Piracy issues and computer KJs

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
I've been reading this thread closely and haven't poked in too much (for fear of stoking the fire more).

I think this is an important & valid discussion that does affect anyone who does public performances of pre-recorded music, with or without graphics. Gray areas do exist in the interpretation of copyright laws, whether out of self-interest, ignorance or legalese language.

I looked at a summary of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998 (DMCA) available from the U.S. Government Copyright office (http://www.copyright.gov/legislation/dmca.pdf, p. 14), essentially an amendment to the copyright laws written & amended over the course of the last 100+ years. This is a summary of a provision regarding "ephemeral recordings;" essentially, the act of digital shifting:

"Ephemeral Recordings for Broadcasters

Section 112 of the Copyright Act grants an exemption for the making of “ephemeral recordings.” These are recordings made in order to facilitate a transmission. Under this exemption, for example, a radio station can record a set of songs and broadcast from the new recording rather than from the original CDs (which would have to be changed “on the fly” during the course of a broadcast).

As it existed prior to enactment of the DMCA, section 112 permitted a transmitting organization to make and retain for up to six months (hence the term “ephemeral”) no more than one copy of a work if it was entitled to transmit a public performance or display of the work, either under a license or by virtue of the fact that there is no general public performance right in sound recordings (as distinguished from musical works).

The Digital Performance Right in Sound Recordings Act of 1995 (DPRA) created, for the first time in U.S. copyright law, a limited public performance right in sound recordings. The right only covers public performances by means of digital transmission and is subject to an exemption for digital broadcasts (i.e., transmissions by FCC licensed terrestrial broadcast stations) and a statutory license for certain subscription transmissions that are not made on demand (i.e. in response to the specific request of a recipient).

Section 402 of the DMCA expands the section 112 exemption to include recordings that are made to facilitate the digital transmission of a sound recording where the transmission is made under the DPRA’s exemption for digital broadcasts or statutory license. As amended, section 112 also permits in some circumstances the circumvention of access control technologies in order to enable an organization to make an ephemeral recording."

This muddies the water a bit more. Does the "public performances by means of digital transmission" include shifting that recording (for which, in essence, we have a limited license because we've purchased the CD/CDG/song to a different format (MP3/MP3+G)?
 
Heh and I broadcast :)

Thanks for that kayleigh.

Steve and weed, sorry if I come off brash, but you guys really need to change your tune.

Do you think our forfathers thought they were criminals because they refused the english tax? That mindset you guys have is going to be our sides downfall. You both use a PC for karaoke, but in the same breath just roll over and say "Yah the karaoke companies are right, we're committing a crime."

It's like you've been beaten so many times you're accepting the FACT that they call our type of use criminal when it's not. I sincerely hope you guys get the point i'm trying to change you over to.
 
I posted this to ask the question, "Is the act of hosting/performing broadcasting, and, therefore, exempt?" The DMCA removes the limitation that *only* those with an FCC license are exempt; it now widens the definition and no longer puts a finite time limit on "ephemeral." Do we, indeed, "brodcast?" Maybe I'll look at the DPRA rules/amendment ad see what it says, since it's specifically mentioned in the Act.
 
OK - quick search of THOMAS (the Library of Congress search engine) revealed this (I edited this so that you don't have to muddle through anything that doesn't apply)...

"(d) LIMITATIONS ON EXCLUSIVE RIGHT- Notwithstanding the provisions of section 106(6)--
    • `(1) EXEMPT TRANSMISSIONS AND RETRANSMISSIONS- The performance of a sound recording publicly by means of a digital audio transmission, other than as a part of an interactive service, is not an infringement of section 106(6) if the performance is part of--
      • `(A)(i) a nonsubscription transmission other than a retransmission;
      • `(ii) an initial nonsubscription retransmission made for direct reception by members of the public of a prior or simultaneous incidental transmission that is not made for direct reception by members of the public; or
      • `(iii) a nonsubscription broadcast transmission;
      • `(B) a retransmission of a nonsubscription broadcast transmission: Provided, That, in the case of a retransmission of a radio station's broadcast transmission--"
KAYLEIGH: edited... information regarding radio station transmissions...
      • `(C) a transmission that comes within any of the following categories--
        • `(i) a prior or simultaneous transmission incidental to an exempt transmission, such as a feed received by and then retransmitted by an exempt transmitter: Provided, That such incidental transmissions do not include any subscription transmission directly for reception by members of the public;
        • `(ii) a transmission within a business establishment, confined to its premises or the immediately surrounding vicinity;
        • `(iii) a retransmission by any retransmitter, including a multichannel video programming distributor as defined in section 602(12) of the Communications Act of 1934 (47 U.S.C. 522(12)), of a transmission by a transmitter licensed to publicly perform the sound recording as a part of that transmission, if the retransmission is simultaneous with the licensed transmission and authorized by the transmitter; or
        • `(iv) a transmission to a business establishment for use in the ordinary course of its business: Provided, That the business recipient does not retransmit the transmission outside of its premises or the immediately surrounding vicinity, and that the transmission does not exceed the sound recording performance complement. Nothing in this clause shall limit the scope of the exemption in clause (ii)."
This doesn't address the direct issue being addressed here (the legal right to use format shifting); I added it because it's mentioned in the DMCA.

Source: http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c104:S.227.ENR: Sec. 3
 
Oh I agree with you Joe,

I simply present what the copyright laws state. Ascap BMI Secac really control the public performance end of it.

But the copyright laws specifically state that no copy can be made and used in a commercial venture without the expressed permission of the copyright holder. Doesn't say you can't play it in public it says you can't make a copy to be played in public. .

Well, that's kind of what else confuses me ( BTW- My back-ups are home-My Quicdisc makes copies as masters -scan and copysafe, my labeled discs come to the show)

1) I don't believe the music is being used in a "commercial venture", for reasons described in my last post ( I'm speaking of karaoke only now)


Also, since I'm disc based, and buy my discs legally, I have have any damaged originals AND the case art, as well as receipts. Though I do have some backups in my case ( marked that way) and can prove purchase of the original.

Steve, I don't doubt your knowledge of this written law. I just haven't seen it tested.

I believe - no, I KNOW- that how laws are written and how they are enforced in court are two very different things. So far, I've seen nothing on record that'll give me the shivers.....
 
Kay,

Even with all that said... the doubting Thomas's will still say your wrong... But as I interprit it we as KJ/DJ are broadcasters and as long as the licensing is paid by the venue or ourselves if necessary then we are not pirates as SC and Stlr would have us believe.... This also further cements my belief and understanding that 1:1 KJ's are doing nothing wrong and are abiding by the letter of the law.
 
1)I don't believe the music is being used in a "commercial venture", for reasons described in my last post ( I'm speaking of karaoke only now)
To be fair, if we're (trying) to earn money, we are using the music (CDG, MP3+G) we've purchased to be used commercially.
Also, since I'm disc based, and buy my discs legally, I have have any damaged originals AND the case art, as well as receipts. Though I do have some backups in my case (marked that way) and can prove purchase of the original.
Do you have the ability to replace the damaged originals? SC and CB will replace any damaged originals still available for a nominal fee. The nominal fee is worth it to me (to CYA).

It may seem like I'm talking out of both sides of my a**. I have originals I can't replace (SC & SM have lots of disks I own; they've been pulled/deleted), but if you can replace the original, you can at least show good faith for using a copy for your shows.

I have friends who contacted me about a damaged disk they have that won't play in their machine (a bubble in the originally produced CDG). I know they own the original. (It's a disk that's only available as a 50+ disk set.) They were told to return the whole set and a new set would be issued or refunded. They can't afford that for their business (1,000 new songs in their karaoke catalog); they need all those disks now. I made a copy of that disk and they can use now and prove they have that original. I told them to keep the original CDG in their traveling disk book for proof-of-purchase.
 
Even with all that said... the doubting Thomas' will still say your wrong... But as I interpret it we as KJ/DJ are broadcasters and as long as the licensing is paid by the venue or ourselves if necessary then we are not pirates as SC and Stlr would have us believe.... This also further cements my belief and understanding that 1:1 KJ's are doing nothing wrong and are abiding by the letter of the law.
I agree with you. Toqer (I'll be bold to say; Toq, please tell me if I'm wrong) agrees with you. We host as 1:1 KJs/Karaoke Hosts. We've bought what we play; we have paid for a limited 1:1 license for what we offer our clients. I think, under the expanded rules, we broadcast "a transmission within a business establishment, confined to its premises or the immediately surrounding vicinity." Under U.S. copyright laws as amended under the DMCA, I think we have legal standing.

The venue, if they have a leased jukebox (most lease; check with your venue...), they pay the mechanical rights to ASCAP/BMI/SECAP with their lease.
 
I agree with you. Toqer (I'll be bold to say; Toq, please tell me if I'm wrong) agrees with you. We host as 1:1 KJs/Karaoke Hosts. We've bought what we play; we have paid for a limited 1:1 license for what we offer our clients. I think, under the expanded rules, we broadcast "a transmission within a business establishment, confined to its premises or the immediately surrounding vicinity." Under U.S. copyright laws as amended under the DMCA, I think we have legal standing.

The venue, if they have a leased jukebox (most lease; check with your venue...), they pay the mechanical rights to ASCAP/BMI/SECAP with their lease.

Your right toqer would agree with me I'm sure of that.

Another thing to consider is that the jukeboxes in most places these days are digital ones and download the songs as requested none are stored on the device itself. There are still the older style jukeboxes in some cases they lease them and in affect pay the licenses... some also purchase music specifically made for use in jukeboxes thru subscriptions... in the end someone has to pay a license to broadcast that music in the bar.
 
I think first things first, you need to understand what the term transmission actually is.

Second commercial venture Kay you have that correct if you are being paid it is a commercial venture.

Now look up interactive service and see what that terms means.

(1) EXEMPT TRANSMISSIONS AND RETRANSMISSIONS- The performance of a sound recording publicly by means of a digital audio transmission, other than as a part of an interactive service, is not an infringement of section 106(6) if the performance is part of--
 
Interactive Service... WHAAA??

A lot of the DPRA (1995) and DMCA (1998) deal primarily with webcasting and Internet delivery/transmission, and not as much with the "transmission" of pre-recorded music in a business place (aside from the question of digital jukeboxes, but I'll touch on that a bit).

I dug up info regarding the distribution of money between the RIAA and the Harry Fox Agency (who distributes a huge majority of these mechanical rights payments) and lots of government legalese regarding this whole issue that I don't wanna bore everyone with. I did dig up some background info I can add to this thread since the question of defining an "interactive service" was raised. I found a Federal Register entry (http://www.copyright.gov/fedreg/2000/65fr33266.html) from June, 2000 that basically asks the U.S. Copyright Office to clarify the definition of a "Service:"

"SUMMARY: The Copyright Office is requesting comments on whether to grant a petition for rulemaking filed with the Copyright Office by the Digital Media Association. The petition requests an amendment to the rule that defines the term "Service" for purposes of the statutory license governing the public performance of sound recordings by means of digital audio transmissions. The requested amendment would expand the current definition of the term "Service" to state that a service is not interactive simply because it offers the consumer some degree of influence over the programming offered by the webcaster."

The background about the importance of interactive vs. non-interactive services is this:

"This distinction between interactive and non-interactive has always been critical to determining the rights of a copyright user under section 114, since Congress believed 'interactive services [were] most likely to have a significant impact on traditional record sales, and therefore pose[d] the greatest threat to the livelihoods of those whose income depends upon revenues derived from traditional record sales.' S. Rep. No. 104-128, at 16 (1995). For this reason, interactive services are excluded from the limitations placed upon the new performance right and, consequently, must conduct arms-length negotiations with the copyright owners of the sound recordings before making a digital transmission of the works."

Digital jukeboxes are a prime example of an interactive, on-demand service. Part of their expense is due to the negotiation of performance licensing rights for not just the labels or publishers but for every songwriter and performer of every song available on that jukebox. Youch.

I guess after trying to filter through all the stuff I've read, I don't know how a digital-based DJ/KJ fits into this, either as an "agent" initiating and delivering ("transmitting") music, or as a provider of an "interactive service" by accepting requests to play certain songs or providing karaoke songs to sing on request.
 
First we don't fit because we do not transmit or broadcast.

However even if we did, then the fact is we would be considered interactive and would not qualify under the rules for exemption.
 
Broadcast or transmit are very broad terms... and can mean anything from transmiting or boradcasting over, wire, radio waves, internet, telephone, or transmitting through speakers. Yes that is considered a method of transmitting/broadcasting because you are casting to a broad environment (ie the venue).

A jukebox could be considered interactive since it requires you to insert coins and select a song. And the dancing that ensues after the song starts could be further construed as interactive..... hmmm not a strong arguement I know but it is something to consider, isn't it?

Kay has made some very valid points that some here seem to be blowing off as not applying.... I think some of us need to re-read.
 
Broadcast or transmit are very broad terms... and can mean anything from transmiting or boradcasting over, wire, radio waves, internet, telephone, or transmitting through speakers. Yes that is considered a method of transmitting/broadcasting because you are casting to a broad environment (ie the venue).

Actually the copyright law narrowly defines both Broadcast and Transmit.

A jukebox could be considered interactive since it requires you to insert coins and select a song. And the dancing that ensues after the song starts could be further construed as interactive..... hmmm not a strong arguement I know but it is something to consider, isn't it?

Yes if you read what Kay posted it does define jukebox as interactive and it requires special licensing.

Kay has made some very valid points that some here seem to be blowing off as not applying.... I think some of us need to re-read.

Yes she did post some valid points, just none that really concern our business.
 
What's bothering me about the whole karaoke fair use argument is you exweedfarmer. You should know the difference between backups and piracy, but you don't.

I don't know if you're on our side or not. Maybe you're just (insert the kindest word you can for someone who doesn't know facts or chooses to ignore them) I got no idea, but your posts these last few weeks has really lost any and all respect I might have had for you.

I have lost your respect????!!!!! Oh shame and disaster. How will I ever go on?

To clarify, I'm on my side. I'm on the "I don't want to go to jail over Karaoke" side. The statute is quite specific and was written back in the days of LPs and is still on the books. No back-ups. The whole 1992 decision of "fair use" simply cannot be made to apply here. If you make a copy in order to archive, to reporduce, or in any way extend the life of the original license which is for the life of the original media, you are breaking the law and your intent is to break the law and will be subject to the full weight of the law. However, if your intention is to play the disk, and your player does its work by cacheing the information for the purpose of sorting and random access in a timely manor, my non-expert opinion would be that it is legal. The long and the short of it, if your computer is a backup device you're a thief, but if your computer is a player you're a law abiding KJ. So, what are you going to call your computer?
 
So essentially it's not so much the copying or changing media that 'breaks the law,' it really just comes down to extending the life of the media. They're counting on the discs wearing out, forcing you to buy them again?
 
Actually the copyright law narrowly defines both Broadcast and Transmit.
That is true; neither the DPRA or DCMA broaden the definition of either; in fact, I think the full texts reinforce the definitions from the original Copyright laws. I've quoted excerpts of the acts (and linked to their full texts) so that anyone posting in this thread has some point of reference for the discussion (at least in terms of U.S. Copyright laws).
Yes she did post some valid points, just none that really concern our business.
That's the tough part. Technology now allows us to do incredible things with music. I think that as an industry (DJ or KJ), we have to consider a) what laws apply to us, b) lobby for clarification of or changes to laws as they apply specifically to us, and c) always conduct business in a lawful and ethical manner.
So essentially it's not so much the copying or changing media that 'breaks the law,' it really just comes down to extending the life of the media. They're counting on the discs wearing out, forcing you to buy them again?
That's what the record companies are aiming for - it keeps them in business. Songwriters, performers and publishing rights owners are looking for protection and a legal claim to their intangible ("ephemeral" in legalese) property. It's easy to point to a car, say, "I own that," because it's something people can see & feel. It's harder to point to an idea or a melody and say, "I own that," or, "I owned that first," which is the source of a lot of these lawsuits.
 
So essentially it's not so much the copying or changing media that 'breaks the law,' it really just comes down to extending the life of the media. They're counting on the discs wearing out, forcing you to buy them again?
The way it reads to me is that if your intent is to copy, your intent is to change media, if your long term intent is to do other than play the music you paid for, it's a violation of the law. But, if your intent is to use your computer as a player for the sake of easier access (in the spirit of the "Fair Use" decision) I would think you are acting legally. If I get busted that will be my arguement.
 
OK, Try This On For Size

Opie & Anthony, a national radio show both broadcast and on satellite are doing the following:


They are holding a Karaoke contest where the singers send in 60 seconds of themselves and their accompaniment. The music is chosen from O&A's song book, downloaded to the singer, who records with it, and is then sent to the show where it will be re-broadcast over satellite and regular radio.

This will tell me if there are any worries for me, because if they don't get busted, no one will. However, if others' get busted and they don't, nothing will hold up in court....