Sorry for the length but some of these posts take time to answer.
Over the years I have heard all sorts of complaints, claims and counter claims for all manner of audio gear. It is funny how the sense of hearing is doubted more than our sense of sight. I have satellite TV. The signal I receive is compressed for transmission. Do I bemoan something is lost? The picture presented to me is superior to a standard NTSC terrestrial transmission. I’ve never heard a claim to the contrary. In fact, Comcast touts its digital COMPRESSED service. When audio is discussed, all certainty goes out the window. The fuzzy nature of sound encourages the doubt not suffered by visual media.
FLAC is now the flavor of the month. That is fine. I have nothing against the algorithm. The claim forwarded is that such large hard drives are available that it makes MP3 unnecessary. OK I’ll bite. Why not buy a larger or two hard drives and cut out the FLAC? I’ll take my pulse code modulation straight. Thanks.
The only credible means to test claims for the superiority of one device, algorithm or cable is double blind testing. Neither the tester nor the tested person knows what is in the signal chain. When this is scrupulously followed all manner of miraculous results are served up.
It is discovered many cannot discern distortion levels up to 5%. Persons cannot tell one amplifier from another once all input variances have been eliminated. In one such test a live violinist hidden behind a curtain along with the test speakers was described as “tinny” and “unnatural”. Differences between cables? You might as well flip a coin.
MP3s sound damn good, my opinion. The algorithm has been steadily improved. It has not remained stagnant. Many of the arguments about something missing were said about CDs when they first appeared. If not 44kHz why not 96? Less missing no? No, maybe Johnny’s right we should never have gone digital. Vinyl (analog) is the best and only “professional” media. How many of those older catalog purchases use the analog tape source?
And by the way, the level of [power] amplification does not enter into it. Either the dynamic range is reproduced or it is not. A pair of headphones retailing for between $100 - $200 are easily the match of a $5000/pair speakers without power amplification. They will easily reproduce the dynamic ranges originally recorded. You want to compare, start with your headphones. For the moment, never mind the FLAC. Compare the CD to a high quality MP3 encoded file. Encode at 192kbs Have somebody mix up some files and see if you can tell the difference between file types. It may not be blind-blind but it is better than nothing. If you can tell the difference make sure to wear hearing protection around power tools as you have golden ears. They're keepers.