IMHO, at least for the wedding audiences in which my specialty lies, oldies are a great ice breaker for multi-genre multi-aged, multi-level of sobriety groups.
The keys lie in the dance beat, not the title or the genre.
While we may work several times a week thus hearing the same tracks over and over, most guests at a wedding, especially the 35+ bracket, are tethered with work and family. Rarely do they get out to "dance" more than twice a year.
Getting a bit deeper into the philosophy of oldies, it is very helpful to have lived and danced to the songs and understand what potential memories of their younger days certain tracks can trigger.
An classic example happened last Tuesday night. (Sea story follows) ;>) !
Allison (my wife) and I had a hankerin for greasy bar food and brewskis. We went to our favorite watering hole and there was about 20 patrons. The digital juke box was playing some of todays trash and the place felt like a mausoleum.
Over to the digital jukebox, shoved a couple of bucks into it and played:
Human Beinz - Nobody But Me
JJ Jackson - It's Alright
Sly & Family Stone - Dance To the Music
Abba - Does Your Mother Know
Dion - Donna Prima Donna
Five songs and the place was was jumpin. Folks boppin in their seats, waitresses giving me money to make more choices, my wife and I dancing by our table, one fella said I oughta be a DJ, and the place was completely energized.
Anybody can push play. It's what specific educated choices are made to put under that play button that separates success from ordinary. Mixing is overrated.
My two cents, anyway.