The groom asks if I use Spotify and is surprised by my answer.

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

Hank Davidson

Affordable, yet priceless.
ODJT Supporter
Nov 15, 2006
7,354
1,663
61
Boston, MA
www.facebook.com
This is just something that happened and an observation/opinion. It might make a good topic for discussion.

I had to get a few songs for the groom prior to the event. I was able to find them on Amazon....

So, after playing a couple, he comes up and thanks me for playing the songs. He then asks (in a given kind of tone), "You using Spotify?" When I said no, he looked surprised and said "Really, why not?" I just told him that I was able to obtain the tracks on Amazon. The end.

Still, it's always amazing how most people at a function just casually assume that we are using some internet means of streaming music, rather than having a stored library. Most everyone has a smart phone and can access any song, anytime they want. I haven't used Spotify at all, but if it is in fact a way to play any song on the fly, what's to stop anyone from doing it? Are we now to be chastised and frowned upon by guests/clients that don't understand why we are not using these means? And as soon as sound and lighting becomes more modern, compact and accessible, what's to stop everyone from having some?

I know that there will always be a need and a benefit to have a professional DJ, but you can't deny that this will eventually take a large piece out of the pie.
 
Im like you. I get all my songs from Amazon. Altho I have used Spotify, but only for home use. Most of the places I go to dont have internet access. So, I have to have all the music before my show. Even if a place has internet access, I still wouldnt use streaming music, due to the fact that the music is only as good as the internet connection. If the connection is low, the music is crappy, and we get beat down by the clients. I agree with you 100%.
 
I would say
"I know what you mean. You would think that would the way to go. What I've found is that with streaming music, the possibility of a glitch is very real. You don't want to hear what a glitch sounds like blasting through theses speakers."
 
I would never use streaming songs, period. In any event, no matter the situation. I would download a song at an event if I didn't happen to have it, then listen to parts of it to make sure it is okay (but I trust my source), and play THAT.... but never ever would I stream.
And Hank, you are right about that taking a big chunk of the pie. We have discussed this lightly in other threads too, but it is blatantly taking business away from you guys. Being a club DJ has more accountability... you have to "audition" most of the time, and usually you start out with a few guest spots... but when you get hired to do a wedding, it is usually based on how you sell yourself, not how you DJ... so they can pick some $50 "DJ" who uses (as per your example) Spotify to DJ, and sells that as a bonus.
"I use spotify to play music, so if there is ANYTHING that you want to hear, I have it at my fingertips. It is much better than someone who uses CDs or Music Files on a computer, since they are limited by what they have. I don't have any limitations, as I can play anything, literally anything, right away". And the B&G would fawn over him with things like "He is WAY less expensive than those other DJ's, AND he can get us any songs we want, right away... we should go with him".
They don't understand the horror they are about to witness. I mean, what if the venue has NO internet at all? Even if the guy has his own mobile hot spot, what if there is no signal? Mobile hot spots work just like cell phones... if there is no 3G or 4G signal on your phone, there won't be one on your hot spot. Add to that the fact that most hotel wi-fi is HORRIFICALLY SLOW, the guy streaming with Spotify will literally be playing nothing.
So although I think there will be a rush of wannabe's, I don't see them lasting too long. Word of mouth spreads fairly fast when it comes to trends, and once people start talking about how bad of an experience it was to hire a DJ who uses "on demand" music, the $50 Spotify DJ will start to diminish.... but you will always have those $50 DJ's with a PA system and a laptop/iPod! lol
 
Good topic Hank. I can't count how many times I've had somebody say to me "Can't you just download it". And this is only going to get worse. With smart phones some people expect EVERYTHING and they want it NOW. I'm already having people want to plug phones into my system. They could care less about how legal you are.

99.9+ percent of my music has come from Promo Only CDs, Promo Only POOL, or I have the CD. The only time I ever download from Itunes is when I can't obtain the track on disc. Some will say that makes me a pirate but I do pay for what I use.
 
Totally agree with everything here. No streaming, legal libraries, etc. I don't use Internet at any shows.
 
Good topic Hank. I can't count how many times I've had somebody say to me "Can't you just download it". And this is only going to get worse. With smart phones some people expect EVERYTHING and they want it NOW. I'm already having people want to plug phones into my system. They could care less about how legal you are.

99.9+ percent of my music has come from Promo Only CDs, Promo Only POOL, or I have the CD. The only time I ever download from Itunes is when I can't obtain the track on disc. Some will say that makes me a pirate but I do pay for what I use.

I have only had this happen once. I imagine it will get worse. In my case I said the truth - that it goes against the terms of service of the site. I also said that I don't play ANYTHING unless I hear it first, ESPECIALLY if I don't know the song. No way I am dropping bad language on a crowd. My one exception was at an event that was primarily Indians. They wanted Indian music, and I had none. They provided much of the music.
 
People will always try to get what's cheapest or free and they don't care about anything else. As stated before it's not a legal issue but also a quality issue. Again you don't know the quality of the music, language or glitches that may be on the file. I don't buy downloads as I always want an original hard copy, however even when ripping CD's to WAV a glitch may pop up so every file is reviewed and it's ripped again if there is such an error so I can trust the quality of my whole library. You guys don't have the time to do this as you are constantly using your files but I would recommend listening to them (The most popular ones) just to make sure everything is in order and your speakers will thank you ;) .
 
With smart phones some people expect EVERYTHING and they want it NOW. I'm already having people want to plug phones into my system.

Yup, I've had guests come up with their phones and just point to a song on their phone and ask "do you have this?"

They don't even bother naming the song...just shove the screen in my face.

Then they see the antennas for the wireless mic and say, "Oh can you just download it?"

I've said it before and I'll say it again...technology is great but it is killing our industry.
 
I sometimes feel like I'm in the minority here, but I see technology as a great thing. People typically no longer have to come up to you and hum a song and a couple lyrics, they can just use their phones and search for the lyrics, then come up and show you the song they want to hear. If you don't have it, you can go buy it off of Amazon and have it playing in minutes if it is appropriate to the mood you are going for.

And just so we are clear since this has come up when I've made this argument in the past, I do not promise anybody anything during the sales process about the ability to download music. I don't mention it on my website. But if I get to the venue and they have a wifi connection, or I can get one using my phone I'm going to do it every single time. I also have never streamed music on the spot, and wouldn't until that technology gets A LOT better, but I have had absolutely no problem with buying a track off of amazon.

I guess what I'm saying is this: We are here. The ability to download music on the spot almost anywhere has arrived. Trying to hold on to the fact that DJ's used to be the only people with large music libraries by telling people that downloading music on the spot isn't safe, or could compromise the performance, is going to be seen very quickly as you not being with the times because the people asking you to do so download music all the time with no problems or glitches. So I guess you can either be bitter about it, or you can adapt and move on. It does take a bullet out of the gun, but I don't think anybody here was selling only their music library as the reason they should be hired to be someone's DJ.
 
I sometimes feel like I'm in the minority here, but I see technology as a great thing. People typically no longer have to come up to you and hum a song and a couple lyrics, they can just use their phones and search for the lyrics, then come up and show you the song they want to hear. If you don't have it, you can go buy it off of Amazon and have it playing in minutes if it is appropriate to the mood you are going for.

And just so we are clear since this has come up when I've made this argument in the past, I do not promise anybody anything during the sales process about the ability to download music. I don't mention it on my website. But if I get to the venue and they have a wifi connection, or I can get one using my phone I'm going to do it every single time. I also have never streamed music on the spot, and wouldn't until that technology gets A LOT better, but I have had absolutely no problem with buying a track off of amazon.

I guess what I'm saying is this: We are here. The ability to download music on the spot almost anywhere has arrived. Trying to hold on to the fact that DJ's used to be the only people with large music libraries by telling people that downloading music on the spot isn't safe, or could compromise the performance, is going to be seen very quickly as you not being with the times because the people asking you to do so download music all the time with no problems or glitches. So I guess you can either be bitter about it, or you can adapt and move on. It does take a bullet out of the gun, but I don't think anybody here was selling only their music library as the reason they should be hired to be someone's DJ.

Just gonna be the devil's advocate for a second. What happens when Amazon's mp3 download is unavailable or the file they have is corrupt? Funny how suddenly at that point technology isn't your friend.
 
Just gonna be the devil's advocate for a second. What happens when Amazon's mp3 download is unavailable or the file they have is corrupt? Funny how suddenly at that point technology isn't your friend.

Technology is always your friend. But like all friends, you have to treat it with respect and not put it on the spot. Grabbing a song from the web by any means during an event is taking a risk. Percentages of failure are likely minute, but still it is a risk. CDs and CD players are technological too and are subject to failure as well.

You can plan ahead all you want, but there will always be the chance that a request could arise for something you don't have. I would much rather have the option of filling that request than not.
 
Just gonna be the devil's advocate for a second. What happens when Amazon's mp3 download is unavailable or the file they have is corrupt? Funny how suddenly at that point technology isn't your friend.

Well, if the file is not available....it's not available. I typically don't even tell people that I'm downloading the song. When somebody requests a song I check my library, if I don't have it, I check amazon. If it's there I let them know I'll get to their request on in a few songs, if it's not there I just let them know I don't have it. Like I said, I don't bring up the ability to download music at any point during the process of selling my services. Even if I felt like bringing it up I'd never say, "I can download any song you want without question."

As far as corrupt files I've downloaded literally 100's of songs from Amazon and have never had a corrupt file. I think that happens much more often on a P2P site than Amazon.
 
I will never stream, nor download on the spot. Every song in my working library, has been listened to in its entirety.

Just because you can do something, does not mean you should do something ;)


If it was a backyard party at my house -- I'd do it for goofs. But not when somebody is paying me good money for a quality performance. They get my show, with what I have available. I'm not big on requests -- although you folks already know that :)
 
I don't even know what Spotify is, yet I'm not at all opposed to using streaming sources to play requests. It is also NOT illegal to play a song from You-Tube, or a smart phone at any private event. If you have access to the song you can play it.

Only broadcasters and commercial establishments have to abide by sourcing committments. Private events are legally beyond the reach of such restrictions.

I get paid to PLAY songs not stockpile them. I am perfectly happy to play a song and not have to own it - especially deep album tracks that I'll never use again. Let the client hand me their iPod, or personal CD. Far be it from me to let my ego get in the way of saving time, money, and storage space.


I think media access wil indeed supercede media collecting. Having a large music collection is of zero value in a world of almost unlimited online access. The age of the "DJ" is already over - America's got talent and this is now the age of the "entertainer." It may seem as though there are more DJs than ever today but, in reality that specific profile and value is diminishing very rapidly. It's not just the economy at work there is also a very big shift in demand and expectation.
 
I don't even know what Spotify is, yet I'm not at all opposed to using streaming sources to play requests. It is also NOT illegal to play a song from You-Tube, or a smart phone at any private event. If you have access to the song you can play it.

Only broadcasters and commercial establishments have to abide by sourcing committments. Private events are legally beyond the reach of such restrictions.

I get paid to PLAY songs not stockpile them. I am perfectly happy to play a song and not have to own it - especially deep album tracks that I'll never use again. Let the client hand me their iPod, or personal CD. Far be it from me to let my ego get in the way of saving time, money, and storage space.


I think media access wil indeed supercede media collecting. Having a large music collection is of zero value in a world of almosty unlimited online access. The age of the "DJ" is already over - America's got talent and this is now the age of the "entertainer." It may seem as though there are more DJs than ever today but, in reality that specific profile and value is diminishing very rapidly. It's not just the economy at work there is also a very big shift in demand and expectation.

Sorry Bob, if you feel the need to stroke your ego and call yourself an entertainer, then by all means do so. Just remember when you boil it down at the end of the day you're still a DJ, doing the job of a DJ which is to play music.