Are the Big Guns good for the industry?

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Big guns usually kill little people. :sqerr:

I have a really hard time blindly following what someone says I should do. I certainly wouldn't have made it in the military, cult or any highly structured organization.

I/we are "Independent" small business owners, whether we are part-time or full-time and I don't think that anyone can speak for this industry with all it's diversity.

I can however listen to what others have to say and utilize the useful information, suggestions, etc. that will work for me.

In my opinion "Big Guns" (leaders) no matter what the industry usually only care about "their agendas" and making themselves more important and powerful.

Can a Big Gun have a useful message? Yes
Will it always be for me? No

Am I right? Maybe, then again maybe not..
 
But you are saying that you believe the PT DJs who did know about it, and did not attend, stayed home because they don't care to improve. There are more possibilities than two.

Why do you believe that the majority of part time DJs not in attendance do not care to improve? Are you basing it on talking to PT DJs? I'm not trying to be difficult here. You and PM have both made the same claim and I am curious as to what you base it upon.

Kat...I'm not sure I understand your question. I thought I answered it. There are no hard #'s and no phone calls were made to missing djs to confirm but I'm just basing it on common sense. Common sense to me at least.

I think I can broaden the label of not "wanting to improve" a little more and I don't think Mr. Merry would mind. Not to put words in his mouth but when I read that, I think they don't care "enough" to improve. As I gave in my own example, I bought speakers this year. Were they way overdue? Yes. I've had the same speakers for almost a decade...yikes...I know. Did the shows that I performed at since then notice a difference? Hmmm....I'm not sure. What about the knowledge that I would've gained by attending the conference? Would my customers see that? I'm counting on it. Even if it was just a new found excitement of getting rejuvenated for the biz again.

I can accept that there are three possiblities why dj's didn't attend the show.

1. They didn't know about it
2. They didn't care enough to want to improve, save up for it, plan ahead so they could get days off, etc.
3. They really, really couldn't afford it. Family emergency month before the show. Dog need surgery, who knows. I think this would be a huge minority.

The "didn't care" catagory encompasses many possibilities itself. There's something that is said in sales when dealing with a potential customer that is not wanting to open their wallet. Are they unwilling or unable? I'm guessing in most cases with the djs that know about it, they are unwilling. Unwilling to make it a priority.
 
I can accept that there are three possiblities why dj's didn't attend the show.

1. They didn't know about it
2. They didn't care enough to want to improve, save up for it, plan ahead so they could get days off, etc.
3. They really, really couldn't afford it. Family emergency month before the show. Dog need surgery, who knows. I think this would be a huge minority.

The "didn't care" catagory encompasses many possibilities itself.

Would you accept the possibility that the show just isn't that good? Or lots of people see no value in it? Or people have found other ways of improving themselves?

The claim that the majority of PT DJs just don't care to improve is an awfully broad claim and belittles a whole lot of good professional DJs. Shouldn't a more sound basis for such a claim be established before making such a statement?

BTW, I am a fulltime DJ, and don't necessarily have a dog in the fight here, but I do know a whole lot of PT DJs who DO care. In fact, I only know of two or three who do not care to improve.
 
Would you accept the possibility that the show just isn't that good? Or lots of people see no value in it? Or people have found other ways of improving themselves?

The claim that the majority of PT DJs just don't care to improve is an awfully broad claim and belittles a whole lot of good professional DJs. Shouldn't a more sound basis for such a claim be established before making such a statement?

BTW, I am a fulltime DJ, and don't necessarily have a dog in the fight here, but I do know a whole lot of PT DJs who DO care. In fact, I only know of two or three who do not care to improve.


What about taking the show out of the whole equation? For those that have been every year and have seen the same seminars more then once (I'll buy that but there is always new equipment right?) what about looking at the conference as a gathering place to meet/ greet/network with other djs/owners? If someone cannot see the value in that then I honestly think they DON'T care. Or are just too ignorant to see the value in even THAT little slice of the event. And if that's the case, it's like talking to a brick wall.

What about all of the djs that do care about improving themselves or their biz? What percentage of them stayed home? Would you agree that any of them that did stay home just didn't care enough to make it a priority?
 
Exactly...It means I don't care enough to make it a priority. I for one am the first one to stand up and say that I am part of the problem. I am not exempt. How much was the show? If you paid for it early it was what....$100? I don't know how much the hotel was or avg airfare from Seattle so maybe someone could help me out but for me at least...everything else came first. I probably would've been better off not buying my new speakers and going to the show instead. The financial payback would've been much greater.

Ok now we are getting somewhere! I don't see it the same way you do.

What was the return for you on the speakers you purchased?

What would be the return on the investment of attending the convention other than a partial write off on your taxes?

Why do you see your inattendance as part of the problem? Did you make money during the week of the convention?

I go through this every year. So pissed that I missed it and it totally depresses me when I read on the boards about guys meeting up for dinner, drinks, etc. Even if for nothing else...let's say you don't attend one seminar and you hate PM's guts...what about the shot in the arm you get with hobnobbing with other djs while there? That's the stuff that gets me totally stoaked. Knowing that there are other guys in the same position that I'm in. Other guys that are struggling and wanting to get their biz at a different level. That would be worth the price of the show alone.

So you meet up with a bunch of guys you talk with on-line 99% of them from outside your market area and you hobnob. What did you really gain other than blowing off some steam and having a good time? (I certainly don't have a thing against having a good time and if I attend that is the only reason I will have for doing so).

According to PM's figures there are 175,000 people in the same situation you are in. I think you will find that the vast majority of DJs have their business at exactly the level they want it to be at and are comfortable with it being where it is at (I know I am one of them).

For me to attend will mean basically shutting my business down for the better part of a week. To do that would be suicide from a business standpoint. I would not only lose the money from those shows but potentially many of those shows. Now include the shows that I may lose because of not being there when that potential client was looking.

Take into account that unlike the Peter Merry's and other "Big Guns" my business is 100% referals, I do no advertising other than word of mouth. I don't list myself in 50 phone books, I don't buy paper or shine ads, my business comes from people who actually see me. And personaslly I don't think my being in Vegas with a bunch of other DJs is going to bring in a lot of referals.

If you honestly think that attending a convention is going to increase your business then by all means do so, personally I feel like attending Dolly world will increase it about the same amount. If I were going to vactation and I had the choice between Dolly world and Vegas or AC I would choose the later two. But when I can take a vacation I choose to make use it to attend family reunions and things of that nature.
 
What about all of the djs that do care about improving themselves or their biz? What percentage of them stayed home? Would you agree that any of them that did stay home just didn't care enough to make it a priority?

No question it wasn't a priority. But not caring enough to make it a priority and not caring to improve themselves is two different things. I agree with you 100% that they didn't make it a priority. Where we split is when you say the majority didn't attend because they do not care about improving themselves. That argument is premised on the fact that the MB show is the only way of improving, and I just can't get on board with that. If that were true, MB would have no problem marketing the show effectively.
 
Ok now we are getting somewhere! I don't see it the same way you do.

What was the return for you on the speakers you purchased?

What would be the return on the investment of attending the convention other than a partial write off on your taxes?

Why do you see your inattendance as part of the problem? Did you make money during the week of the convention?



So you meet up with a bunch of guys you talk with on-line 99% of them from outside your market area and you hobnob. What did you really gain other than blowing off some steam and having a good time? (I certainly don't have a thing against having a good time and if I attend that is the only reason I will have for doing so).

According to PM's figures there are 175,000 people in the same situation you are in. I think you will find that the vast majority of DJs have their business at exactly the level they want it to be at and are comfortable with it being where it is at (I know I am one of them).

For me to attend will mean basically shutting my business down for the better part of a week. To do that would be suicide from a business standpoint. I would not only lose the money from those shows but potentially many of those shows. Now include the shows that I may lose because of not being there when that potential client was looking.

Take into account that unlike the Peter Merry's and other "Big Guns" my business is 100% referals, I do no advertising other than word of mouth. I don't list myself in 50 phone books, I don't buy paper or shine ads, my business comes from people who actually see me. And personaslly I don't think my being in Vegas with a bunch of other DJs is going to bring in a lot of referals.

If you honestly think that attending a convention is going to increase your business then by all means do so, personally I feel like attending Dolly world will increase it about the same amount. If I were going to vactation and I had the choice between Dolly world and Vegas or AC I would choose the later two. But when I can take a vacation I choose to make use it to attend family reunions and things of that nature.

Steve, great post. I totally understand where you're coming from and you made me think of something brand new! Yee haw!

Maybe we're confusing terms here. You say most of the djs are comfortable with where there business is at. I think the problem with this whole argument is the terminology. When PM says that those djs "don't care" it comes off as a negative thing but in essence...isn't that what you're saying? Isn't another term for liking their business at the level it is...being comfortable with it ALSO means they don't care about growing it any more? Maybe you work 30 weekends of the year and you don't care about growing it to 40? Then there is also caring about the type of service you offer. Not to get into the whole love song, intro stuff but even if you want to stay at 30 weekends per year don't you think there might be some tidbit...however small...that you could glean from one of the seminars?

As far as equipment/seminar....yes, I'm saying that the return on the seminar would be greater then the return on new speakers.

As far as you being gone, that can be covered in so many ways. Again...I see things differently. So you lose money from the shows that you don't book that week for being gone but you gain things from the seminar that will improve your biz in the long run which means you can charge more $$? Have an answering service answer your calls while you're gone. Can't you check in on msgs a few times a day and return calls?

Maybe part of the prob is we're at two different ends of the spectrum when it comes to experience. I feel pretty good about having 12 yrs into it but I'm sure you have many more. I feel like I have so much to learn and I haven't even been to one confererence...ever. I'm sure I might feel differently if I had attended a few.

Everyone goes through experiences in different ways. Even through my "regular" jobs whenever there was a conference, seminar, etc I always loved them because even though the subject matter in the actual conference might have been a total snooze fest, just hobnobbing with other people helped me immensly. Drinking and dancing with other djs is great but I'm sure there are many conversations where you guys compare different ways you do things...or a certain song that you don't know about that you can add to your show...things like that right? I love that stuff and that's the point I was making. Even if I didn't go to one seminar, I would return from the trip with so much enthusiasm and excitement just from talking with other djs.
 
No question it wasn't a priority. But not caring enough to make it a priority and not caring to improve themselves is two different things. I agree with you 100% that they didn't make it a priority. Where we split is when you say the majority didn't attend because they do not care about improving themselves. That argument is premised on the fact that the MB show is the only way of improving, and I just can't get on board with that. If that were true, MB would have no problem marketing the show effectively.

I don't think that Mobile Beat or anyone that has anything to do with the show is saying it's the ONLY way to improve your biz. It's one of several tools that we have to improve ourselves in whatever way we want. What I think PM is saying - and I have to agree - is that it is THE main dj seminar that is out there (it IS the main one, right?) and to not make it a priority in attending can reflect the level of seriousness and committment you have to your biz. So you don't go to MB camp or the cruise or whatever else there is. The Vegas show is the big one! Is it that hard for djs to see the importance in attending at least that one? A major tool - not the only one - in improving your business?

Again, I don't think the whole "seen the seminars" is a valid excuse to not attend. I think someone that thinks they cannot gain anything from the show...let's say they attended every seminar, seen all the speakers, etc...is STILL being shortsighted in thinking there is nothing they can gain from being there. See comments I wrote to Steve about hobnobbing....lol
 
I don't think that Mobile Beat or anyone that has anything to do with the show is saying it's the ONLY way to improve your biz. It's one of several tools that we have to improve ourselves in whatever way we want. What I think PM is saying - and I have to agree - is that it is THE main dj seminar that is out there (it IS the main one, right?) and to not make it a priority in attending can reflect the level of seriousness and committment you have to your biz. So you don't go to MB camp or the cruise or whatever else there is. The Vegas show is the big one! Is it that hard for djs to see the importance in attending at least that one? A major tool - not the only one - in improving your business?

Again, I don't think the whole "seen the seminars" is a valid excuse to not attend. I think someone that thinks they cannot gain anything from the show...let's say they attended every seminar, seen all the speakers, etc...is STILL being shortsighted in thinking there is nothing they can gain from being there. See comments I wrote to Steve about hobnobbing....lol

I ain't lettin' Steve Miller hobnob me OR softsoap me. That ain't happenin'. :sqlaugh:

It's a simple logic exercise and here's where it fails.

If A then B.

A= not attending Mobile Beat
B= doesn't care about improving

When there are countless reasons for A, and we've discussed many of them, then B does not logically follow. You would have to stipulate that A is the ONLY method of improving if B is to follow logically. It may be that there are some who do not care about improvement, but I see no logical, (or otherwise) basis for making the claim that has been made. It just doesn't wash. It is merely an opinion that cannot be supported, or certainly has not been supported as of yet. The problem is that PM has stated it in various places as fact. It just aint so.
 
I ain't lettin' Steve Miller hobnob me OR softsoap me. That ain't happenin'. :sqlaugh:

It's a simple logic exercise and here's where it fails.

If A then B.

A= not attending Mobile Beat
B= doesn't care about improving

When there are countless reasons for A, and we've discussed many of them, then B does not logically follow. You would have to stipulate that A is the ONLY method of improving if B is to follow logically. It may be that there are some who do not care about improvement, but I see no logical, (or otherwise) basis for making the claim that has been made. It just doesn't wash. It is merely an opinion that cannot be supported, or certainly has not been supported as of yet. The problem is that PM has stated it in various places as fact. It just aint so.

Ok Mr. Smarty pants mathemetical genius Bill Nye the science guy....what if - going back to one of my previous posts - we add the word "enough" to the equation since that's the way I've felt all along?

The average dj doesn't care "enough" about improving to go to the show. Sure, they care some but they care more about improving in other areas such as....saving their money so they can renew their subscription to the ADJA (don't laugh) or magazine sub or whatever...what I think he's saying in a roundabout way is that more djs should put the priority on the show.

Are we done yet? I'm getting tired....:sqlaugh:
 
It strikes me as odd the number of people that pass judgement on certain individuals or the philosophy they're trying to espouse before even reading their materials! How on earth can a correct and informed judgement be made before doing so? If you read it, attend the workshops and still don't agree with the "movement" then more power to you but to come to that conclusion before doing so smacks of pure ignorance to me. I just don't get it.

strange you should mention this Ive always found it funny how certian individuals can pass judgement on many based on nothing else than what they charge and what else they do. They know nothing about the average (and I dont mean average in terms of talent) DJ or the average DJs market. They know nothing of the average DJs business model

But they dont hesitate to pass judgement. Is that not ignorance also?

The other night I heard Peter on Mobile Beat radio (yeah, I didn't know it existed either! :sqlaugh: ) and I was surprised that many things that I heard talked about on the boards about his book, the guild, simply weren't true at all. So...if that's the case, don't you think that the criteria that you are using to pass judgement on his beliefs (and not by reading the materials themselves) might also be flawed?


Gawd if Peter said it wasnt true it couldnt possiably be :sqconfused: :sqrolleyes:
 
To say that a dj doesnt care because they didnt go to Vegas. Heellllooooo there are other dj conventions, why does it have to be Vegas. Like I said before its the same old thing.

Try this for a change, what if they had someone come in and speak about djing on a budget or djs for those on a budget. Or how to get a great wedding reception with a limited budget. You most likely wont see these kind of seminars care to take a guess why. Why do you think Vegas gets so much play, think about it. Someone always seems to have a dvd, or book to peddle. I went to the MAPDJ convention in 2004 in Minneapolis. Yes I did get some out of the speakers, but the best info came from networking with others.

Maybe we should get rid of the speakers and just have vendors and networking.
 
strange you should mention this Ive always found it funny how certian individuals can pass judgement on many based on nothing else than what they charge and what else they do. They know nothing about the average (and I dont mean average in terms of talent) DJ or the average DJs market. They know nothing of the average DJs business model

But they dont hesitate to pass judgement. Is that not ignorance also?




Gawd if Peter said it wasnt true it couldnt possiably be :sqconfused: :sqrolleyes:


One major item that EVERYONE thought was a requirement to be a part of the guild is that you had to be a full time dj. That is not correct. Pretty critical assumption on everyone's part. Peter Merry and his board are setting the ground rules and requirements on being a part of the guild so I will believe him when he says you don't have to be a full time dj to get in.
 
Joe...where did you get this information? All I'm going on is what I heard the man himself say on the dja radio show and if I remember correctly he started dj'ing several years ago. Right around the time I started. 93 or 94 I believe. I also believe he worked for another company, started his own while working, then quit his day job and did it full time. What more does he have to do to say that he was a dj? So what if he doesn't do that anymore if he did for1 10+ years? Does that not count for anything? Regarding beatmixing and equipment knowledge we have 100 other djs telling us how to do that. A monkey can be taught to beatmix.....*sigh*.........


I never said he WASN'T a DJ, I said he isn't one anymore, and his occupation is event planner. He doesn't have anything to prove. I don't care what he does or doen't do, or whether he's successful or not, any more than I care what a building contractor does across the country. HE'S NOT IN MY LINE OF WORK! HE'S NOT A DJ! Which means, in my opinion, he should deal with event planners and leave DJing to DJs. And DJs, if they require a role model, should find a successful DJ to emulate. I truly don't understand the difficulty here. My father, before he retired, was a provisions broker. Why not have him give seminars at DJ conventions? Or a brick layer, or a SETI specialist?

As for the technical side, I agree it's easily taught. I was just making a point regarding the fact that Merry is not known for his actual DJing skills. Value added services are fine, but if you concentrate on them to the point of excluding DJing, than you are now in another line of work, possibly Peter Merry's or some other.


Please, make it stop.......

No hit on you Sir Dawg. It's just that hearing a name that, in my neck of the woods, doesn't exist off-line in the DJ community constantly touted is wearing me out.
 
I never said he WASN'T a DJ, I said he isn't one anymore, and his occupation is event planner. He doesn't have anything to prove. I don't care what he does or doen't do, or whether he's successful or not, any more than I care what a building contractor does across the country. HE'S NOT IN MY LINE OF WORK! HE'S NOT A DJ! Which means, in my opinion, he should deal with event planners and leave DJing to DJs. To repeat, by the way: I truly don't understand the difficulty here. My father, before he retired, was a provisions broker. Why not have him give seminars at DJ conventions? Or a brick layer, or a SETI specialist?

If you actually feel you need a role model ( not YOU Dawg, I mean the general you) than find a successful DJ! As for the technical side, I agree it's easily taught. I was just making a point regarding the fact that Merry is not known for his actual DJing skills. Value added services are fine, but if concentrate on them to the point of excluding DJing, than you are now in another line of work, possibly Peter Merry's or some other.


Please, make it stop.......

No hit on you Sir Dawg. It's just that hearing a name that, in my neck of the woods, doesn't exist off-line in the DJ community constantly touted is wearing me out.


Joe, I understand we're beating a dead horse here but you're just not making any sense. But I still love you...hear me out.

Peter is a dj. Has been a dj. Has been a dj for well over a decade as far as the numbers that I know bear out. Apparantly he is STILL a dj because he mentioned on the Mobile Beat radio show that he just received a booking a few days prior. Oh, I guess he could be lying about that as people will now tell me.

So what part of the equation tells you that he is not a dj? I'm really struggling here man! He has been a dj for over a decade, and just booked a show. ??????? Of course he is not going to be dj'ing as much because of the book but even he hasn't dj'd a show for over a year, I still have no problem with him giving back. What part of djing do you not understand? You say he is only an event planner. Well, last time I checked, someone who brings in equipment, plays music, makes announcements, etc. IS a dj or have we changed the definition of that now?

Saying your dad has just as much right to write a book about dj'ing (even though he was a provisions planner) as Peter does just does not make any sense. Do you realize what you're saying? How does that compare? Let me break it down...

Peter Merry
dj for over a decade
just booked a show so that means he is still a dj.
does not just plan the event.
He plays music, makes announcements so that qualifies him as a dj.

Your dad
provisions planner
has never been a dj or has not recently booked a show. (as far as I know...LOL)

Whether or not he is a dj STILL...that matters little since he has been at it for over a decade. Even if he hasn't performed for a year, why would that not qualify him as an expert? Heck, I have no problem with your father writing a book about um...breaking provisions! :sqembarrassed: Sounds like he did it for a long time? Was he an expert? Probably. Even if he was retired for 5 yrs I'm sure he could still write a great book about it.

I don't think you have to be dj'ing, or laying bricks, or flying an airplane at this VERY MINUTE to be able to say something relevant about the industry.

I don't get you man.....is anyone else not understanding Joe or is it me? It wouldn't be the first time I know! :sqbiggrin:

My head hurts.....
 
Joe, I understand we're beating a dead horse here but you're just not making any sense.

I'll try to bury this horse's carcass......
OK, me bro, part of this is my bad. I get too wordy, and some of what I posted was hyperbole to make a point.


He does do some DJ work, but by his own words, MOST of his time is spent as an event planner. He is no longer PRIMARILY a DJ. Though he is well known for his excellent work as an event planner, he's got no great claim to fame as a DJ, only that he has some experience ( I have more, as do many here)

That being said: I am a Karaoke Host/DJ who provides some value added services. However, I am not, NOR DO I WANT TO BE an event planner. Therefore I do not need to learn how to be one. Therefore Peter Merry has nothing of use for me.

If it makes you feel better, my sister-in-law IS an event planner, and I pointed her at Peter, because I respect his work in THAT field.
 
I'll try to bury this horse's carcass......
OK, me bro, part of this is my bad. I get too wordy, and some of what I posted was hyperbole to make a point.


He does do some DJ work, but by his own words, MOST of his time is spent as an event planner. He is no longer PRIMARILY a DJ. Though he is well known for his excellent work as an event planner, he's got no great claim to fame as a DJ, only that he has some experience ( I have more, as do many here)

That being said: I am a Karaoke Host/DJ who provides some value added services. However, I am not, NOR DO I WANT TO BE an event planner. Therefore I do not need to learn how to be one. Therefore Peter Merry has nothing of use for me.

If it makes you feel better, my sister-in-law IS an event planner, and I pointed her at Peter, because I respect his work in THAT field.

Now I'm good! :sqwink:

I did learn something new though Joe if what you're saying is correct. You're saying that he does plan events without djing at the event itself? I did not know that. Where did you find that out? I'm not doubting you for a minute I'm just curious.

Hell, I bet he can't beatmix Yeah with Get Low! :sqbiggrin:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.