Where Does The Brilliance Come From?

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

JoeChartreuse

New DJ
Dec 12, 2006
3,934
1
70
Bergen County, NJ
I get a lot of offers regarding DJ instructional materials. Here's my dilemna:


Many of these offerings cite DJs who say they do gazillion dollar events. They say they spend lifetimes on each one, and do maybe 15 of the super duper top notch events (usually weddings) per year.


My question is, at that event count, where did they acquire this vast storehouse of experience that they're selling? These guys would have to work over 15 years to equal just ONE of my years. ( That's including bar venues of course, but I still do 2-3 times what they do in private events, and that's not bunches either- but I'm not selling instruction.)


When I actually ASKED one of these guys I was told that since my event count was higher than theirs I must be doing hack shows and formula events. Since I have the hide of a rhino, and since anyone attempting to sell anything this way was a moron in the first place, I let it pass and said goodbye. I now put the question to you. Are they learning from others' instructions, cribbing, repackaging, and reselling? DO they actually HAVE anything to offer? ( Not to me so far, but mine was a tiny sampling). SHOULDN'T some one offering instruction based on experience HAVE more than the prospective client?


Hey, this is the stuff that goes through my head at 4am. What can I tell ya?
 
DO they actually HAVE anything to offer?

Everyone has something to offer from the newbie to the gazillion dollar guy. Is it worth buying? Well that's up to your train of thought

More to say when I'm more awake
 
1) Everyone has something to offer from the newbie to the gazillion dollar guy. 2) Is it worth buying?



1) You're absolutely right, of course. That's why I come here!


2) THIS is the question that's important, along WITH their source of info...Where DOES it come from?
 
Thanks, Joe. :)

Jeff's right. Everyone has something to offer. Should one take everything that is offered, compile it and package it for sale, more power to him or her.

Being skeptical is not necessarily synonymous with being the bad guy. I too am initially suspicious of anything that's being sold as must-have or must-do. On the other hand, I have yet to get nothing useful from any seminar or training session. The successful presenter knows how to deliver the goods in a non-confrontational manner.

There is some good in everything. Separate the wheat from the chaff. Take what you can use, save what you can't for later and disregard the fluff. Pay no attention to the byline. Who wrote it or said it doesn't matter. It's what's written or said that matters. :)

Whether you're doing "hack" shows or not isn't an issue. The fact that you're doing shows ~ and gaining experience from every one ~ is what's important.
SHOULDN'T some one offering instruction based on experience HAVE more than the prospective client?
In this old dog's humble opinion, yes. Nothing attracts respect like experience. I could read a training manual on tampon forming machinery and still be as dumb as a rock. I could dig in to that machinery and turn wrenches and be a little less dumb. But after turning the wrenches, I have a better understanding of what the training manual has been saying all along.

Hands-on experience and advice from the experienced go hand in hand. Never, ever turn down advice, even if your initial impression is "I don't need that." In truth, you may not need it now but you could well need it later.

Thoughts?
 
I get a lot of offers regarding DJ instructional materials. Here's my dilemna:

Many of these offerings cite DJs who say they do gazillion dollar events. They say they spend lifetimes on each one, and do maybe 15 of the super duper top notch events (usually weddings) per year.

Joe,

I can't speak to anything else you wrote, but the majority of the prominent educational / instructional offerings for DJs are ones that I own. I own Randy Bartlett's 1% Solution DVD set, I own Scott Faver's Gamemaster DVD set, I own of Peter Merry's book and DVD, Rob Peters' book, as well as some Bobby Morganstein products amidst others.

I'm not sure what other specific materials you're referring to, but I know that for the aforementioned folks, they're all tried and true full-time entertainers with the experience that validates their credentials and educational offerings.
 
1) Whether you're doing "hack" shows or not isn't an issue. The fact that you're doing shows ~ and gaining experience from every one ~ is what's important.

2) In this old dog's humble opinion, yes. Nothing attracts respect like experience. I could read a training manual on tampon forming machinery and still be as dumb as a rock. I could dig in to that machinery and turn wrenches and be a little less dumb. But after turning the wrenches, I have a better understanding of what the training manual has been saying all along.

Hands-on experience and advice from the experienced go hand in hand. Never, ever turn down advice, even if your initial impression is "I don't need that." In truth, you may not need it now but you could well need it later.

Thoughts?

Just so we don't get off track:


1) The "hack" comment was thrown at me as an insult. I don't do 'em. While bar venues COULD get stale if I let them, I don't. Each and every private event is planned to be unique- no formulas.....I'm just sayin' that the "hacK" thing is not an issue for this thread.



2) I agree that any information can be useful, and again, that's why I come here. Also not an issue. I guess I'm not a great communicator,,,:sqembarrassed:


The issues are:


A: Would you BUY instructional information from some one less experienced than you?


B: Any thoughts on where inexperienced people get the information that they are attempting to SELL?
 
Joe,

I can't speak to anything else you wrote, but the majority of the prominent educational / instructional offerings for DJs are ones that I own. I own Randy Bartlett's 1% Solution DVD set, I own Scott Faver's Gamemaster DVD set, I own of Peter Merry's book and DVD, Rob Peters' book, as well as some Bobby Morganstein products amidst others.

I'm not sure what other specific materials you're referring to, but I know that for the aforementioned folks, they're all tried and true full-time entertainers with the experience that validates their credentials and educational offerings.

I am sure that there are some very good instructional videos out there, whether or not I've seen them.

PLEASE:


I made it a point not to mention any names. I have have no wish to start a thread of flames and comparisons. The thread issues are as stated in A and B above. ( Post #6)
 
A: Would you BUY instructional information from some one less experienced than you?

I would if the person offering the material demonstrates that they are worth listening to. The way to determine that is to get to know the person; go to a free seminar they are giving; look at their posts in forums.

B: Any thoughts on where inexperienced people get the information that they are attempting to SELL?

Just because a DJ has done fewer events than I does not mean that they are inexperienced.

But, to answer the question:
1. Success they have had in the events they have done.
2. Compiling anecdotal experience from other DJs.
3. Pure speculation (BS).
 
I stumbled upon a niche market and developed my own personal program to serve it.

A good number of people expressed interest in learning more about it, so I compiled all I had learned into a business plan and began to sell it.

While my plan isn't for everyone, it is for the right type of person.

Just like the other books written by fellow DJ's, if they provide helpful information on a certain niche, they'd probably be worth investigating. I'd have a hard time buying a generalized "how to DJ" book, but that's me.

However, I did buy Sid's book of games, as I wanted to explore that segment of the business. I did find about half a dozen things in that book that I was able to use in my own gigs, so I found that book quite useful. But, as you can see, it was addressing a specific niche that made it appealing.
 
I don't think years in the biz has everything to do with it. Some people just "get it" faster than others.

You asked "where does it come from"

where do any new ideas come from? Some people just have better minds than others. Who came up with any idea first? How long where they cooking meat before someone siad "uggm, it be better with some of this leaves on it" (in my best caveman voice)

maybe that person had just started cooking but had a great idea.

I know DJs who have been in biz for years and never have a idea of there own, they just learn from boards like these, conventions and so on.. It's cool.

As far as all the stuff out there to buy? I tell my wife when she is at a lost for what to buy me, open the back of a mag, and buy one of them, I can always learn something from even the stupidest thing... :)
 
Before I comment, I wonder...

Where are you truly having the issue. Is it paying for information vs getting "free" via chat boards?

Or is it attempting to find if paying for information vs. defining the quality?
 
I would if the person offering the material demonstrates that they are worth listening to. The way to determine that is to get to know the person; go to a free seminar they are giving; look at their posts in forums.



Just because a DJ has done fewer events than I does not mean that they are inexperienced.

But, to answer the question:
1. Success they have had in the events they have done.
2. Compiling anecdotal experience from other DJs.
3. Pure speculation (BS).



That's the sort of stuff I was looking for. So, experience isn't neccisarily all? Ok that's the first issue. The second? Where are the getting the smarts?
 
Before I comment, I wonder...

Where are you truly having the issue. Is it paying for information vs getting "free" via chat boards?

Or is it attempting to find if paying for information vs. defining the quality?


The issues are as I posted them.


The issues are:


A: Would you BUY instructional information from some one less experienced than you?


B: Any thoughts on where inexperienced people get the information that they are attempting to SELL?
__________________

I am already on this forum and learn plenty, and in a very enjoyable manner. This, or any other free forum is not a part of the issue. Also, in my eyes payment NEVER defines quality one way or the other.