RIAA Sues Stroke Victim in Michigan

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
Doug,

So they are going after a person who pirated a lot of music from them. What should they do?

The law is not supposed to "see" the difference between one person and the next, justice is supposed to be applied evenly.

I hope they soak the guy completely just to set an example for the rest.
 
I am not going to say anything about this until I see some more responses, because I have feeling my view on this topic is going to be totally opposite everyone else's in this group.
 
Folks,

The website link Doug posted is biased against the RIAA. It is unlikely that a balanced view of this issue may be presented on the blog site.

The RIAA is a group of lawyers. They are responsible for enforcing copyright law. Violation of copyright law is a federal offense. In today's global Internet world, enforcement becomes more difficult.

Agreed, the RIAA has rubbed some people the wrong way. Yep, enforcement has appeared to be selective. Personally, I don't think the Girl Scouts should be called to the copyright carpet for singing songs around the campfire.

That being said, the RIAA is not actively pursuing DJ companies that work with second-hand copies (CDRs, MP3s, HDDs etc) when the company owns the masters. Trouble for the DJ industry arises when comp sets are mass produced and marketed without permission from the copyright holders, ie DJ Tools and the Promo comps.
 
You guys need to dig deeper into what's going on. What the RIAA has been and is doing is in the same league as the Inquisition.
 
There are points to be made in both directions in my opinion. A lot of points actually. The recording industry in America is fat & bloated, greedy, and kinda evil. Then again, downloading music for free isn't right or legal.

People illegally obtain music, and they seek legal counsel to find out what to do about it. What do lawyers do besides sue? It's all understandable.

Music & suing feeble "stroke victims" can be an emotional subjects, but the RIAA is all business and profits. What do you expect?
 
I am not going to say anything about this until I see some more responses, because I have feeling my view on this topic is going to be totally opposite everyone else's in this group.

I would actually like to hear your take on this subject since you're involved on the copyright owner's end.
 
Technically so is recording a TV show, watching TV on the web, playing cd's at a gig.....

Charging $3.000 a gallon for gas should be illegal. Heck...I bet the gov't does more illegal

Call it the little man's revolution.....for personal use...I don't have a real issue with it....
 
Then again, downloading music for free isn't right or legal.

OK, you're all right on this issue.

However, let's consider the fairness of the RIAA's pursuit of file sharers (not sellers). It stops at the internet.

What about the people ripping loads of music out here in the real world from friends, family, public libraries, etc? You can bet when Apple lifts the security feature from it's files, all hell will break loose between the millions of ipod owners.

They really hurt themselves further by making examples of these online swappers. It just encourages the masses to seek more stealth means of trading.

So now it's like the war on drugs. You make a couple of busts here and there for show, but you'll never really rid the world of it.

Technology is a double edged sword.
 
OK, I don't illegally download anything ANYMORE. Haven't in years. NEVER did for DJ use. I see it as something the RIAA has a right to do if they choose to.

However, I also want companies to be sued and lose BIG TIME if their copy protections screw up my hard drives, or stop me from ripping to my HD at all.

BTW, as an aside, I have been ripping songs to my HD for the last week... 2,000 so far, and maybe that many more to go.... So 2 days ago I was telling my cousin this when she called.... here is what she asked?:

If I send you an external hard drive, can you make me a copy of all of them? :sqerr: :sqeek:

Ummm... No. She couldn't understand why I wouldn't do it as "it doesn't cost you anything".

I don't think I am her favorite cousin anymore. :sqfrown:
 
I can see both sides of the issue, I lean more towards the little mans side though because I'm a little man myself (figuratively speaking, Jon ;) ) .

Illegally downloading music/tv/movies is wrong, 100%. I agree with that. What I don't agree with is suing regular Joe's out the behind, lets face it the RIAA is never going to collect the reward from someone whose only income is a social security check.

My beef is why aren't they going after the big guys, the burner farms, the people who are out on the streets selling bootleg DVDs of movies that are in still in the theater for $10 a pop. You know why? A majority of these people are illegal immigrants, all that's going to happen is deportation and they'll never have the chance to collect.

So let the real thief's, profiting from piracy carry on like nothing is wrong yet have Ma & Pa Kettle loose their home because of their grandkids downloading a few songs. Where is the justice in that?

Again, I'm not saying piracy is right. I'm wondering why the RIAA is putting people who are doing it only for personal use in their cross hairs while the guys doing it for profit carry on unabated.
 
I find it interesting they we continue to avoid the "illegal to play your cd for profit", yet under the same breath: "downloading illegal music is wrong"..

If the man wasn't so intent on sticking to the little man, we wouldn't have the problems we have now...

and this whole p2p/file sharing thing isn't about ripping off the artist either. The man was sticking it to them way before Napster...

...I don't speed either...it's illegal....

Dan...it's easier for the man to stick it to the common man....
 
So 2 days ago I was telling my cousin this when she called.... here is what she asked?:

If I send you an external hard drive, can you make me a copy of all of them? :sqerr: :sqeek:

Ummm... No. She couldn't understand why I wouldn't do it as "it doesn't cost you anything".

I don't think I am her favorite cousin anymore. :sqfrown:

Illegal downloading is a problem but like it's been said it is not the root of the problem. I've also had people asking me to record stuff for them from my large music collection. As in Papas case I run into the same old thing. Why should I let people have copies of the music I purchased over 25+ years for nothing at all? I'm not going to sell it them 1. because it's illegal and 2. it takes time.

But even if they deport the illegal immigrants after being caught they find a way to make it back into the US. So it's a vicious circle that will never stop. The huge labs that produce the illegal copies are the ones they have to go after.
 
Strange... the RIAA has been in existence longer than most of us. Yet few ever heard of the RIAA until CDRs and MP3s became available and computers became able to play music ~ something they weren't designed to do.

As I understand, recording from TV and radio falls under fair use. This battle was fought by Sony back in the '70s when they developed the Betamax home video recorder. RCA's VHS had been down the same road.

I agree that the mass bootleggers should be the real target. And for all practical purposes, they are. But they're mostly outside the jurisdiction of copyright law enforcement. This leaves the end user as an easy target.
 
I was telling my cousin this when she called.... here is what she asked?:

If I send you an external hard drive, can you make me a copy of all of them? :sqerr: :sqeek:

Ummm... No. She couldn't understand why I wouldn't do it as "it doesn't cost you anything".

I don't think I am her favorite cousin anymore. :sqfrown:

Hillarious...

I pissed my nieces off last week, same thing... they don't get it.
 
It's Long, But Here Goes....

Alright all, you asked for it, so here is my take on the RIAA and the entire downloading thing. First, I believe anyone who wants talk about this needs to be educated, and one of the best things you can read to educate yourself is this book Amazon.com: All the Rave : The Rise and Fall of Shawn Fanning's Napster (9780641919596): Joseph Menn: Books@@AMEPARAM@@http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41GFTQRYCSL.@@AMEPARAM@@41GFTQRYCSL

It is a completely non-biased account of the rise and fall of Napster (what started the entire issue).

Now, onto the issue at hand. I will take a look at this from three different perspectives, then wrap it up at the end. First, a look from the artists perspective. I think you need to break the artists down into three groups to really understand how illegal downloading effects them. At the bottom is the regional band, trying to break in. These are the type of bands I work with on a daily basis and I can tell you from behind the scenes, they love people downloading their stuff, be it legally or illegally. Why? Because it gets their music to new fans, which is the entire goal of these bands. Most of these groups are not supported by any record label, are self financed, and do not make many from any form selling their CD’s. They make money by playing 300 shows a year all across the country in bars, and they only way for me (and companies like mine) to get them into those bars is to convince the booking managers that there is a demand for the band, and one way for such a demand is to have people in their area to ask for them. This come about by fans hearing their music, and in today’s world, that music is received 90% of the time through the internet. The more people that come to their shows, the bigger the word of mouth becomes, and the bigger guarantees they can demand in the future.

Up next is the just breaking out artist. These are the bands you see in VH1’s You Should Know segments. Think Augustana, The Fray, Jason Mraz type. This is the group which illegal downloading hurts the most. The reason is because there deals with the labels are not high dollar heavy, and are very reliant on high album sales. They get mid level up front money which comes off the back end (record sales). Normally, after all the fees are taken out (managers fees, label fees, ect), the band makes about $.30 on each disc sold. Which, if you sell a million copies, and have 4 bands members, that comes out to each member making about $75,000. Not destitute poor by any means, but also not filthy rich either. Yes, there are other sources of income as well (merchandise, touring receipts, ect), but the labels and promoters take a major bite out of these.

Finally, you have the upper echelon. The big boys. The Springsteens, U2, REM , Metallica groups. Basically, the ones who bitch and complain the most about illegal downloading, and yet, the ones who are effected the least by it. Because there deals with the labels are guaranteed. They are not based on album sales. (yes, they do get a percentage of the sales, but they still have a gtd. Amount no matter what). Unlike the middle group, who have to make back the advance given to them by the labels (an example of the complications from this can be seen in Hawthorne Heights current battle with Victory Records), the big boys are handed a check from the labels without the back end deals. Meaning the $80 million deal REM has with Warner and the $100 million The Boss has with Sony/BMG do not require the artists to sell X amount of discs to make that money. So the ones who are complaining the loudest have the least to lose in the whole fight. And the ones who are supposedly hurt the most (the indies with no label) have the most to gain from illegal downloading. The ones who no one ever mentions have the most at stake.

But the artists are not the only ones who huge stakes in this. Radio may have an even bigger stake, because no longer do the Clear Channels and Infinity’s of the world have the exclusive claims to be able to break on artist out. Now, with Myspace, PureVolume and other artist sites, it is possible for musicians to bypass the traditional means of getting heard. And Napter, Limewire and other sites like it play a huge role in this.

So where does the RIAA fit into this whole thing? Well, 5-6 years ago, when the illegal downloading craze began to pick up steam, they had to choose which direction to take. They could either become proactive and look for ways to help artists establish a strong technology based presence. Or they could become reactive, and look to stop the craze from happening. They chose the later, which is akin to using a stepping in front of a speeding train and holding your hand out, thinking it will stop. The labels had the chance to buy Napster early on (the book details how Fanning only wanted to create something that would be a way to get new music out, no matter if people had to pay for it or not), but the RIAA discouraged the labels from doing so, claiming it would set a bad example to the record stores. This kind of thinking has only slowly begun to fade away.

Now, my take on all of it. Well, I can tell you right now that I do have Limewire installed on my computer, and yes I use it a lot. But not to steal music, but to find artists I may be hesitant to purchase without hearing full songs first. I will download a couple tunes from an artists someone tells me about, and if I like it, then I will head over to BMG Music Club (of which I belong) and order the disc. I do not download massive things daily to load up onto my mp3 player, and most of the time, what I download is deleted off the computer in a couple of days. Why do I do this? Because most of the music today is crap. The labels are so busy trying to find the next big thing that they forget about the good things they already have under contract. So until they realize that music fans want an alternative to paying $20 for a disc with one good song and 10 filler songs, then people will always find a way to get that one good song and save the money.
 
The RIAA is a group of lawyers. They are responsible for enforcing copyright aw. Violation of copyright law is a federal offense. In today's global Internet world, enforcement becomes more difficult.

Gotta disagree here Fred. Yes, they are lawyers. They have been hired by the producers and represent the producers. They do not represent the artisits.

They aren't responsible for enforcement. The producers are the ones running the show and the RIAA is their hired gun.