Mono, Bi and More Amping - a short primer

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

Balanced Line

New DJ
Aug 14, 2006
855
0
72
Yeah it is really long but there are pictures too!

In preparation to answering Tyrone’s excellent question I thought it might make it easier if we had some drawings to refer to. Tyrone’s question is very straight forward but it requires some explanation of bi-amp’d systems in order that everyone can follow along. There are many permutations to bi-amping including tri and quad amping and beyond. If there any questions or comments - feedback is appreciated post or PM if you prefer.

A word on conventions used in the drawings. A broken (dashed) line is represents the enclosure of a piece of equipment. The lines outside the broken line are cables that you can handle outside the piece of equipment such as speaker and line level cables. A triangle is an amplifier. You’ll note the rounded corner rectangular boxes with a droopy line above Hi or Lo Pass. Think of this representing the frequency response curve of the output. Each schematic represents half a stereo pair. A pair (two) of the equipment represented is necessary for stereo.

For purposes of starting at the beginning let us view Figure 0a. This is the simplest configuration of amplified audio system. An audio mixer drives a power amplifier with a full range line level signal. The amplifier provides gain, increasing the amplitude of the signal sent to the single, full-range speaker. Systems like this can sound quite good but not as good as systems using two or three way designs. A one-way speaker design’s response falls off at the highest and lowest frequencies. Another factor is power handling. They are not capable of handling as much power as a two or more way speaker system.

In figure #0b we have a two way speaker design. There is still only one amplifier per side but that amplified signal is now fed to a passive crossover. Passive means all the elements function without external power to the speaker level signal. Crossovers can be designed in many different ways to suit specifications of the drivers for frequency response and power handling and relative efficiency of the speaker drivers. The least complicated and costly “crossover” is a bi-polar capacitor, which blocks low frequencies from the tweeter. That technically is not a crossover but it plays one in cheap speakers. Tweeters, typically can't handle as much power as a woofer. Tweeters are built more lightly because there is less energy (power) in the higher octaves of sound for music and voice.

Figure 1 presents a classic bi-amplified system. You will note that the crossover has been removed from the speaker enclosure. It is now an active piece of electronics that no longer needs to handle significant power nor does the design have to contend with the reactance presented by the speaker drivers . Instead it only needs to shape a line level signal and is isolated and buffered by electronics. This allows the design to much more accurately control the response curve for the intended drivers. This change requres two amplifiers per side as there are now two line level signals that must be amplified to speaker level (on each side). Typically because there is less energy in higher frequencies the high frequency amplifier can be (approximately) half the size of the low frequency amplifier.

Figure 2, for all you “active” speaker fans is the configuration (in simplified form) of one of the most popular DJ speakers, the Mackie SRM 450. All the same elements are there. The only thing that has changed is the location. All the earlier elements are now contained within the speaker enclosure. A line level signal is connected to the input. All decisions and adjustments have been decided by the designers. All you need do is set the system gain with the input sensitivity control. Truly plug and play.

Figure 3. Simply because the speaker system is powered does not necessarily mean the design has to have an active crossover or be bi-amped. In this design a single built-in (mono) amplifier applies a signal to a passive crossover that in turn drives the speakers. The bi-amped design is preferable but if properly designed this type of configuration can proved very good quality at more modest power levels.

Figure 4. This is the configuration that Tyrone mentioned in his original question. As you view the schematic you will see it represents variations on the original themes. The “tops” in the box on the upper right hand corner of the drawing are passive non-powered speakers with an internal passive crossover. A nearly full range signal is being fed to the tops lacking only the bottom octaves. These bottom octaves are reproduced by the sub-woofer. If the tweeter and woofer inputs are available outside the speaker there is no reason this couldn’t be reconfigured as a tri-amped system with the addition of another amp and a suitable active crossover.

The mixer sends the full range of frequencies to an active crossover. The lows are sent to one pair of amplifiers and the higher (but still most of the range) are sent to a second pair of amps and on to the “tops” or full range speakers where the passive crossover further divides the signal.

Bi and tri amping provides better clarity and better handling of speaker signals. Damping is improved because there is no resistance presented by coils or dropping resistors. Power to is used more efficiently because of the direct connection of the speaker drivers to the amplifiers. Many hands make light work, the multiple amplifiers can more easily and more accurately drive the individual speaker drivers without resorting to enormous power amplifiers. There is safety here too in the redundancy of multiple amplifiers.
 

Attachments

  • Fig_0.gif
    Fig_0.gif
    18.3 KB · Views: 15
  • Fig_1.gif
    Fig_1.gif
    17.5 KB · Views: 8
  • Fig_2.gif
    Fig_2.gif
    24.3 KB · Views: 7
  • Fig_3.gif
    Fig_3.gif
    20.3 KB · Views: 10
  • Fig_4.gif
    Fig_4.gif
    22.1 KB · Views: 7
WOW! Very thorough!!!

I read over this a couple of times and still didn't grasp it. It's not you... it's me. I'll get this drink out of my hand, and try it again tomorrow. Nice Job!
 
Ask questions, the answers are only $.50 each! Yes, only 50 cents! Four bits.

Please don't struggle with it. If you have questions or something isn't clear, ask, please.

I'm not a professional writer guys so please give me feedback rather than assuming I have described it clearly.

Tyrone, all that was to set the stage. The answer you asked is much simpler to answer once everyone can see a schematic. Did I describe the connections for your system correctly?

NO! Keep the drink. It dulls the pain of having to think. Believe me I know.
 
Thank you, my friend.

Once you've used a bi- or tri-amped passive system, you'll never go back to full-range sound. Yeah, it involves more work and expense... but the client deserves no less than the best.

From my experience, people appreciate a good system tone. We have received many compliments on our sound over the years.

I've been poked at a few times by DJ buddies who see our tri-amped, passive rig and chuckle because they don't load all those amps, cases and cabinets.

My humble opinion: The easy way isn't necessarily the best way. If good tone was easy, anyone could do it.
 
I just talked to a sound tech...

I had a guy come into my gig tonight and introduce himself. He also does Karaoke in the Twin Cities. We started talking about speakers and systems and I asked him the same question as above.

He said "the best way to get more out of your system is to add one more speaker on each side of an amp. The 8 ohm speakers bridged, would result in a 4 ohm load and would make the amp work much better with better head room".

So, I am now assuming that I would have been much better off using 4 speakers on each of my two amps for 8 total speakers (two subs on the right, two on the left of first amp, two tops on the right and two on the left of second amp). Does this sound right to anyone?
 
Are you getting tired of this answer?

Maybe.

It depends upon the amp. You can get more power out of your amp by paralleling another speaker on each side.

I do believe he told you to connect the speaker in parallel not to bridge it which is a whole 'nother kettle of fish. The additional pair must be very similar to the first pair. They must have 8 ohm impedance or you will be running down toward 2 ohms which is not a good idea even if your amp will run 2 ohm loads.

Tyrone, didn't you say your additional pair was powered? I'd be careful about the passive subs aren't they 4 ohms each?
 
It depends upon the amp.

So, what makes most sense in my case? PLX 3402..... 700 WPC @ 8 ohms.... bridges to 1700 WPC @ 2 ohms.

If I want to add a passive sub, does it make sense to bridge the tops on one channel, and run the other channel to a passive sub? I have way too much amp, IMO, for just running a pair of MPro 215's. That is OK, as I would rather have, than not have enough power.

I don't want more tops. I do want a sub.
 
G'night

Papa, shooting from the hip - just a guess - a SWAG Scientific Wild Assed Guess. Bridge at 4 ohms, not two.

G'night folks. I'll look it up in the morning Papa.
 
Yes, Balanced...

I neglected to say that... I'd only use passive with passive in my above scenario. And by "bridging", I meant to say that I'd plug one speaker into the other with the extra jacks on my speakers. BTW, I was told not to use a third speaker on this channel, which would bring the ohm load too close to 2 ohms.

I know the result would be a 4 ohm signal to each of the two speakers on each output. I'm now looking for some more speakers to fill this need.
 
There's a lot of truth to this.

Adding speaker cabs (or drivers) is a good way to get more SPL from an amp. More speaker systems equal more movement of air.

Just please keep your amp's capabilities in mind and calculate your impedance loads before making a purchase.

Hope it helps.
 
A couple of points to remember:

When paralleling speakers ideally they should be identical. Failing that, they should have similar sensitivity and power handling specs. Otherwise one will be louder or pop (burn) earlier than the other. The weakest link determines your power limit.

Check the specifications on your amplifier. Ohm’s law states that if you halve the resistance in a circuit the current (and therefore power) is doubled too. The better the amplifier, the closer this is to being true for your sound too. Look at the specs for your amplifier. What is the difference between the output for 8 and 4 ohms? The closer it is to double, the more robust the construction of the power supply and signal chain. There can be exceptions but as a general rule this is true. Less robust power amplifiers will limit the advantage of adding a second pair of speakers on the same amplifier.

Bridging, connects the two halves of a stereo amp and makes it into a higher power mono amp. Did you want to run mono Papa? If you are talking about running two subs, no, keep them both running on each side of that amp. There is no advantage to bridging if you wish to run two, four ohm subs off that amp. I have not seen a 2 ohm bridge spec for your amp Papa. An amp that will run 2 ohm loads in stereo will typically run bridged loads down to 4 ohms. Similarly if your amp is good down to 4 ohms in stereo mode, will only operate in bridge mode down to 8 ohms.

Don't forget too that the harder they work the more likely they'll fail. You will find very few knowledgable persons that recommend operating at 2 ohms as normal operating proceedure. It is good to have a cushion.

BTW: That QSC has impressive specs even if it can't bridge @ 2 ohms Papa. I just confirmed via the QSC site that they don't publish a spec for bridged use @ 2 ohms.