Molded vs. Carpeted Speakers?

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

mtnsounds

New DJ
Nov 14, 2006
23
0
35
Colorado
mountainsoundsdj.com
Hello all,

I was wondering if anyone has had experience with both carpeted and molded speakers and could give some pros and cons as to both. I currently have birch carpeted speakers, but the fact that I have a cat has just recently posed a problem :sqembarrassed:
Therefore, I'm thinking about buying molded speakers in my next upgrade instead of new carpeted speakers. So, I'm asking before I buy, if you know of any sound differences or construction quality differences between molded and carpet. Pros/cons, like i said before.

Thanks,
Jake
 
Greets, Jake.

Carpet or rat fur is not the only option available. Carvin's TRX line of cabinets is covered with what they call DuraTex™. As I understand it's a tough, rubberized coating. The TRX are birch plywood as well.

Actually, you will get a better tone from the birch plywood cabs. Molded cabinets do not seem to have that warmth. But that's just one old dog's opinion. :)

Don't sacrifice your tone for the sake of your kitty cat.

Hope it helps.
 
Greets, Jake.

Carpet or rat fur is not the only option available. Carvin's TRX line of cabinets is covered with what they call DuraTex™. As I understand it's a tough, rubberized coating. The TRX are birch plywood as well.

Actually, you will get a better tone from the birch plywood cabs. Molded cabinets do not seem to have that warmth. But that's just one old dog's opinion. :)

Don't sacrifice your tone for the sake of your kitty cat.

Hope it helps.

I don't want to lose my tone for the sake of my kitty cat, but I also don't want the speakers to look like crap because a cat has clawed at them and has hair all over them.

Speaking of which, Carvin is a brand I've been considering. I've been looking at the TRX series and the club series; and now that you say that I'll keep my eye on the TRX series. :)
 
The old Club series has been superseded by the LS line. It's upgraded... but still rat fur, LOL.

Carpet bugs the heck out of me as well. You do an outdoor show and grass clippings stick all over the stuff. We have three puppy dogs here and the cabs can get furrified easily if we set 'em up in the house. I once had a tipsy bride with a wad of cake frosting on her hand use one of our cabs to steady herself...

But I digress. I have read some excellent reviews on the TRX. If I were in the market for new cabs, the TRX would be my choice. :)

Hope it helps.
 
Fred has hit it pretty much on the head but I will give you my take anyway.

Wood Boxes.

Most do produce a warmer (smoother) sound (but this depends a lot of the construction of the box and the componets used) Coated boxes done by many different manus such as Carvin, JBL, Peavey and on and on have an advantage over carpet for wear but many times the finish is very rough and holds dust. Carpet if properly cared for can last and look clean for years. The down side to wood boxes is weight and size.

The vast majority of molded cabinets (poly) do have a dry sound, the advantage (at least with the non-powered cabinets) is a lot less weight to deal with and generally a smaller size. Also very easy to clean up with soap and water.

I own many of both, but only made the mistake of buying molded subs once!
 
Wood boxes with <insert the trade name used by the manufacturer> plastic/vinyl etc. coating.

My rat fur daze is ova!

Agree totally with Fred's & Steve's takes on the molded plastic cabinets. The sound is different and not to my liking.

P.S. GET COVERS FOR WHATEVER SPEAKS YOU BUY. You'll definitely appreciate the extended newness and substantially reduced wear on your boxes.

Peace, OUT!
 
A little trick I learned to help renew the look of carpeted speakers....SHAVE 'EM!!! (after a while, the carpet tends to get "furry" from snags, etc.).

Take a pair of hair clippers and shave all the fuzz of. If you put the speaker on a stand, you don't even have to move :sqwink: (just rotate the speaker).
 
Back in the day, Carvin offered slipcovers for their Club and Red Line cabinets. All of our cabs have slipcovers. That said, both lines have been superseded. I don't see covers listed in the catalog for the new lines.

It's true that protective covers are a good investment. They will pay for themselves in no time. The covers absorb the rigors of the road and your cabs will always look like new.
 
My carpet covered birch boxes sound better to my aging ears than my poly boxes, but my aging back appreciates the poly's considerably lighter weight.

After set-up I always go over my carpet covered boxes with a wad of duct tape with the sticky side out so my Basset Hound's hairs (and other debris) are never seen by my clients.
 
One pair of my speakers are carpeted (the ones I use the most these dayz), and every time I load up one of my cats always has to do the stretch on them!

She also has to do the same to one of my CD cases (also carpeted) . . .

However, when I'm not DJing . . . my system is all packed away, covered and sheilded so that none of it can be seen or gotten to by the cats!

Or anyone else, for that matter . . .
 
Usually mine is as well, but this was a late night event and I got home around 1:00 and I wanted to go to sleep. Call me lazy, a bad dj, whatever, but I had had a full day before the event too and I was tired. So I figured that it'd be fine to have it out for a night. Boy was I wrong :(
 
I have a ton of carvin speakers, including the club series, TRX series and i just ordered 2 ls series speakers. All of the ones i have including the molded plastic PM15a have a real nice warm sound to them. I do recommend that you buy covers for any carpet covered speakers. It will keep them nice for years.