O/T DLP TV - Repair or Retire???

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
Ok, we've enjoyed having a 46" Samsung DLP TV in the living room since Jan 2005. Still has the original lamp, even....

Yesterday afternoon, the Mrs. calls saying she and our son were watching TV, when the unit suddenly made a loud "Bang" & sounded like glass beads falling inside the TV. The picture then went from color to B/W. At the same time, the one fan became a LOT louder than we ever noticed.

When I got home last night, I replaced the lamp (had a spare) - no difference, so I replaced the lamp with the original one - still a B/W picture & a very loud fan.

Called Samsung CSR this morning - they suggest that it could be either the color wheel &/or the cooling fan....

I've Googled the color wheel & see they're about $125/ea... Cooling fan? Not able to find that yet, but they suggest a tech come out first to fully diagnose the problem(s).

When does it make sense to fix vs replace? As it turns out, the extended warranty expired in 1/2009....oh yay. :)

Any thoughts/suggestions? If you were looking at replacing with something current, what type of TV would you go with? Looking at a 42-46" if possible.

Cheers,

Joe
 
Thanks, Joe.

Since it's out of warranty, if you have a shop repair it for you you're looking at a big fat bill.

After all these years I'd say you got good service from it. The gotcha with DLP sets ~ by the time you've replaced lamps and other parts, you're well on your way to a new LCD or LED set.
 
Thanks Fred.

The reason we got it in the first place? Well, I told my Beloved, that if the Eagles went to the Superbowl, I'd get one... well, we all know how THAT turned out. Yup, we did get 2340 days, or (feeling geeky...lol) over 56,000 hours - I know, it wasn't on 100% of that time, but it still had the original lamp too. ;)

I'm researching now the LCD vs LED (I know, they're not a TRUE LED) but those that in the 40-46" range.

It felt weird watching the Phils beat the Red Sox last night on the 32" monitor we had in with our DJ stuff....but it'll do in a pinch :)

Oh, and when I did call the # that Samsung gave me for the closest authorized repair center? It was a call center & the guy asks "What's your Samsung repair auth #?" I was fuming that now I have to call Samsung BACK, just to get this flippin' # b/c the CSR didn't bother to give me that, just the phone #. For them to send a tech out to diagnose the problem(s) would be $63.... umm - I'll put that & the parts/labor towards a new TV.

Cheers,

Joe
 
well in the last 6x months prices have fallen so much

I would get a LCD screen a 42"
just have a look around - so many out now and getting better


oh and CHEAPER!
 
UPDATE -

We decided to go the replacement route - bought and installed yesterday a 46" LED Samsung - 6000 series TV. WOW! What a difference!!! Watching movies - they don't even look like movies... :)

The nice thing was that we were also able to recycle our old DLP TV at no additional cost.

Cheers.
 
how about while talking TV 400 dollars for a commercial grade 60 inch plasma LG Flattron.
 
see its getting cheaper to buy the big ones these days
 
how about while talking TV 400 dollars for a commercial grade 60 inch plasma LG Flattron.

Funny you say that. Obviously plasma is on the way out. But I was in a store recently where they had a Comcast salesman there. Either he was grossly misinformed, or a flat out liar.

He claimed that plasma TVs do not use more power than LCD or LED. Wrong.

He claimed that plasma TVs are "clearly superior" when looking at the screen. Well, obviously he doesn't understand the concept of subjectivity, as I personally prefer looking at an LCD screen. Plus, who wants to have all that extra weight hanging on their walls these days? I liked that I bought a 46" LCD and was able to carry it myself, and set it up basically by myself. ( Mount it ) My wife helped a little, I admit. So unless you are dead set on having a bigger screen for less money, I see no reason to buy plasma anymore.
 
I have heard they are doomed but this price is very good even if it lasts only 2yrs. The screen is subjective as to comparison to me but Im blind in one eye and cant see out the other lol so the bigger the better and clarity is minimal one to the other for me. Im not that big on TV anyhow but would love watching sports on a screen that size regularly.