sales are down due to file trading in the industry. In fact many artists have proved that file trading increases sales if the music is worth buying in the first place! The RIAA is trying to put a HipHop Masher in jail for 20 years and the artists are having fits because one of his mashes is worth an additional 100,000 units sold even though the mash is distributed for free.

The industry though don't want to admit to that because they want to not only sell you the song, they want to sell it to you 5 different times. Want it on cd, that's one, your ipod - 2, music video - 3, cell phone - 4, a remix - 5 and so on, that is what DRM is about! Not protecting their product but forcing the "honest" consumer to purchase the same thing over and over again to listen to it in different ways.:sqmad:

The industry is producing crap on top of that. I mean how many more flash in the pans do we have to put up with like Hilton, Spears most of the American Idols do they think they can sell? Long term profits are made from selling the same artist you invested a little in again and again over the years. Rolling Stones, Beatles, Fleetwood Mac, Aerosmith... Artists with staying power. No one expected Spears to sell past the first 3 albums at most and even now who can really remember her last album, we know she lost her panties though. But the industry wants to invest in artists like Spears instead of cultivating actual good, lasting music because they think they can control and make more from them than they can the good type. So sales go down.

It happened in the early 90's and then they blamed tower records and threatened legal action for used cd retailers. It took new artists like Pearl Jam, Nirvana and such with actual good, long lasting music to pull the industry out of it's slump back then.

I mean think about it what songs from 2000, 2, 3, and 4 do you get requests for today. For me there are a few country songs and the cha cha slide, but not much else. Look at the top 200 that mobile beat generates off of their little request program, there isn't much new stuff on there. Pour Some Sugar On Me was on the radio when I started High School.

Frankly what you fear isn't going to happen, not even close. What will happen is the RIAA will go the way of the dino and the record companies we know today will look radically different. The record companies are becoming non issues.

As a Dj I keep up to date with record company music from RPM as a music fan, I haven't bought a record company album except for Wierd Al's latest in years instead I surf MySpace and directly support talented artists like Gina LaPiana ones who can actually sing!
 
I don't like the idea of a CD Tax, what percentage of cds do you burn as audio discs, data discs? What about companies that don't mess with audio of that sort yet have to burn data, they are having to pay out of it... Could be set up for abuse.
 
I don't like the idea of a CD Tax, what percentage of cds do you burn as audio discs, data discs? What about companies that don't mess with audio of that sort yet have to burn data, they are having to pay out of it... Could be set up for abuse.

From what I have read in the countries where these "taxes" are applied, no artists have seen any money. In fact I believe there is a massive lawsuit going on in Canada over just this very thing.

One last thing on my original post I left out. The RIAA really should be put out of existance, it is a thinly disguised law firm that is shoved off onto the artists and copyright holders. It is a good idea gone bad. If you have read much about the RIAA you will find that not only does the labels feed it massive amounts of money but there is no evidence that monetary awards have ever actually been paid to the real "victims" from the money the RIAA has "won". In fact they declared in the file sharing cases they were going to keep the money to fund further lawsuits. So they are getting money from the lawsuits and they are being funded large amounts by the labels! Who exactly is really the beneficiary here!

This is another example of the "control" issue. If independant recording artists/writers/producers were the ones responsible for their own work then let's be honest the RIAA ceases to exist. I am a videographer, I do not have a battalion of lawyers ready to file suit against violators of my copyright. I have to find the violators myself, hire the lawyer myself and pay for the litagation myself, like nearly every other creative individual out there, except for the recording industry and the movies. In fact the RIAA does not operate at the behest of their employers, they actively seek out offenders on their own and keep the rewards. I know in lawsuits the lawyers usually end up with most of the money, but this is just ridiclous the plantiffs usually see something from the proceedings. We have a pack of lawyers out of control!

The RIAA at this point sees the writing on the wall, they know their time with the time of the Labels is limited and are performing the equivalent of a crash and grab.
 
Very well put Brian, I am a videographer and lead video editor at my place of employment, I personally would be offended if I heard somebody rip off our DVD's, it prob has been done, duly noted they are a little pricy, but beyond the fact that I would like to be indirectly compensated even if I don't get the extra money or not. It keeps my job. (in a roundabout way)
 
I've Posted before....
Basically another Tax in an Overtaxed Canada


The Copyright Board of Canada administers the Copyright Act and sets the amount of the levies on blank recording media and determines which media will have levies imposed. almost 10 years ago this seemed like a pretty good deal for the music industry: $0.77 CDN for a blank CD and .29 a blank tape, whether used for recording music or not. Found money for the music moguls who had been pretty disturbed that some of their product was being burned onto CDs. To date over 70 million dollars has been collected through the levy and there is a good possibility the levy will be raised and extended to MP3 players, flash memory cards and recordable DVDs


Copyright Board's Decision
Private Copying 1999-2000
 
In the US I think we ARE already paying a "media tax" in the price of media such as blank CDs Tape and MD, wasn't that imposed back in the 80's?????

In regards to the RIAA, as time goes on they will become less relevant and fade as the NEED for Artists to have a major Label will fade. Technology is such that you don't need a multi-million dollar studio to record. For what it would cost to use a studio to record a whole album, the Artist could totally outfit themselves!

You DON"T need a major label to promote or distribute the music just look at the internet now! All the forms of marketing available as well as webcasting mixed with building a following live, it can be done by the artist!
 
Start selling good music in a format that would make it worth paying for

Isn't that what capitalism is all about?

I bought the new Norah Jones CD, for $9.99 at Tar-gay

I've said for many years......put out a CD with four or more songs that I'm gonna play, and I'll gladly pay $10 for it.
 
Start selling good music in a format that would make it worth paying for

Isn't that what capitalism is all about?

I bought the new Norah Jones CD, for $9.99 at Tar-gay

I've said for many years......put out a CD with four or more songs that I'm gonna play, and I'll gladly pay $10 for it.

:notworthy::notworthy::notworthy::notworthy:

:clap: :clap: Amen to that! :clap: :clap:

In a lot of cases, I'd be happy if they just put two good songs on a disc... :D
 
I voted for the puppy slayings. It's the most likely of the things the RIAA would do to get people to stop music piracy.

Here's a suggestion to the RIAA: you should have stopped the general public from being able to DUPLICATE ANYTHING TO BEGIN WITH!
Should have never allowed blank cassettes, cds, dvds to be sold.
Should have never allowed cd/dvd copying/burning programs to exist.

That's my opinion. Probably a little blunt...
 
Here's a suggestion to the RIAA: you should have stopped the general public from being able to DUPLICATE ANYTHING TO BEGIN WITH!
Should have never allowed blank cassettes, cds, dvds to be sold.
Should have never allowed cd/dvd copying/burning programs to exist.

Hmmm... They tried! The case was called Sony vs MPAA back in the early 80's. Consumer rights won out.
 
Oh...I didn't know that. Thanks!

Wait..."consumer rights"...I thought "consumers" didn't have any rights.

Yup we do...

The right to remain silent....
 
Sony was preparing for this back in the mid '70s. Video tape recording was an old technology even then but it was limited to television stations. I remember the huge reel to reel video tape decks, lol.

It wasn't a big deal until it was converted to cassette form (VCR) and available to the consumer's home. In reality, any media that is broadcast may be recorded and reproduced by the consumer for personal use.