I've been reading this thread closely and haven't poked in too much (for fear of stoking the fire more).
I think this is an important & valid discussion that does affect anyone who does public performances of pre-recorded music, with or without graphics. Gray areas do exist in the interpretation of copyright laws, whether out of self-interest, ignorance or legalese language.
I looked at a summary of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998 (DMCA) available from the U.S. Government Copyright office (http://www.copyright.gov/legislation/dmca.pdf, p. 14), essentially an amendment to the copyright laws written & amended over the course of the last 100+ years. This is a summary of a provision regarding "ephemeral recordings;" essentially, the act of digital shifting:
"Ephemeral Recordings for Broadcasters
Section 112 of the Copyright Act grants an exemption for the making of “ephemeral recordings.” These are recordings made in order to facilitate a transmission. Under this exemption, for example, a radio station can record a set of songs and broadcast from the new recording rather than from the original CDs (which would have to be changed “on the fly” during the course of a broadcast).
As it existed prior to enactment of the DMCA, section 112 permitted a transmitting organization to make and retain for up to six months (hence the term “ephemeral”) no more than one copy of a work if it was entitled to transmit a public performance or display of the work, either under a license or by virtue of the fact that there is no general public performance right in sound recordings (as distinguished from musical works).
The Digital Performance Right in Sound Recordings Act of 1995 (DPRA) created, for the first time in U.S. copyright law, a limited public performance right in sound recordings. The right only covers public performances by means of digital transmission and is subject to an exemption for digital broadcasts (i.e., transmissions by FCC licensed terrestrial broadcast stations) and a statutory license for certain subscription transmissions that are not made on demand (i.e. in response to the specific request of a recipient).
Section 402 of the DMCA expands the section 112 exemption to include recordings that are made to facilitate the digital transmission of a sound recording where the transmission is made under the DPRA’s exemption for digital broadcasts or statutory license. As amended, section 112 also permits in some circumstances the circumvention of access control technologies in order to enable an organization to make an ephemeral recording."
This muddies the water a bit more. Does the "public performances by means of digital transmission" include shifting that recording (for which, in essence, we have a limited license because we've purchased the CD/CDG/song to a different format (MP3/MP3+G)?
I think this is an important & valid discussion that does affect anyone who does public performances of pre-recorded music, with or without graphics. Gray areas do exist in the interpretation of copyright laws, whether out of self-interest, ignorance or legalese language.
I looked at a summary of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998 (DMCA) available from the U.S. Government Copyright office (http://www.copyright.gov/legislation/dmca.pdf, p. 14), essentially an amendment to the copyright laws written & amended over the course of the last 100+ years. This is a summary of a provision regarding "ephemeral recordings;" essentially, the act of digital shifting:
"Ephemeral Recordings for Broadcasters
Section 112 of the Copyright Act grants an exemption for the making of “ephemeral recordings.” These are recordings made in order to facilitate a transmission. Under this exemption, for example, a radio station can record a set of songs and broadcast from the new recording rather than from the original CDs (which would have to be changed “on the fly” during the course of a broadcast).
As it existed prior to enactment of the DMCA, section 112 permitted a transmitting organization to make and retain for up to six months (hence the term “ephemeral”) no more than one copy of a work if it was entitled to transmit a public performance or display of the work, either under a license or by virtue of the fact that there is no general public performance right in sound recordings (as distinguished from musical works).
The Digital Performance Right in Sound Recordings Act of 1995 (DPRA) created, for the first time in U.S. copyright law, a limited public performance right in sound recordings. The right only covers public performances by means of digital transmission and is subject to an exemption for digital broadcasts (i.e., transmissions by FCC licensed terrestrial broadcast stations) and a statutory license for certain subscription transmissions that are not made on demand (i.e. in response to the specific request of a recipient).
Section 402 of the DMCA expands the section 112 exemption to include recordings that are made to facilitate the digital transmission of a sound recording where the transmission is made under the DPRA’s exemption for digital broadcasts or statutory license. As amended, section 112 also permits in some circumstances the circumvention of access control technologies in order to enable an organization to make an ephemeral recording."
This muddies the water a bit more. Does the "public performances by means of digital transmission" include shifting that recording (for which, in essence, we have a limited license because we've purchased the CD/CDG/song to a different format (MP3/MP3+G)?