Trying to mix and get seamless transistions in a gym type acoustics...

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
I am not trying to be rude, or bruise anyone's ego, I seriously am not.... but most normal people don't really know a good mix from an ok mix, or sometimes even a bad one. I have had DJ's open for me that trainwrecked (mashing two songs together totally off beat), and DJ's that were just "ehh" - nothing special.... yet they would get people like "Your ish was TIGHT dog!!" when they were done, usually from their friends, or girls that thought they were cute or whatever.
Point is, you can *think* your mixing is fine, when it isn't the greatest and not get any complaints, or even get complimented on your mixing, because the "normal" people don't really know they are hearing in a mix. They don't know they may be missing a great mix vs. an okay one. Unless you have a monitor (or sometimes some headphones, I'll concede to that) you never really know what it actually sounds like for sure. If you are going off the speakers you are playing out to, it will sound like crap (in my experience). So I wouldn't take the harsh comments about mixing too much to heart. Chances are they didn't have a clue about mixing anyway, and just enjoyed how you played the right songs at the right time. Sometimes mixing doesn't matter all that much as opposed to how and when you play something.
So if a B&G complained about mixing, then they probably knew a tad more about mixing than the regular average Joe and Jane. They probably expected a club-like mixing style, and that just isn't how you approach most weddings.
 
I am listing to my recording - just one goofed transition. Everything else flowed very well. Might make it a FB link when done.... and let ya'll listen for yourself. GRRRRRR :)
 
Ed, your mixes were probably fine, it's the acoustics that cause the anomalies. Even using the Bose system there are still things that will affect the sound and the only thing you can do is try to minimize them.
 
I am listing to my recording - just one goofed transition. Everything else flowed very well. Might make it a FB link when done.... and let ya'll listen for yourself. GRRRRRR :)

If you recorded straight from your Mixer output, then it will sound just as you thought they should, which Im sure sounds great. However, this is not the same as what the room heard given the situation you described with horrible echo and all. I also find it usefull to adjust my mixing on the fly to adjust to echo. In a lot of case, Bass bounces harder than the highs. So I cut more Bass of the incoming than I normally would and do a deeper cut on the bass on the outgoing and slowly reintroduce bass while trying to do my best guestimate of how its bouncing off the walls.
 
Yeah, so my fault for 'bathroom acoustics' yet every other one like that I play gets nothing but raves from the guests and client. Glad it was on theknot vs WW. Would have dropped my score down a tad.
 
You said the bride referred to your "transitions" - are you sure she is talking about your mixes rather than the arrangement of song selections?

I mean, I could make a great mix from Balck Eyed Peas to Frank Sinatra but I doubt many people would appreciate it no matter how nice the acoustics. :)
 
You said the bride referred to your "transitions" - are you sure she is talking about your mixes rather than the arrangement of song selections?


Good point Bob. Perhaps we're looking in the wrong direction...

Could also refer to any talkovers during changes, personality on the mic, etc...
 
Good point Bob. Perhaps we're looking in the wrong direction...

Could also refer to any talkovers during changes, personality on the mic, etc...

While listening to the recording one of my cadavers was trying to get to the shuttle and flee the morgue :D:D:D:D:D:D
 
If I had to guess percentages in regards to what makes for a successful dance floor at a wedding it would be 95% song selection 5% mixing. If mixing was that important my dance floor would be empty and it's not.
 
Well, I was 'bugged' every so often to make that announcement (among others). Thing is, no one really gives a flying flip until they are left behind.

Again, thanks for those comments - great to know. The bride never got back w/ details so I have no idea exactly what the issue was.

But the dance floor told a much different story...... I mean, how many other DJs would offer an almost 100% money back if not delighted?