JBL SRX718s v.s. QRx 118S

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
If I could just talk mommy into letting me get a trailer, I might just shoot for the 728's. But for now with the size and weight factor, I would probably rather have 4 718's than 2 728's.
 
If I could just talk mommy into letting me get a trailer, I might just shoot for the 728's. But for now with the size and weight factor, I would probably rather have 4 718's than 2 728's.

When coupling subs you get a 3 db increase in output. If you got 4 JBL 718 subs with two amps this would give you a 136 db peak. One Yorkville LS 808 sub with the smaller Crown amp will peak 137 db. 4 JBL 718 subs can't match the output of one LS 808.

The cost for this is.

JBL 718 @ $800.00 x 4 = $3200.00
Crown XTI 4000 @ $1000.00 x 2 = $2000.00

VS

Yorkville LS 808 @ $600.00 x 1 = $600.00
Crown XTI 2000 @ $700.00 x 1 = $700.00

Ok, the total for the JBL rig is $5200.00 VS the Yorkville rig $1300.00. The JBL will cost you $3900.00 more and still will not have the output of one Yorkville LS 808.
 
Garret,

I understand what you are saying, but the weight of that unit is just too much. If I'm going to get a single 18" sub, I need to be able to lift it EASILY by myself. Can I lift an 808? Sure. I've lifted 800p's when I used to rent them. But if I can get something that is 79 lbs vs something that is 115 lbs. I will have to think about it, but I'm pretty sure I want the JBL's.

BTW the math is WAY off. It would be 4 subs and 4 amps.
 
If he does see it. Maybe we can both get the EV discount..

Sorry Guys - no "employee discount", but no worries, our products are worth what you'll pay for them!

As far as the QRX118 sub is concerned, it is a great little box and would be a perfect match to any of the QRX tops. The sensitivity on the QRX118 is lower than you might expect because the size of the cabinet is so compact. It is however loaded with our legendary EVX-180B woofer that you will find in all of our highest end systems including X-Line. If you decide you can handle a larger box, be sure to look into the QRX218 - the much larger enclosure will be worth it! In fact, I think Ben @ Northern Light FX has a full QRX rig that was our demo model from the Mobile Beat show....Ben???

Chris - feel free to call or email me with more details - I'd love to help you find the right solution for your applications...

....BTW - we just introduced an active version of the ZX-5! The ZXA-5 is a bad mama! Here's some details...

Electro-Voice is pleased to launch the new ZxA5 powered two-way loudspeaker at NSCA 2007—the new standard in no-compromise audio performance and versatility, in a simple to use, compact package.

At the heart of the ZxA5 are state-of-the-art transducers. To develop the DVX3150 15” high performance transducer, EV used advanced computer aided design techniques to create forced-air, directional voice coil cooling for high power and efficiency. Finite element analysis was used to optimise the suspension and magnetic structure for long, linear travel, providing low distortion and greater LF extension. Perfect for an incredibly wide range of applications, the DVX3150 provides the ultimate in lightweight reliability… but with a heavyweight 500W power rating.

Handling the HF is the ND2, a two-inch voice coil compression driver based on a neodymium motor structure that allows maximum output while keeping size and weight to a minimum. The ND2’s precision phasing plug and titanium diaphragm provide better HF performance, while the integral heatsink provides cooling for high power output.

ZxA5 features an integrated high output, lightweight digital amplifier that produces 1000W LF and 250W HF. The very low noise design includes a 24 dB/octave 100Hz high pass filter for use with a sub, the perfect match being the EV Plasma P2 18” powered subwoofer.

ZxA5’s high tech enclosure uses injection molded high-impact polypropylene structural foam for incredible durability. The enclosure geometry elements have been carefully designed to provide maximum rigidity and bass response. By design, the ZxA5 is also a perfect solution for stage monitors, allowing two angles (45 or 55-degrees) with no additional accessories.

ZxA5 is equipped with three anchor plates for rigging with single stud fittings, along with two more possible anchor plate attachment points on the bottom. For permanent suspension or attaching brackets, the ZxA5 also has two M8 inserts on the top and bottom, two under the handle, and four on the back of the enclosure, for a total of 10. All versions are available in black or white.
 
You won't be sorry about a 218, except maybe for the weight issues you mention. We've had guys returning other dual 18 boxes in a steady line after we demo'd the 218. Most are paying twice as much as what they originally spent on a dual 18, and nobody is complaining (except our shipping guys who have to restock all the returned "other" brands LOL).

Regarding the JBL or EV subs... sorry Yorkie guys... there's an old saying, numbers lie and liars use numbers. You have to look deeper than the published SPL specs and response charts. Those are created by engineers, but published by marketing. I would take either the JBL or the EV over a Yorkville. That's just me and my 14 years talking... so flame me if you want. LOL.

Frankly, I've always been impressed with the SRX series, and the SRX700 did not disappoint. Great stuff, no question about it. The QRX series... well, frankly blew me away. Amazing stuff. I do think it's worth the extra money if you have it... and I agree that new is always the way to go. Granted, my opinion may be skewed b/c we are an equipment reseller... but we often have used or demo products too. Demo is one thing, used is another typically. Speaking of, I wonder if we still have that demo pair of ZX5s. Hmmmmm.

At any rate, we have some GREAT financing options that can help make any acquisition much easier to swallow, and the warranty EV offers makes getting new a slam dunk.

Ben
 
No, it would not. When daisy chaining two subs. The subs will split the power. So each JBL sub would get 1600 watts. That comes out to a 127 db peak. The Yorkville can put out a 127 db peak with just a 128 watts. If you were to put 1600 watts into the Yorkie it would produce a 137 db peak. Thats 10 db more then the JBL for the same amount of power.

The Yorkville 808 weight is 115 lbs and it has casters. The JBL sub has no casters.

The JBL subs come with optional castors, I have a pair. The price of the castors were the same as buying a hand truck. Very convenient as you don't have to worry about having the subs tip off of the truck anymore.
The SRX 715 w/ 718 sound awesome btw. For what we do, these are more than big enough. I did a dance with 700+ people for Xmas and it was plenty loud enough.
 
Regarding the JBL or EV subs... sorry Yorkie guys... there's an old saying, numbers lie and liars use numbers. You have to look deeper than the published SPL specs and response charts. Those are created by engineers, but published by marketing. I would take either the JBL or the EV over a Yorkville. That's just me and my 14 years talking... so flame me if you want. LOL.

Ben,

Every thing I said came from the JBL web site. It's JBL that says their sub has a sensitivity rating of 95 db, not me. It's JBL that says their 718 subs needs 3200 watts to peak a 130 db. Is JBL the liar or is me? Check out the web site, see it for yourself. Why would JBL lie about their own products?
 
Garret,

I understand what you are saying, but the weight of that unit is just too much. If I'm going to get a single 18" sub, I need to be able to lift it EASILY by myself. Can I lift an 808? Sure. I've lifted 800p's when I used to rent them. But if I can get something that is 79 lbs vs something that is 115 lbs. I will have to think about it, but I'm pretty sure I want the JBL's.

BTW the math is WAY off. It would be 4 subs and 4 amps.

Chris,

I'm sorry I was thinking you were going to daisy chain them. So here's the calculated SPL. One briged amp per sub. The XTI 4000 will put out 2400 watts @ 8 ohms. That much power will get the JBL sub up to a 129 db. So if you use two coupled you'll get a peak of a 132 db. If you use 4 coupled that would come out to a 138 db peak. One Yorkville 808 max peak is 137 db. So it will take 4 JBL subs and 4 Crown amps to bet the Yorkie, but it's only by 1 db. The JBL/Crown rig is going cost $7200.00.
 
Garret,

I understand what you are saying, but the weight of that unit is just too much. If I'm going to get a single 18" sub, I need to be able to lift it EASILY by myself. Can I lift an 808? Sure. I've lifted 800p's when I used to rent them. But if I can get something that is 79 lbs vs something that is 115 lbs. I will have to think about it, but I'm pretty sure I want the JBL's.

BTW the math is WAY off. It would be 4 subs and 4 amps.

SNL001_LG1.jpg
:sqwink:
 
Does anyone else doubt the math here? On paper it looks great, but put them in the same room in front of the same dB meter -- do you really think that it would take 4 SRX's -- coupled even -- to match one Yorkie?
 
When it comes to JBL, I never look at their specs. Why? It's usually underated. If they say 500 watts RMS, chances are you can stick 1000 rms to it to get it moving.
I use a method called the Real Feel Thump. The SRX's would bend the 808's over and send them back home to Mama limping. I do agree the Yorkie subs kick serious ass, but the SRX is a whole different breed of animal.
 
When it comes to JBL, I never look at their specs. Why? It's usually underated. If they say 500 watts RMS, chances are you can stick 1000 rms to it to get it moving.
I use a method called the Real Feel Thump. The SRX's would bend the 808's over and send them back home to Mama limping. I do agree the Yorkie subs kick serious ass, but the SRX is a whole different breed of animal.

I can't wait til I have an amp that will match this sub. I've got it on a bridged EP2500 and it sounds great, but I think more power would be even better. I also really need a better crossover... I'm looking at getting a driverack in the very near future.
 
Having used yorkville's subs and JBL SR's and EV QRX's in club installs... all I have to say is the yorkvilles are good but not in the same league with JBL or EV.
 
Does anyone else doubt the math here? On paper it looks great, but put them in the same room in front of the same dB meter -- do you really think that it would take 4 SRX's -- coupled even -- to match one Yorkie?

When you think about it. It just looks like no way can this be possible. But it is correct. Why? The sensitivity rating of the JBL sub is very low and the Yorkville's is very high. The EAW LA 400 sub has a higher sensitivity rating then the Yorkville. The JBL's max SPL rating is a 130 db. The JBL sub needs 3200 watts to get to that level. Now the Yorkville needs 256 watts for a 130 db peak. The EAW needs only a 161 watts to reach the 130 db peak.
 
So to re-word this, you actually think that a Yorkie running 256 watts would be the same volume as a JBL running on 3200, first of all, and then also have the same sound-quality?

I understand sensitivity, but I'll believe it when I see it. I like the quote earlier -- "there's an old saying, numbers lie and liars use numbers" -- not calling you a liar, I'm just saying that just because it looks right on paper doesn't mean it'll be the same in the real world.

Anyone else care to comment anymore?
 
you actually think that a Yorkie running 256 watts would be the same volume as a JBL running on 3200, first of all, and then also have the same sound-quality?

The Yorkie @ 256 watts and the JBL @ 3200 watts. Yes on a meter they will read the same SPL. As for sound they will sound very differant. I love the sound of the JBL SRX 718 sub. I have heard them with a band and with a cd. Both times I have been very impressed. This coming from someone who owns the LS 808.
 
I know you guys want to argue about it, but I really have ZERO intrest in the Yorkie right now. Having rented LS800p's and SRX728's I can say the Yorkies did put out a lot, but as far as sound quality, the SRX always seemed more accurate IMHO.

Yorkie is a great sub, but I would much rather have a 79 lb sub than a 115 lb sub right now.
 
You hit the nail on the head... a better amp with more headroom and faster charging of the power rails will make a BIG difference... so if you're happy now... prepare to be blown away. ;) Great choice on the xover too.. DRPA is an outstanding piece of gear for the price. In fact, it's a featured product in our catalog AGAIN. We featured it a couple years ago and a product usually loses it's "sizzle" after a year or two... the DRPA remains at the top of a short list of "must haves" IMHO. When you're ready to go down that road I'd be happy to help with amplifier recommendations for you.

Ben

I can't wait til I have an amp that will match this sub. I've got it on a bridged EP2500 and it sounds great, but I think more power would be even better. I also really need a better crossover... I'm looking at getting a driverack in the very near future.
 
You hit the nail on the head... a better amp with more headroom and faster charging of the power rails will make a BIG difference... so if you're happy now... prepare to be blown away. ;) Great choice on the xover too.. DRPA is an outstanding piece of gear for the price. In fact, it's a featured product in our catalog AGAIN. We featured it a couple years ago and a product usually loses it's "sizzle" after a year or two... the DRPA remains at the top of a short list of "must haves" IMHO. When you're ready to go down that road I'd be happy to help with amplifier recommendations for you.

Ben

Thanks Ben! I got my CA-9 controller from you guys a few months ago. When the time comes for a driverack I will probably be going used, maybe from ebay, just because of the price difference and lack of moving parts to wear out. They've been going pretty reasonable, from the ones I've seen.

What would your ideal idea (???) be as far as an amp for my SRX? Everyone has their preference in brand, and I don't even want to go there. I'm just wondering if you personally have a recommendation? The XTi4000 was mentioned above, but have you got anything less than a grand? :sqbiggrin: If that's what it'll take, that's what it'll take I suppose.

I should mention that I've got one SRX now -- no plans in the near future for another, but wouldn't rule it out. I'm assuming it would be best to have a dedicated amp for each if I did go that route later on?

The EP2500 has a filter built-in for 30Hz and 50Hz and when I enabled the 50Hz it sounded a lot better and I could go a lot louder before clip; it had been trying to go too low before that. It sounds like it must be a slow curve at 50 though, because it does still hit low. The really low ones just block out though and it sounds good. This is why I want the driverack -- more control.