Do You Have Enough Rig For The Gig?

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

What Are Your Parameters When Choosing A System For A Gig?


  • Total voters
    13
I use old Peaveys, with Black Widow 15's and huge horns. I can do 300-500 outside -- possibly more.

150 watt per channel Onkyo amp (which my brother felt the need to throw out).

Inside, I had to turn everything down to minimal -- very loud speakers. Heavy as sh_t, but they do fit in the back seat of the Mustang.

The cops used to show up when I turned the system on, and the closest neighbor is a few hundred yards away. They're holding up a table now, since I have no amps up here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
I have ten of the same top, and ten of the same sub. I bring between two and eight of each. I have never needed "ten"...as "eight" is a simpler setup and the extra two boxes don't really add much. With eight of each cabinet, I can provide adequate sound reinforcement for about 2500 adults or 1000 teenagers. Each increment of the system can be tuned to be "flat to 40" for an appropriate coverage area.

I consider room size (indoors) or "seating area" (outdoors), head count, size of dance floor / area to have "good" sound reinforcement, type of event & type of content, degree of control I have over the content (e.g. am I the DJ, are others DJing, is this a live band), and a handful of other factors (load in/out path, help or not, parking issues, etc)....all of which gets me to how much of my total rig I bring.

I suppose that the "one system fits all" is the closest poll option to what I have...but that doesn't really capture the reality of how I deploy the one system.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
This stack is 1/4 of available FOH sound.. So you tell me if there's enough
I may need that Nov 24.... I have a marathon that has grown from 1500 to expected 3000 over the last 3 years... Two 15" on sticks might not be enough now even for announcements
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
I may need that Nov 24.... I have a marathon that has grown from 1500 to expected 3000 over the last 3 years... Two 15" on sticks might not be enough now even for announcements


We did 10.000 people once in the band. We rented a set of of speakers, 4 x 8" on each side with horns, for the mics and drum kit. I had two MusicMan heads with a 120 watts each on rhythm, The lead guy had a 50 watt fender. The bass player had less than 100 watts.

They loved our renditions of Radar Love, Train Kept a Rollin, and All Right Now.

It's not the size of your penis that counts -- it's how you use it. ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
There are way too many variables for a standard response here. We used to have one small venue here that I had to bring a ton of power to because of the design of the building and the lack of acoustic friendliness and that same venue when full was much better than it was empty. It defied logic the sound traveled better when there were people in the way.

If it's a prom I bring the big gear regardless of the space if it's a 50th anniversary I bring a couple of speakers on sticks unless the room is extremely large. If it's a venue I am not familiar with which would be a rare occurrence I bring more than I would need based on what I can find out about the space
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
A couple of points here but this is not meant to discredit anyone's own opinion as to how they approach the solution of determining what Rig they can deploy. First, the last Option of "None! I have a one size fits all". When I see this I think of a DJ who has just one system and is willing to deploy it anywhere and hope that it works. Many times what they have may be enough and at other times it may not. That person may also only accept Gigs that is within their scope and may not be willing to buy/rent additional Gear if needed. They are more than willing to limp through the event with a blaring sound.

Second, there will always be a variables. There is no way I could have listed all in the Poll or discussion, everyone's situation not only is different but will also change for themselves when they go from Venue to Venue. The options of the Poll itself was to determine if the parameter(s) to be chosen was a "cut and dried" approach by many who may handle it that way. For example, I know of one guy, if he was hired to play for 40 people in a Hall that was best suited for 300, will only bring two 2 Way 15" powered speakers for sound. The acoustics in the room will mean nothing to him. Sure that system in a smaller room for the same people would work great but will sound like a POS in a large room.

However, it is more reasonable to say that usually a client will rent space that is more commensurable to the amount of guests that they are going to have. A venue may also guide them in that direction, even though I have seen and played for Clients who rented a huge space for a handful of people. I think therein lies a critical factor. How would the delivery of sound be perceived? If the DJ is making his choice solely on the number of people and the Hall is big, the sound projected may quickly be absorbed where his rig will sound inadequate to the listening audience no matter how it is deployed.

So yes there may be a combination of factors but I would think that one of them would take precedence. For me personally, I start with the size of the place, hence one of the reasons I make site visits. My objective is the fill that space with sound coverage. The SPL level can be controlled by adjustments in Gain or Volume. Needless to say, Pricing will be determined by the kind of Rig that I will be using.

To go one step further, lets suppose the Client wants lots of lights, given a particular size room, it may or may not take the same amount of lights for 40 people as it would for 400 people, if the Client is willing to pay for the same effect that will be adequate for that particular room. So really there is no right or wrong way for anyone but the kind of approach can lead to other less or more Dollars in your pocket. A construction hole can be dug with 4 men with shovels or 1 Huge back hoe. The hole may end up being the same but the cost may vary depending on how efficient the contractor or client wants it to be.
 
One other factor you failed to mention, Houston. No matter the sound system used, it can always be turned to '0'....the variable is where '10' falls. Could one argue that aside from physical space constraints, it is impossible to have too much system ('0' is equal in every system), yet entirely possible to have too little? Same for the person running the system. I have heard some pretty crappy systems sound better than they should; and likewise, some really nice systems I couldn't believe could sound so bad. Therefore, the 'ripping your head off' sound may not be volume at all, but just uncomfortable EQing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 people
One other factor you failed to mention, Houston. No matter the sound system used, it can always be turned to '0'....the variable is where '10' falls. Could one argue that aside from physical space constraints, it is impossible to have too much system ('0' is equal in every system), yet entirely possible to have too little? Same for the person running the system. I have heard some pretty crappy systems sound better than they should; and likewise, some really nice systems I couldn't believe could sound so bad. Therefore, the 'ripping your head off' sound may not be volume at all, but just uncomfortable EQing.
That is true Val. Thanks for pointing out that fact. Another reason I stress the importance of having an EQ, a few culprit frequencies can spoil good sound.
 
That is true Val. Thanks for pointing out that fact. Another reason I stress the importance of having an EQ, a few culprit frequencies can spoil good sound.

I'm glad to see you guys mention this. Since I switched over to 3-way tops, you wouldn't believe the difference in clarity and how much smoother it sounds, even cranked up. Keep in mind, I'm using the low-end Carvins (plastic case) but dang if they just don't put it out there and with no harshness at high volume. Pretty amazing given its $280 price tag and, knock on wood, they're rated at 400 watts cont./1600 watts peak. Haven't had a hint of breakdown.
 
Rick Ryan,
If you can imagine for a minute that a system had a selected driver for each available frequency that would make for an awesome sound. However it would be impossible have the ideal dedicated drivers and sound for each frequency for each and every song. this is why drivers are designed for a operable range. Think in terms of Live Sound where there is a large Mixer that feeds the individual musician's signal to its appropriate speakers. Each frequency range is then tailor made and can be individually adjusted. Same as in a studio, each frequency can be tweaked but then everything is mixed down in a condensed way to accomodate the general range of equipment used by the consumer. The music/CD is only limited by the system reproducing it.

Have you ever heard a true 4 way system where the main signal is broken down by one Crossover and fed to four drivers? This way there is no overlap or absence of frequencies. In my opinion this is the best way to separate the signals. Using onboard speaker settings or amp setting can overlap or cut out some frequencies and thus parts of the music.
 
Rick Ryan,
If you can imagine for a minute that a system had a selected driver for each available frequency that would make for an awesome sound. However it would be impossible have the ideal dedicated drivers and sound for each frequency for each and every song. this is why drivers are designed for a operable range. Think in terms of Live Sound where there is a large Mixer that feeds the individual musician's signal to its appropriate speakers. Each frequency range is then tailor made and can be individually adjusted. Same as in a studio, each frequency can be tweaked but then everything is mixed down in a condensed way to accomodate the general range of equipment used by the consumer. The music/CD is only limited by the system reproducing it.

Have you ever heard a true 4 way system where the main signal is broken down by one Crossover and fed to four drivers? This way there is no overlap or absence of frequencies. In my opinion this is the best way to separate the signals. Using onboard speaker settings or amp setting can overlap or cut out some frequencies and thus parts of the music.

Yes, I've worked (as a musician) on some world-class systems. You're right, nothing better than a properly-tuned big rig to make you moist and put a smile on your face. Problem is, we're mobile DJs and have to carefully balance every choice and it always come down to a benefits/cost comparison. I generally like dedicated crossovers but it does add a bit of complexity that in my mind is about as well handled by using an amp with a built-in crossover. I have also seen a crossover fail on a gig (a nice EV unit that I own) so it just stands to remind that the fewer components you can do the job with, the fewer things to go wrong.
 
Crossovers ALWAYS introduce artifacts into a system as there is ALWAYS overlap (that's how the work).

You need to have a small overlap to prevent the notch filtering that would happen otherwise. The trick is to manage the transition zone appropriately based on the 2 specific drivers .. a reason that active crossovers tend to be more versatile as they can have the curves, gains and other parameters set different for each driver.

One technology introduced relatively recently with active crossovers are FIR filters used instead of the older crossover curves (Butterworth, Bessel, etc.). The FIR filters handle impulse signals better and can be fine tuned to the individual drivers. Many of the higher end powered speakers are starting to use them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
Yes, I've worked (as a musician) on some world-class systems. You're right, nothing better than a properly-tuned big rig to make you moist and put a smile on your face. Problem is, we're mobile DJs and have to carefully balance every choice and it always come down to a benefits/cost comparison. I generally like dedicated crossovers but it does add a bit of complexity that in my mind is about as well handled by using an amp with a built-in crossover. I have also seen a crossover fail on a gig (a nice EV unit that I own) so it just stands to remind that the fewer components you can do the job with, the fewer things to go wrong.
Here is where one has to be careful. For the benefit of those who may be lost when frequencies are discussed I will lump the frequency range as 1(Highest Freq.)-12 (Lowest freq). Lets suppose you are using an external 3 Way Crossover and you assign 1-3 to the High Driver, 4-9 for the Mid Driver and 10-12 for the Woofer. Then with this configuration all frequencies will be addressed. Nothing is overlapped or skipped. If the setting on one is tweaked it will conversely tweak the setting on its adjacent/next frequency block.

Now, if you are using onboard frequency setting on an amp or speaker, you can easily overlap or miss out on a given frequency. For example, you set the hig amp to cut off at 3 (you are getting 1-3) the Mid amp is set for 5-9 (You are now leaving off #4) and the Bass amp is set at 11-12 (You are now leaving out #10) Follow me here? This is what I fear the most for those who don't have a grasp on the technicalities of the frequency ranges and how they perform. I have seen it happen where someone was using a conjunction of External Crossover and onboard setting on a Bass speaker. Same thing can happen when bi or tri amping using only the DSP on the amps.
 
Here is where one has to be careful. For the benefit of those who may be lost when frequencies are discussed I will lump the frequency range as 1(Highest Freq.)-12 (Lowest freq). Lets suppose you are using an external 3 Way Crossover and you assign 1-3 to the High Driver, 4-9 for the Mid Driver and 10-12 for the Woofer. Then with this configuration all frequencies will be addressed. Nothing is overlapped or skipped. If the setting on one is tweaked it will conversely tweak the setting on its adjacent/next frequency block.

Now, if you are using onboard frequency setting on an amp or speaker, you can easily overlap or miss out on a given frequency. For example, you set the hig amp to cut off at 3 (you are getting 1-3) the Mid amp is set for 5-9 (You are now leaving off #4) and the Bass amp is set at 11-12 (You are now leaving out #10) Follow me here? This is what I fear the most for those who don't have a grasp on the technicalities of the frequency ranges and how they perform. I have seen it happen where someone was using a conjunction of External Crossover and onboard setting on a Bass speaker. Same thing can happen when bi or tri amping using only the DSP on the amps.

In my main rig, I keep it simple. 100hz gets sent to a pair of 18" radiators. Everything above goes to the Carvin 3-ways and I let their passive crossover handle the rest within their cabinet. After using this rig for a while now I really have noticed the space that I was getting between the driver and horn on a 2-way. The 3-way top gives a lot better presence and punch to the overall sound, but the horn still has plenty of air to balance things out. I like flexibility (and fun of being able to tweak them) with outboard units but really, in my situation, it's just not worth the extra levels of complexity and chance for failure of any one piece. In the current config, I've got 2 amps and if one fails I can have it switched over in a heartbeat. I also keep extra tops and power amp (ceremony rig) in the van if needed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
The best sound I get out of my system in a small room is with one 18" sub and my 8", two way ZX1 tops crossed at 100hz, subs are set 40-100hz. Not saying when I put out all eight 18" subs with a combination of my ten tops I can't get better/great sound, the ZX1s just amaze me. I am guessing if you have a quality and properly crossed over 3 way top with a sub, you should be able to get even better sound.

Ray J.
 
The best sound I get out of my system in a small room is with one 18" sub and my 8", two way ZX1 tops crossed at 100hz, subs are set 40-100hz. Not saying when I put out all eight 18" subs with a combination of my ten tops I can't get better/great sound, the ZX1s just amaze me. I am guessing if you have a quality and properly crossed over 3 way top with a sub, you should be able to get even better sound.

Ray J.
If I was using 8" tops I will send notes to it no lower than 200hz as the starting point. Asking a 8" driver to reproduce anything below 200hz is really putting it to task at higher volumes. To me an 8" top like the XZ1 is better suited to be matched with a 12" Sub in a very small room. That is just me though.
 
The best sound I get out of my system in a small room is with one 18" sub and my 8", two way ZX1 tops crossed at 100hz, subs are set 40-100hz. Not saying when I put out all eight 18" subs with a combination of my ten tops I can't get better/great sound, the ZX1s just amaze me. I am guessing if you have a quality and properly crossed over 3 way top with a sub, you should be able to get even better sound.

Ray J.

100 Hz is a bit low for an 8" top .. and 200Hz as Canute said is probably too high. A 15" top is usually crossed at around 90Hz, a !2" somewhere in the 100-110Hz range. From there I would say 130Hz for a 10" and 150 for an 8. I only have played with the 15s and the 12s, so the other 2 are merely extrapolations, but moving the crossover above 100 will clean up the mid bass a bit.
 
All I can say is you would have to listen to the ZX1's processed at 100 hz, the sound engineer at Bosch/EV sent me the program I am running with the ZX1 and 18" subs in my DCONE. I questioned him as I cross my 12" tops at 100hz and my 15" tops at 90hz and he said use the file I sent you and report back.

I played in a room 30' x 50' with my speakers on the front wall, sub in center and tops spread 25' apart on 30' wall. Tops were 6.5' to the bottom of the cab in the air, ceillings about 18'.

The gig was a 50 year class reunion in the Country Club. First time I played in venue. I set up early and the manager and entertainment manager both asked me to play some music before I went home and changed. They stated they had over 20 different DJ's play that room and none of them had sound anywhere near as good as my system sounded. What was really funny was the dance went 20 minutes over, as the old folks just kept dancing (I say that politely as I am closer to thier age than I am to 30-40 year olds). As I was starting to tear down the management asked me to play another list of 70-80's dance music, I was shocked, most venues when you are around midnight want you out to go home. I played the music and all the workers and the manager were out on the floor jamming.

The manager said, Ray if you have the openings you are now our DJ we have 6-7 events that we book a year (sponsored by the Club and you have them and we will pass you as the prefered DJ to our clients that have private events. I was floored.

Great weekend as the venue is roll in roll out, takes 15-30 minutes to set up (lights take an extra 15). They offered 400.00 for 3 hour shows. They said they would feed 3 people each time and all the drinks were free, of course noone in my group drinks. My daughter who plays with me has CP and a couple of the girls on staff treated her like gold, helped her to bathroom and insuring she had great food and something to drink. Honestly we where treated more like guest than DJ's.

Ray J.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
All I can say is you would have to listen to the ZX1's processed at 100 hz, the sound engineer at Bosch/EV sent me the program I am running with the ZX1 and 18" subs in my DCONE. I questioned him as I cross my 12" tops at 100hz and my 15" tops at 90hz and he said use the file I sent you and report back.

Ray, you're using the passive version, correct? I have a pair of actives and they are really, really good little speakers that match up well to a sub. I'll partially agree with Steve, I don't think the cab will really meet the 100hz line (without rattling), but in my case I used the low-end filter which I'm assuming was ducking everything below 200hz. Sure, it leaves a hole but with a good sub (which you certainly have) you've still got pounding lows and high-end that's clear and present. The ZXa1 also makes a potent little ceremony rig, even just a single one.
 
Yes I have the passive and EV has not fudged the specs on these when it comes to power handling. When I played the last set for the manager I hammered the system, that is what she wanted.

I was using a powerfull amp CP4000, and the subs channel was hitting the 0 db and lightly flashing the limit light and the tops were barley flashing the 0 db light. The sound was earth shaking on the bottom and crystal clear on the tops, one of the songs was Gregeroy Abbot (Shake You Down), managers favorite song and a song that will tell you what your tops are worth. The ZX1 is rated at 200/400/800 and I think they will take that easily. I like the ZX1 so much I will never use my TX1122 (12" tops) in a small to medium room again, they will be used in medium and up room for teen dances, where I need a little more throw and spl.