Cap...
I'm going to open my mouth... hope I don't prove that "stupid theory".
From the tone in your voice (yeah, I can here it

), I'll assume that you do have some empathy to the concept of the guild. I'm also guessing that down under neath it all, you think the requirements are beyond the reach of 99.9% of most of us (you included). No problem so far...
I really don't see a problem with some sort of DJ "certification" concept. Isn't that what Johnny is after with his DJ Revolution site? Johnny's site is easier to join, and his requirements are much easier to attain.
The concept isn't new... certification of DJ's has been an issue of discussion for years. I don't see any of them being successful, unless the goals can be met by the majority of members who put forth some extra effort in order to join.
I can tell you that I'm a member of several magician's groups and am able to claim that for my desired purpose, but I don't have to know a single magical illusion. What's up with that?
So really, a "guild" is only a useful tool when certain requirements can be REASONABLY met by people who WANT to put forth the effort to be included in the group. The "guild" doesn't appear to be that sort of an organization. What it really amounts to is a clique of "Country Club" oriented individuals, intended to make the rest of us feel inferior.
So, I'm telling everyone that I believe the requirements for the "guild" are ridiculous. They are practically unattainable by all but a few of the thousands of working DJ's across the globe. $900 bucks for bragging rights... hell, I can claim anything I want (for free), and who would know the difference? That's my problem with the "guild".
I still love ya man... (in a guy sort of way

) pass me a beer.