Food for Thought???

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

Mikey V

New DJ
Dec 14, 2006
52
0
I thought of a question we have never asked ourselves, so here goes.

Are DJ's and KJ's worth the same??? Do we all do the same kind of work with shows and weddings etc. Are we equals in the Fields we work in? Do we Respect eachother for the work we do, or appreciate eachothers professions to help support and defend our marketplace in the Electronic Entertainment Industry?? How do we feel about where we are and if we all got here together?? Are we all on the same team, to make things better for all of us??
Just a question I was pondering. Any Thoughts??
MV
 
I have a ton of respect for Karaoke Host, I feel they are in most cases under paid for what they do. As a dj we can beatmix between songs, Karaoke host have alot of dead air to fill.
 
The worth depends on the job to be done. Although almost completely different professions at the higher quality end of each they are most certainly equals.

For those of you who don't know, I'm a Karaoke Host first, DJ a far second. I am the first to admit that my DJ skills do not approach my skills as a host.
 
i don't think DJ's or KJ's are inherently worth more than the other. I think it's all up to the individual. Some KJ's are incredible entertainers while some DJ's simply play music....and visa versa.

The reality is though, that people seem to spend more for entertainment on a wedding than anything else, which is mostly a DJ gig.

Karaoke tends to be mostly a bar business and owners do get offers to undercut alot so they are only willing to pay a certain amount, usually much less than i think he or she is "worth"

It is because of this that i went from being a KJ/DJ to a DJ that does mostly weddings and does some karaoke.
 
I think we need to compare each on the same level.

1. KJ at a bar or club gig, Low end - $50 - $100, Mid Range - $150 - $200, High end $250 - $350.

2. DJ at a bar or club gig, Low end - $50 - $100, Mid Range - $150 - $200, High end $250 - $350.

3. High End Private Party or wedding $1000+ for a DJ/KJ.

4. High End Private Party or wedding $1000+ for a DJ.

No matter how you fold or bend it, it still comes out to about the same amount of money, the difference is going to show in expenditures, however the number of weekly bar gigs is going to be substantually higher for the KJ over the DJ so that difference is going to be smaller versus income level.
 
In general, I think that a DJ is going to have a lot more invested than a KJ. The sound gear does not need to be as good. DJing is about the quality of sound, the mix, beat matching, and keeping the dance floor full. KJing has almost nothing to do with the music. It's all about giving people their three minutes of fame in a place that probably isn't big enough for a dance floor. I think you're comparing apples and oranges. Should they make the same money? No. There is more competition in the KJ ranks so they make less.
 
In general, I think that a DJ is going to have a lot more invested than a KJ. The sound gear does not need to be as good. DJing is about the quality of sound, the mix, beat matching, and keeping the dance floor full. KJing has almost nothing to do with the music. It's all about giving people their three minutes of fame in a place that probably isn't big enough for a dance floor. I think you're comparing apples and oranges. Should they make the same money? No. There is more competition in the KJ ranks so they make less.

? where do you do your Karaoke shows?

Mine are all about the quality of the sound.

But you are right there are those out there that don't invest in decent gear and also put on a lousy show.

But again there are DJ's out there who shouldn't be in the business too.

I am willing to bet per capita there are more DJ's than there are KJs. The goods ones are making money the bads one are finding it hard to get a gig even at $50 a gig and it doesn't make any difference if it is KJ or DJ.

I use the same type of gear for a band as I do for a KJ gig or for a DJ gig.
 
I thought of a question we have never asked ourselves, so here goes.

Are DJ's and KJ's worth the same???

NO


Because of over-saturation.......KJs are worth MUCH less than a DJ (generally speaking).

In our area, there is NO SUCH THING as a "quality KJ" because they have so diluted the market with $50-a-night shows, there is nobody doing Quality.

For example, very few (in our area) use Sound Choice CD+Gs, they are too expensiive for the lowballing KJs who cannot afford to spend $$$ on CD+Gs.
 
? where do you do your Karaoke shows?
Mine are all about the quality of the sound.
I work mostly in little bars with customers ranging in age mostly 30-40.

I think the quality of sound issue is over-rated. Drunk people are not into critical listening and we are there in aid of selling booze.

If you're hiding behind your mixer and calling names every so often, you're a DJ with some karaoke disks. If your out there finding them coasters, explaining microphone technique, and being asked twenty times a night "What song do you think I should sing?" You're a KJ.
 
The reality is though, that people seem to spend more for entertainment on a wedding than anything else, which is mostly a DJ gig.

Gotta give you an "oops" there Scott. Most of the straight DJs I know tell me they get requests for karaoke at all kinds of events. I try not to do straight DJ work if I can avoid it ( no knock, I just prefer Karaoke Hosting), and really no longer have to. I have done many DJ/Karaoke weddings, usually the first half DJ, the second Karaoke. The same for corporate events ( which are receiving my greater focus as of this year)- all for the same money as when I did straight DJing. I've also done weddings where, except for entrance music, it was ALL karaoke.

BTW- I've found I can approach wedding pay with my corporate events, with much less hassle, hence my new focus.....
 
NO


Because of over-saturation.......KJs are worth MUCH less than a DJ (generally speaking).

In our area, there is NO SUCH THING as a "quality KJ" because they have so diluted the market with $50-a-night shows, there is nobody doing Quality.

For example, very few (in our area) use Sound Choice CD+Gs, they are too expensiive for the lowballing KJs who cannot afford to spend $$$ on CD+Gs.

I don't know. The northern part of the Entertainment State probably has some decent Karaoke Hosts around somewhere, likely in the higher end restaurant/bars that can afford them. I know that I no longer do dives. If this sounds snobbish, keep in mind where the money is. Plus I've gotten cranky about little things like people puking on my sandals or smashing my mics, I don't know why......

I wouldn't use SC discs as my quality guage though. People are learning just how over-priced they are compared other quality mfrs., like Zoom...
 
1) The sound gear does not need to be as good. DJing is about the quality of sound, the mix, beat matching, and keeping the dance floor full. 2) KJing has almost nothing to do with the music. 3) It's all about giving people their three minutes of fame in a place that probably isn't big enough for a dance floor. I think you're comparing apples andoranges. 4) Should they make the same money? No. There is more competition in the KJ ranks so they make less.

1) QUALITY Karaoke is as much about sound quality as DJing, with possibly more work and definitely more specialized equipment. Nobody wants to listen to crap. DJs mix original artists' music including vocals. Hosts have to make karaoke music and unprofessional singers sound as good as possible, and that in itself is a special skill. You don't want to clear out the restaurant that me be where your next private event takes place. Sound is CRITICAL.

2) Karaoke is as much about the music as DJing, and with ( generally speaking) a much more knowledgeable clientele. These singers know their artists!

3) Many of my venues have dance floors for the nights they have bands or straight DJs. The floors get plenty of use when I'm working too. People like to dance to music, whatever it's source. The same goes for my private events as well. Karaoke is about music, laughter, the joy of song, and companionship. Apples and oranges? Yes. One superior to the other? No.

4) In my area, there are ten DJs to every Karaoke Host. I guess it's just a matter of geography.

Both are the reason a venue or event is a success or failure. Good ones get it done, and the pay should reflect it. Bad ones......who cares?
 
In general, I think that a DJ is going to have a lot more invested than a KJ. The sound gear does not need to be as good.

Weed, I originally posted this on another thread, but it may be helpful...


Whereas a good karaoke host uses different equipment than a DJ, it's generally not inferior, but superior, for the job at hand.

Mics: A Sennheiser is a terrific mike, BUT, very unforgiving to the amateur. A good host will "step down" to a more forgiving mic, Like a Shure 58, or even 48's for a smaller venue.

Subs: In karaoke, unlike DJing, the mixing priority is on the vocals not the music. Subs, in general, can be very annoying in a karaoke show.

Speakers: Since most DJs are more music oriented than karaoke hosts, they tend to have 2-way instead of 3-way speakers ( a must for good vocals)


Mixers: I don't see a lot of straight DJ equipment with top end vocal mixers. In general DJ equipment just isn't meant for karaoke. Some of the very best DJ equipment can produce some truly lousy karaoke sound.

Power: Do you really want 2000 watts of off-key singing?

Venue Size: Varies as much as a DJ's, but does seem to work better in mid-sized to smaller venues

In other words, what some perceive as lesser quality, may actually be better quality for a different purpose...
 
Joe: I don't disagree at all with your views on equipment. The only place I disagree is on the assumption that anyone is really listening at a karaoke show. They are waiting to sing, drinking, visiting with friends, or waiting for something weird to happen (my favorite). The vocals are usually so bad that people tune them out in self defence. That is why I don't think the sound is of great importance. Even if somebody gets up who can sing, and they select a song that somebody else might be interested in hearing, the song is half way done before anyone notices.
 
The only place I disagree is on the assumption that anyone is really listening at a karaoke show. Even if somebody gets up who can sing, and they select a song that somebody else might be interested in hearing, the song is half way done before anyone notices.


Weed, I guess it's just a matter of different venues. Some of my singers make pros look like pikers. Several have been scouted. I have non-singers who come in just to hear their favorites, and who actually complain about wait time even when their favorites DON'T! I do have a few clinkers, but they seem to bring smiles to the mic. Some are like the bar mascot. I understand what you mean though. I worked a biker bar for yaers that fit your scenario. I work a more sophisticated crowd now, both for the money and more enjoyment. All I'm saying is that for me, what you describe is the exception.
 
Is this how Karaoke is percieved??

After all these years of Karaoke being just a "Bunch of Drunks" in a bar, is that all Karaoke is percieved as? The KJ is not only the host, but sound mixer, cheerleader, and organizer of the entire evening. Without knowing many of the singers who sign up each night, (unless the host has a regular cast of singers every night,) Each night is different and unique in its own way.
The KJ makes or breaks the show. People "Do" go out to enjoy the camaraderie and fun that Karaoke provides. Its not just about selling drinks, its about sustaining a crowd just like a DJ does, and is harder to do than a DJ does. Since each night is very different, the KJ must be more prepared and improvise every night of their shows. Their equipment, sound, books, lighting, and hosting must make each crowd feel comfortable with each singer, good or bad, that comes up to their stage. Their libraries must provide each customer who comes to sing, a selection that they would want to come back for again and again.
In my 18 years of hosting Karaoke and DJ'ing I feel that both work hard at what they do and should respect eachother's work so we all make more at what we do. Lets not look at the low end that we complain about so much in both our industries, but the Best that our businesses have to offer both sides. DJ's and KJ's both give their all and both deserve the highest of respect from eachother....MV:sqbiggrin:
 
Weed, I guess it's just a matter of different venues. Some of my singers make pros look like pikers. Several have been scouted. I have non-singers who come in just to hear their favorites, and who actually complain about wait time even when their favorites DON'T! I do have a few clinkers, but they seem to bring smiles to the mic. Some are like the bar mascot. I understand what you mean though. I worked a biker bar for yaers that fit your scenario. I work a more sophisticated crowd now, both for the money and more enjoyment. All I'm saying is that for me, what you describe is the exception.
If your crowd isn't buying drinks because they are busy enjoying the music so much, how does the bar make money? Must be one heck of a cover charge.

Back in the day before karaoke, I had a gig doing the one-man folkey thing and I got fired. The owner was very nice about it and explained that although I was putting butts in the seats, I wasn't putting cash in the register drawer because people were listening and not drinking. That made a big impression. I would not run karaoke like that.
 
My venue has been doing karaoke for 25 years. It's a small bar in the Japantown section of San Jose called 7 Bamboo. Originally it was japanese karaoke, but in the late 90's they purchased a DKK set.

One thing they do in Japan is they charge for karaoke. at 7 Bamboo they charge $1 per song to sing. Now I know a lot of you are going to flip out on that last statement, but please consider, I work for a very lovely elderly Japanese couple. This is how it's done where they are from and it works very well over here.

Charging accomplishes several things.

1. It makes karaoke a revenue stream vs being a crowd draw. There is a direct correlation between the number of songs sung, and sales at the end of the night. Typically on a full blown night, with global tempo speedup we can fit about 100 people in. Not a huge number compared to total bar sales, but if you consider the product costs them nothing (printing up tickets) the profit margin is really good. Also note, more tickets are sold than are actually turned in each night.

2. It forces those water drinking, no tipping, sit in a corner all night and bitch they aren't up soon enough bastards to actually spend something.

3. It puts a financial penalty on the number of songs a person turns in. This helps meter the amount of songs they turn in.

4. It makes the karaoke stage more a "rental" thing. I.E. a person paid a buck so they could sing a song for 3-4 minutes. Totally changes the customer service dynamics and adds a monetary value to their stage time. Is someone really gonna miss their turn when they've paid a buck? (well, some still do)

Anyone that has never worked at a Japanese style karaoke bar should try it at least once. As a Gaijin (japanese for whitey) i've found the whole system to be much more fair and effecient for the bar/venue than venues run american style.

Open invites if you wanna run my show for a night, I still get my pay and anything in the tipjar, but if tips are good you'll get a free breakfast at Denny's when the nights over :)

--toq
 
If your crowd isn't buying drinks because they are busy enjoying the music so much, how does the bar make money?

I think there's some sort of misunderstanding. I never said they weren't drinking. In fact they're drinking plenty, and I'm talking about $6.50 mixed drinks, not $1.oo draft beers. They're just a more sophisticated crowd, not rowdy, and generally polite. They also order actual meals instead of a plate of wings. That's why I can ask for top dollar in these types of places ( restaurant bars, clientele usually above 35, but many younger who just happen to enjoy the atmosphere. As of a couple of months ago none hold more than 225)

I don't understand what you mean by a one man folksy thing. I may well be one, but could you give a better explanation?

BTW- I'm not knocking yours or anyone's venue. I used to enjoy working a younger party crowd. I just got old and cranky I guess.....
 
BTW- I'm not knocking yours or anyone's venue. I used to enjoy working a younger party crowd. I just got old and cranky I guess.....

Amen!

Older folks make more money, tip better, better mannered, less aggressive, quieter, less destructive and I could go on and on.

Sometimes management cares about them... Sometimes they don't...

I've been hired to take care of the screaming, squeeling, flirtatious, drunken, pissing and vomiting in the alleyway kids that come in thurs/fri/sat nights. We're closed on Sunday, Monday. Tuesday is dead, and Weds is sort of specifically reserved for our older Japanese crowd. On Weds night our KJ is an older Japanese woman. 100% fluent in the language and culture (she was born there). I envy her tipjar and customers, even though my nights are more crowded. Her tipjar in a single night is double mine for 3 nights.