A New Consideration For DJ Licensing.

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
Status
Not open for further replies.
(This was posted on another board by me, but it was inspired by this thread which kinda touched a nerve and I want to bring it up here to initiate a dialogue with the good folks here. I'm not looking to pick a fight with anyone, I am merely throwing this idea to the marketplace of ideas because it's time may have finally come in order to save the jobs of many of my DJ friends out there.)

Perhaps it's finally time to lobby for DJ licensing. In order for a DJ to play in a hall, they have to produce a copy of their DJ license. Hell, many halls are now requiring DJs to have liability insurance, so they are already in the habit of checking for paperwork.

A DJ license wouldn't have to be based on performance. That is a subjective item and really cannot be judged objectively.

However, requiring a DJ to prove certain things, such as a minimum liability insurance policy and a business license from the town hall of their residence, are not subjective items but bland paper documents that would be fair to everyone.

No license, no play. The hall lets you play, they take a chance on a fine of some sort.

The iPod DJs, the fly by nighters, the lowballers would suddenly be forced from under the table, since their existence would now be proveable. The Fed and the State would expect there to be some kind of income for tax filing purposes.

I hate that it has come to this where I, as a proud Conservative "get government out of our lives" kind of guy, have come to advocate a program like this.

But, if my friends still in the business wish to remain, hell, if the DJ industry itself wishes to remain, it has to fight back with methods outside the box.

Trying to convince a prospect of paying a going rate when an iPod (which everyone has) can do the job for pennies on the dollar. There will begin to emerge a bride demographic that would prefer to spend her money on other things, as it becomes quite easy for her family and friends to talk her out of spending big money on something that she can get for much much less.

Granted, there will always be a market for the high end customer who appreciates what a DJ's skills can do for her wedding, and how a DJ lacking in those skills can ruin an event. However, based on what I'm reading, from someone now on the outside looking in, I'd say that things aren't looking too rosy for my fellow DJ brethren.

Licensing may be an issue whose time has finally come.
 
In theroy...

...it sounds like a good idea, but you are, in fact, inviting government into our lives with the suggestion.

iPod DJ's will dig their own graves if given enough time. Skill and talent can't be made up. The customer for a high class show will always be there. You just need to figure out ways to search out and market to that customer.

And, buy the way, there are lots of "cheap" brides who WANT "cheap" entertainment for their weddings. Guess who going to fill that market? Not me!
 
John,

I'm not attempting a derail or upstage...simply clarification.

Which side of the fence are you on...regarding the issue you've posed?

It sounds oddly familiar to [CLICK HERE TO VIEW] thread...

Tyrone Blue said:
Skill and talent can't be made up.

Then where are all these upstart DJs coming from? :sqwink:
 
Licensing is all well and good but for the people who "just don't care" it won't have an effect. Look at how many people drive a car without a license even though every state has driver licensing laws.

How many people do you know operate some sort of business without the proper licenses, insurance, and so on? In my (very) small town I can think of 4 or 5 off the top of my head.

I also agree with Tyrone's sediments who wants big brother looking at their lives more?

For the wedding jocks and most mobiles it will help some but the impact would be very little, IMHO. You will always find the hall manager who forgets to look for the license, who doesn't know to look for the license, the guys that will just turn a blind eye, and the others who will take a kick back for letting you preform without a license.
 
Licensing is all well and good but for the people who "just don't care" it won't have an effect. Look at how many people drive a car without a license even though every state has driver licensing laws.

Dan,

I respectfully disagree...

Licensing without enforcement may have little effect.

However, make the penalties sting...and the message will get across.

If we fully apply the drivers license anology...one must ask why do we even bother issuing drivers licenses...since there may always be an unlicensed driver?

Sometimes the general order of things creates a need for clear and aggressive guidelines.


How about this for teeth!

$500 initial fine and automatic IRS audit.
$1,000 in additional fines if the entity fails to comply within 30days of initial reporting.
$2,500 in additional fines if the entity fails to comply within 60days of initial reporting.
$5,000 in additional fines and seizure of all related equipment for liquidation of fines if the entity fails to comply within 90days of initial reporting.

You can't tell me that $8,000 in potential fines, automatic audit and seizure of equipment wouldn't deter most nare-do-wells.


How about a 2nd level of enforcement.

Any "hosting" entity...public, private or commercial must obtain an entertainment permit that requires the hiring of a licensed entertainer.

This license could cover all forms of entertainment.
 
John,

I'm not attempting a derail or upstage...simply clarification.

Which side of the fence are you on...regarding the issue you've posed?
Dude, I'm on this side today. Tomorrow I may be on the other side.

I just felt like blabbering and this is what came out. :sqwink:

Actually, I just wanted to inspire a good debate. It's starting to get hot out again, the humidity is climbing and I will be stuck in my office all day for the next couple of days, it's the only room in the house with AC and I need it when the weather gets like this. I literally struggle with simple breathing when the air gets all thick and the thermometer climbs into the red.

But, anyway, back on topic, I just felt like starting a topic that I hoped would generate some serious discussion.
 
Wellllllllllllllll :)


Problem here (other than the afore to mentioned getting gov't out of our lives), is that you can't have one national license, as that would go against states rights. Every time somebody does that, there seems to be a civil war ;)

So, you can get a business license for $10-25 just about anywhere.

IRS can't be brought in for penalties -- heck, we're not even sure they're legal themselves...

"Clear and aggressive guidlines", are all well and good, if YOU are on the side wanting them. If not, you will fight just as hard against them.


IMHO, this country wasn't founded on the ideals that big brother needs to take care of you -- you need to take care of yourself, and do a better job than the next guy, and you will succeed.
 
Dan,

I respectfully disagree...

Licensing without enforcement may have little effect.

However, make the penalties sting...and the message will get across.

If we fully apply the drivers license anology...one must ask why do we even bother issuing drivers licenses...since there may always be an unlicensed driver?

Sometimes the general order of things creates a need for clear and aggressive guidelines.


How about this for teeth!

$500 initial fine and automatic IRS audit.
$1,000 in additional fines if the entity fails to comply within 30days of initial reporting.
$2,500 in additional fines if the entity fails to comply within 60days of initial reporting.
$5,000 in additional fines and seizure of all related equipment for liquidation of fines if the entity fails to comply within 90days of initial reporting.

You can't tell me that $8,000 in potential fines, automatic audit and seizure of equipment wouldn't deter most nare-do-wells.


How about a 2nd level of enforcement.

Any "hosting" entity...public, private or commercial must obtain an entertainment permit that requires the hiring of a licensed entertainer.

This license could cover all forms of entertainment.

In theory that sounds great. In real life it won't work, here's why:

Who is going to enforce it?

That's the bottom line, when people can make money free and clear weather they're "cheating" the government out of taxes or not, they will and will break the law to do so.

Look at the "war on drugs" this has been going on since the 1970's (correct me if my timeline is off). You have government law enforcement agencies (think DEA or ATF) dedicated to specifically erraticating drugs and local law enforcement doing simple buy and busts on a daily basis. Yet, the drug trade is bigger, more efficient, and profitable than ever. You would think with all the billions we have and will continue to spend on "the war on drugs" they sould of been erraticated by now. Why haven't they been? Simple to the growers or cultivators and suppliers it's virtually free money. For everyone one of the thousands they lock up, 2 or 3 more come out of the woodwork to continue on.

You can bet your last dollar on this: If our government could figure out a way to tax it and control it, all drugs would be 100% legal.

I realize that I've deviated from the topic at hand but the same holds true for those "limewire/iPod DJs", it's free money.

You will always find a local cop that will look the other way. Any venue owner, be it bar or catering hall, worth a hill of beans has a relationship with the local PD, who will in turn look the other way for a "friend".

County and state officials, think sheriffs and state police have better things to do than check if a DJ has a license or if the venue has checked for a permit/license, like the war on drugs. ;)

What most people loose sight of is:

The forum "talking" DJs represent a very, very small segment of DJs, even at the largest forums on the web. The few that are passionate about this industry are always over ruled by the collective, those not on the radar, such as the non-forum participating DJs who will do a wedding for what amounts to beer money.

Secondly what our government has lost sight of:

People by nature will pursue riches and fame by an means presented to them without regard for the law.
 
IMHO, this country wasn't founded on the ideals that big brother needs to take care of you -- you need to take care of yourself, and do a better job than the next guy, and you will succeed.
Rick, I agree and that's why this issue can have me taking one side today and the other side tomorrow.

Good debate so far. Unlike what I found on another "DJ Chat" board.
 
As i said elsewhere, where do you think dj licensing will fit in terms of municipal, state, federal politics......on the low low end of the scale.....

I think a better tact would be for the various associations to lobby to the venues and educate them, as well as brides and grooms as to the importance of having insured dj services in their buildings. from a legal liability standpoint, I can't fathom any venue taking a risk with any uninsured contractor coming onto their premises. they open themselves up, as does the bride and groom to all kinds of liability.

Too bad the associations, at least here, seem uninterested....
 
Problem here (other than the afore to mentioned getting gov't out of our lives), is that you can't have one national license, as that would go against states rights. Every time somebody does that, there seems to be a civil war

Rick,

Is the US Copyright law state or federal?

Albeit, there may be "civil" war..., however, as John Allo pointed out...there is a problem at hand.

Throw this into the mix.

Moonshiners have been around for years!

They made money hand over fist during prohibition.

Moonshiners pop-up & are shut down by the ATF.

Here's what the "non gov't control" voice doesn't acknowledge.

If the ATF was not in place, moonshine would be readily available to consumers across the nation as a "cheaper" non-taxed alternative.

The ATF, by process protects legit brewers while they keep the riff-raff at bay while enforcing a tax structure.

Control does not necessarily mean less competition and tyranical intrusions. It can provide a greater established marketplace for products & related educational services.

The ATF was created to help defray Revolutionary Was debt. When congress proposed a domestic tax...taxpayers (just like MDJs would) grumbled with political resistance.

Yet, the same arguements of resistance...it'll never fly...say NO to big brother...we don't don't want big government...it's a cartel...etc...were probably heard by Congress in 1792.

Here's a curious thought?

Could Congress pass such a legislation today given the intrusion that media & instant communications provides?
 
Is the US Copyright law state or federal?

Federal, unfortunately (IMHO).


Moonshiners have been around for years!

Yes. Check the records, my Great-GrandFather and GrandFather were busted for it in 1929 -- one of the stills is still buried in the back ;)


If the ATF was not in place, moonshine would be readily available to consumers across the nation as a "cheaper" non-taxed alternative.

Problem being?



IMHO, it doesn't matter.

The only folks that bitch and want more government control, are those that aren't doing well on their own.

When people are doing bad, they tend to blame somebody else, in this case, the low end iPod DJ.

As Mel Brooks would say, "Everybody does it..." :)


What's the cure? Well easy, make 'em get a license, pay more taxes, and the problem will go away. Sorry, the problem is your own, and if you can't take the heat, well, the kitchen has a door...

I hear insurance is a good business to be in these days (unless God decides not to bust our chops for awhile)... ;)

:sqbiggrin:
 
OK lets reflect.

For awhile all that was being said was make sure your dj has back up gear or if they have a problem they could end up ruining your big day. In essence a scare tactic but the djs that the comment was aimed at went out and bought backup equipment. Cant use that one any more.

Make sure your dj has legal music you don't want the RIAA rushing in during your wedding and shutting it down because the dj has a few illegal songs. Again a scare tactic aimed at getting people to stop using under priced djs. Again even the RIAA has trouble deciding on the exact letter of the law. But in essence we are all illegal according to what I've found out. So that ones really a bust also. Besides what RIAA official wants to go to court and face a judge for shutting down a wedding, while the bride is standing there crying.

Make sure your dj has liability insurance, again a scare tactic but this one truly holds some truth. But the problem is that to get insurance its really not that hard or really that expensive.

Now we want to tell everyone that they should hire a dj who is licensed. The regulation on this would be a nightmare. You have to remember that when one branch of the government gets involved, lets say the federal, how long before the state, county, and city governments want a share of the pie also.

The problem I see is that those who are making $1500.00 to $5000.00 per gig might think this is great but in reality what you are really doing is trying to regulate free trade and business. And to be honest that isn't right. Yes if this came about many low end djs would probably have to close up shop, but if you think weddings are down now I for see it getting worse if there is no competition.

If I can make a living paying my bills and taking care of my family what right does anyone have to say how I run my business as long as its legal and honest. If you are having a problem making a go of it maybe you've hit the glass ceiling and need to lower the rates some.

Yes I do believe that insurance is the way to go but a license for what, just so someone who cries about not being able to handle free enterprise can feel good about themselves, why don't you just get out of the business, I hear Walmart is hiring.
 
Yes. Check the records, my Great-GrandFather and GrandFather were busted for it in 1929 -- one of the stills is still buried in the back ;)

Cool!

The only folks that bitch and want more government control, are those that aren't doing well on their own.

Interesting statement.

One's persons bitching...is another persons pursuit of happiness.


If a person were to open any type of business. Rent the space, hire the staff, inventory the business, pay the utilities...etc... and another person comes along without a lick of overhead...claiming that they are "equal" & commences selling out of a van or on the sidewalk directly in front of that business...who's screwing who?

In essence...it's what we have in the MDJ industry.

"We do everything they do...for less..because they're greedy and we're not"

There's a radio ad running in my market currently based on that very premise.

When people are doing bad, they tend to blame somebody else, in this case, the low end iPod DJ.

Rick, the low end...is screwing the low end these days.

This has more to do with defending one's livelihood than a case of sour grapes. Blame is one of those interesting catalyst words. Perhaps blame really means "properly identifying" the source of the problem.


1998-1999 ushered in one of the death tolls that began ringing for the MDJ industry.

Napster...and other's soon after...provided a weapon that would create a wound that doesn't heal. This industry has become infected by algorithms sold as a convenience, embraced by greed, employed by the masses for unscrupulous replicate gain.

What's the cure? Well easy, make 'em get a license, pay more taxes, and the problem will go away. Sorry, the problem is your own, and if you can't take the heat, well, the kitchen has a door...

Perhaps that’s just the heat we need to turn up on the nare-do-wells...? Who knows? Maybe they will leave the kitchen.

thatmusicguy said:
Too bad the associations, at least here, seem uninterested....

Which associations would that be?

thatmusicguy said:
I think a better tact would be for the various associations to lobby to the venues and educate them, as well as brides and grooms as to the importance of having insured dj services in their buildings.

Lobbying takes $$$, time & commitment. Appealing to the masses takes major bucks. There is little hope for a unified front (too many do it my way-er’s). WAY TOO MANY WIIFM-ers!

Brides & Grooms are short lived. Seasonal at best. Each new season offers a new crop of Brides & Grooms that need to be educated.

Venue’s may be the best hope...however, they rarely seem to take action on things that they don’t directly profit from.


Deejay Dan said:
In theory that sounds great. In real life it won't work, here's why:

Who is going to enforce it?

Wouldn’t a better approach be to discuss the possibility of WHO could enforce it?

How about the Secretary of State, Attorney General & Local Law enforcement working in conjunction with a state MDJ association.

Deejay Dan said:
People by nature will pursue riches and fame by an means presented to them without regard for the law.

Precisely why a solution needs to be found.
 
This has been a good civil debate! Thanks everyone!

As I said before, quite unlike the same thread at another "DJ Chat" board.

All a license would require is a minimum of 2 things: proof of insurance and a valid business license from your town hall.

This would force a level playing field, as everyone would now have this minimum and then let the chips fall where they may. However, once a fly by night DJ's existence has been "outed" (for lack of a better word) with these mimimum requirements, they'd have no choice but to start paying taxes on their income.

It was my experience that the under the table DJs pay no taxes, that's why they're under the table.

Bring them into the light, require everyone to play by the same rules and then let the market decide.

Is that such a bad idea?

Special to Rick: I advocate this today. Talk to me tomorrow and I might be on the other side. That's how controversial this issue is and how the right to privacy and keeping governmental intrusion as low as possible is offset by unfair market conditions which do not allow fair competition.

Tough call, for sure. Both sides are likely to be right.
 
Greets, John and thanks. :)

If it's any help, Delaware requires disc jockeys to obtain state business licences. GL isn't a requirement, though.

For all the good it does. This area is up to its armpits in inexpensive DJs. Everyone and his uncle is a DJ around here, it seems. I've yet to see a DJ display a state business licence. We've seen several DJs at local bridal fairs. We display ours. We prefer to do things right. But to be honest, no one really cares.

The only way this biz will be regulated is if we offer services that involve public safety, health and hygene. The closest we get to the safety aspect is speaker cabs on tripods, lighting truss and cabling that's laid over access and egress.

The thing with any legislative requirement ~ it carries the added costs of inspections and enforcement. If the state doesn't allocate funding in the budget for these costs, the law is meaningless and has no teeth.

It's a state's rights issue and legislating mobile entertainers isn't a priority for most states. They're more concerned with making up for the highway department fund that's in the red.
 
I hate that it has come to this where I, as a proud Conservative "get government out of our lives" kind of guy, have come to advocate a program like this.

I too am a " keep the government out of it" kind of guy, because once they're in, they are like a Plantar's wart, shoving themselves deep into every nook and cranny- with almost no good coming from them and a detriment to others.

The post, if I read it correctly, pretty much describes DJ licensing as a way to diminish low ball and ipod competion, and not much else. I figure that if I can't sell myself well enough, and have the equipment and expertise to compete with the sort of DJs described, then I shouldn't be in this line of work. This would be a VERY weak reason to allow the government another opening into our lives....

BTW- I'm sure halls and bar venues will check those licenses out as thoroughly as they do for any other entertainment- which is virtually not at all- thus making the whole thing useless anyway.
 
There are still places in the US that don't require you to have a business license. Also, what is described as a business license in one city may be called a different name in another and have different requirements for obtaining one.

I consider DJing and Entertaining to be an artistic and creative pursuit, and I just cannot see artists required to be licensed like a plumber or a nurse. Yes, it behooves the DJ/entertainer to be a good business person to best succeed with their craft and to be legal paying their taxes due, but I don't like the idea of squishing creativity and most importanty, the opportunity to perform.
 
Pammie, those are good points, but as the number of shady "artistic and creative pursuers" who rip off the public continues to grow, at some point, someone's going to start a movement to oversee their business practices.

Yes, it's only a DJ and yes, it's only a wedding (in the grand scheme of things, small fries compared to the damage an improperly wired house can do), but if the public continues to get ripped off on a regular basis by idiot DJs, the wrong person in the vast sea of consumers is going to get ripped off and take some sort of action. (Now THAT's a long sentence!)
 
John,

Two twists:

First, the license you are concerned about already exists in this state. It is issued by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts to entertainment bureaus and talent agents - which would include multi-ops representing a variety of DJs. It requires state registration and the posting of a $1,000 bond. It is the same type of license applied to other forms of "agency".

But, a license at the individual level you seek is not possible. It violates too many individual rights, and the playing of phono recordings at a wedding or similar event is also a private and personal matter. The fact that money changes hands, or that an agreement exists is not enough to distinguish your class of DJ from any other individual or personal arrangement.

What kind of audio gear or perfomrers a facility will or won't allow on their premises can't be regulated to such a personal level. Sure, you can't have a fire-eater without a a fire marshal on site, but it's the flame and the fire code - not the entertainment that triggers the regulation.

Secondly, you are essentially trying to regulate the indooor use of audio or public address equipment which can be construed as an infringement of the 1st amendment and rights to peaceful assembly.

Finally, liability insurance is a business and contractual matter, not a legal obligation. Also, it is not a protection to a client - it is a protection of assets, primarily those of the policy holder. If victims were "protected" the pay-out wouldn't be called "compensation". So insurance isn't protecting them - it's protecting your assets from claims made against you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.