YourBasicDJ,
You might have a problem with patrons thinking that the 'Mystery Song' is rigged when a winner is finally is selected. If the song that is selected by you and the bar is one of your regular's often sang songs, it might appear that this song was selected to make this particular patron win.
(As quoted from the lyrics of Rush - Spirit Of The Radio:
"But glitter and prizes
And then there's compromizes
Shatter the illusion of integrity")
Possible problem two with the Mystery Song, once the pot gets big, some patrons might start singing some of the 'off the wall' songs hoping to hit the jackpot. This can be good and bad, expanding the variety of songs being sung, but can also result in just plain bad, not very popular songs being sung by patrons that shouldn't really be singing the songs in the first place.
Possible problem three, God forbid that a newbie come in and walk away with a big prize, never to be seen again. That goes back to shattering the illusion of integrity. Or, God forbid that someone considered a 'friend' of the bar owner, bar tender, bouncer, bar janitor, or Karaoke Host were to win the prize if it were big!
Possible problem four, the statistical mathmatical probability of getting a winner. With 8,000 songs, the odds are 8,000 to 1. If this were a weekly administered contest, statistically it would take approximately 74 years to come up with a winner. Hitting a winner in a matter of a few weeks or months would appear to be fixed due to the mathmatical improbability and you are back to shattering the illusion of integrity.
Possible problem five. In any contest, there is only one person happy with the result of the contest and that person is the winner. Everyone else that participated and did not win will not be happy to some degree. Some might be so unhappy as to find a new place to sing that had not 'cheated' them. This is a problem, one happy person, many unhappy persons.
Many potential pitfalls, few perceived benefits for the bar owner or show.
Just my thoughts...