600gb of VOBs - Looking For Next Step Advice

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

Cap Capello

Always @ Ur Service
ODJT Supporter
Dec 14, 2006
3,857
4,176
82
Saratoga, NY
www.imadj.com
Colleagues : As a video newbie as of August, 2006, there seemed to be an unnerving number of possible alternatives to the native .vob extraction file format and size. Many such extraction programs and styles were recommended then and are being echoed here as well.

Agreeing with the costs of storage media being quite a bit less expensive than two or three years ago, and being totally confused as to which codec to use and the plethora of user selectable settings within each codec, straight extraction to .vob was chosen.

A crossroads has been reached. The numbers of current resident .vob files has now reached over 500gb. The choices being seen are:

1) Add another hard drive to the existing 500gb ones meaning that three must be purchased (one travel, one office/travel back up, one off-prem back up);

2) Replace the 3 500s with 3 1,000s;

3) Compress the .vob files to another file format.

Understanding the costs and ramifications of options 1 and 2, the focus is squarely on option 3 for the moment.

Is there a recommended conversion program that will allow existing .vob files in existing file folders on a hard drive to be converted to a smaller file size yet keeping the existing already named .vob file the same name?

For example, Adobe Audition will allow for a batch file conversion of a folder's worth of .wav files into .mp3s and keep the existing file name. Is there such a program to batch file convert folders of .vob files and keep/reuse the existing file name for the new file format file name?

If yes, what file structure/file type is recommended to playback videos on a high-definition (HDMI/DVI) capable video card and high-definition capable LCD monitors?
 
Any file conversion is going to take a long time (depending on your computer, as much as 1:1 running time of the .vob file). That said, I'd recommend a freeware program called ffmpeg (http://www.videohelp.com/tools?tool=ffmpeg) with a front-end batch GUI program like WinFF (http://www.videohelp.com/tools?tool=WinFF) and convert your videos to MPEG4 AVIs with AC3 audio. Try to convert one .vob file and see how the playback looks & sounds before investing a ton of time.

www.videohelp.com has lots of information and comparisons of audio and video codecs and could answer any questions you might have.

What are you using for playback (or are you not sure about that, either, after converting your files)?
 
Kayleigh : VDJ4 is my software tool but I'm not sure which mp4 conversion codecs it supports.
 
Cap, Is adding additional drives out of the question because of setup and transportation reasons?

I'm building a USB Drive server out of a black mini tower system. I use PC power supply to power everything internal, including a USB 7 port hub, and then purchased a few of these...."Rosewill RCW-605 USB2.0 to 2.5/3.5 IDE / SATA Cable With Power Adapter" from newegg to connect a variety of drives to the hub. I carry the tower in with all my music on it seperate from the main rig. Laptop in your case if I recall. It just one big external drive case.

Works really well so far.
 
Cap, Is adding additional drives out of the question because of setup and transportation reasons?

I'm building a USB Drive server out of a black mini tower system. I use PC power supply to power everything internal, including a USB 7 port hub, and then purchased a few of these...."Rosewill RCW-605 USB2.0 to 2.5/3.5 IDE / SATA Cable With Power Adapter" from newegg to connect a variety of drives to the hub. I carry the tower in with all my music on it seperate from the main rig. Laptop in your case if I recall. It just one big external drive case.

Works really well so far.

can you post photos of that rig.
thats what I'm talkin' about!
 
Jeff : That is exactly what I'm looking at now. It seems as though the single firewire enclosures I've standardized on only support up to 500gb. That means additional enclosures and drive. A pair of dual or triple drive enclosures with 2 or 3 1,000gb drives eliminates the need to move away from .vobs.

The costs versus labor time in conversion makes it very attractive. I'm looking at triple drive enclosures, built-in power supply, overkill very quiet fans, and with 1394a and 1394b outs.

I hope to have two ordered today once I find which models accomodate 1,000gb drives.

I'm open to suggestions for manufacturers of the enclosures, 1,000gb drives, and where to buy.
 
Cap... try tigerdirect.com I buy all my computer stuff from them, good prices and service.
 
I bought a real cheap Black PC tower that holds 6 3.5 drives, and 4 5.25 drives. I had a 400 watt PC ATX power supply laying around that I hacked to operate without a motherboard to power all the drives, and replace any power adapters that came with the USB interfaces, including the hub. One power cord, one USB cord, plug in, and turn on!

Here's the adapter I chose to use, as it supports 2.5", 3.5", and SATA drives.

AS I read from the documentation, this adapter will allow multiple devices on one interface... "RCW-605 can work with one SATA and one ATA (either 2.5” or 3.5) HD together in one time". Can't say what the drive size limit is on it...

I'll try to post some pictures in a few minutes, but it's still "In Process"... ;)
 
Cap if you decide to go the "do it yourself-er" route and add 1 Terabyte Drives (1,000 gig drives)... Take a look at newegg.com they have some excellent USB 2.0 (fast) enclosures, make sure to get one with a fan built in... I am also unaware of your backup situation, since you have them digitized, would you like to have a redudant data backup... Have you already done so... Knowing you cap (saying this in a ... I know ya voice)... you have already done that :D But if not something to consider a RAID configuration on the external drive while limiting your drive space, while in a certain RAID configuration it would allow you to lose one drive and be able to rebuild it and still have your data. In a live situation, this can be great, since you wouldn't need to carry around your discs???

Also, as Kayleigh mentioned, the conversions to another format can be devistating... "As slow as 1:1" ... In actuality (and you can personally attest using tmpeg) that for a good looking quality conversion, it takes time... Like fine wine as some would say.

To me Cap, you seem to have the right ticket, and my best bet would be a drive enclosure that is going to be durable. And I know you wouldn't want to accept anything less than reliable.
 
Ya, Bounce, 1:1 running time could be optimistic on some systems. I have a friend who said it took more like 1GB/hr to process some of his files. :sqerr:

Have you thought about using something like a SAN storage solution? Some use firewire, USB2 or Ethernet connections. You can upgrade hard drives at will, and some have built-in RAID (Depending on how much you want to spend). I found a selection at TigerDirect.com... http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/category/category_slc.asp?Recs=30&Nav=|c:207|c:2670|&Sort=4
 
Bounce: Just opted for additional enclosures (ME-340U2F) and purchased 6 more with IEEE1394A/USB2.0 capabilities. Sorry, no disrespect intended to anyone however the Windows bus architecture/configuration of USB is less desirable than IEEE1394A. Personal taste rates SCSI above USB but haven't drives made magnificent leaps and bounds in the past 5 years?

Yes, everything in the digitized collection of music, video, and data is backed up...in triplicate.

There's no fear about time in conversion. What is feared is having to use the original DVDs again and having to file rename everything again. If there's a program that will batch file convert a folder of vobs from a hard drive while obtaining the much needed beauty sleep, it would be given a fair assessment.
 
Firewire is basically the same speed as USB 2.0 however are on the right road.

You shouldn't need SCSI for your applications, not only are they expensive, loud, and very bothersome unless you really know what your doing... SATA is a great way to go, you don't have to worry about addressing and those dip switches. Plus you don't need to read/write at the same time.
 
Bounce:
Firewire is basically the same speed as USB 2.0 however are on the right road.
Yes, IEEE1394 is 400mbs and USB 2.0 is 420mbs. Problem with anything USB is it sets very high on the bus architecture. Very processor dominating and resistent to true multi-tasking speeds. But that's another story.

Very very experienced with SCSI. It was really tough to revert to IDE/SATA devices however when WD intro'd the 10,000 rpm Raptor drives, the move was made.

May be an old dog, but I'm hip ! :rofl:
 
I also have a wired/wireles Network storage device that houses a single drive... Has 2 USB ports for external drives... Can be connected via cat 5 cable....
I've also considered using that as the interface instead of a hub.
Concerning Caps last comment, I wonder if this would offset the USB processor issues being seperated via LAN....

Personally, I haven't had a single issue with the drive server as is, other than the power supply fan running full speed, and attracting attention... All in the way it's wired. Hope to fix that soon.
 
And, why wouldn't you consider one of these?

ds1200f_icon.jpg

The website is: http://www.norcotek.com/DS-1200.php

BTW, I took the handles off and used angle brackets to mount it in my rig.

The reason I wouldn't is because my current rack mount gig box weighs in at 80 pounds as is, and is awkward to maneuver through doors, and down steps alone. It really needs to be a 2 man lift. All I need is another gig box addition that weighs the same, but sits lower, to tear up my back even further....:sqwink: That's why I'm looking at the solution presented... Compact, Light weight, and easy to maneuver. I've been able to play 2 videos from this without fail every time.

I'm looking at slightly smaller integrated components that are easy to setup and maneuver.
 
Jeff:

Can you provide more details on your solution? Brands, where you purchased, etc.

Tom
 
Got most of it from newegg.com...
The Rosewell interface is allready mentioned, and will handle 2 drives... I 2.5 or 3.5 parallel, and an SATA. The case was probably cheaper than it should have been, but will hold a total of 10 drives. It's a Raidmax, and did not include a power supply. That I took from an old P4 system I retired, as it wouldn't be sufficient for any new build systems. I believe it was an Antec model 400 watts supply.

The USB hub is a Belkin 7 port model.

Can't locate my Network Attached Storage (NAS) device currently. Possibly no longer available, but there are several better solutions...

Hard drives, I prefer Western digital and Maxtor currently, and more SATA than IDE, but interface will determine this as well... the rosewell will handle either, and both.

It is my plan to create 2 more of these down the road as I rebuild my systems. One for my main system, another for backup to laptop, and a third for archiving. Currently, my archives are still on external drives., and my laptop doesn't get the video files... audio only currently.